43 ms·
World’s Biggest Nuclear Power Plant Being Planned in Canada
- sillywalk 3y agoOver 10+ years away from starting construction.
- evilos 3y agoArticle didn't say that. It's an existing site and they've built so many of these things (typically in 6-7 years)[0] and the local supply chain has stuck around because they've been doing refurbs even now. I think there's a good chance these new reactors are up in less than 10 years. [0] https://pris.iaea.org/PRIS/CountryStatistics/CountryDetails.aspx?current=CA https://pris.iaea.org/PRIS/CountryStatistics/CountryDetails....
- sillywalk 3y agoI stand corrected. I knew it was an expansion of the existing plant, but When I read it, or some other article on the expansion, it said that the environmental review and all the consultations would take a decade.
- mmphosis 3y agohttps://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/london/ontario-new-nuclear-build-1.6897701 https://www.cbc.ca/news/canada/london/ontario-new-nuclear-bu...
- ksec 3y agoI thought Canada was betting on the BWRX-300. Although this one is 10 times larger.
- preisschild 3y agoI hope they will build CANDU 9 reactors. CANDU is easily one of the best commercially available reactor designs available, because it can be refueled while it's running, the uranium doesn't need to be enriched, and it could technically breed and burn Thorium. Plus, it is indigenous and could create a ton of Canadian jobs.
- credit_guy 3y agoI like CANDU reactors, but I like pressurized water reactors (PWR) reactors more. PWR reactors are the majority of the active commercial reactors in the world. The advantages of the CANDU reactors over PWR reactors can be seen as disadvantages, actually. 1. Ability to refuel without stopping the reactor. That's a very convenient feature if you intend to make nuclear bombs. Seen differently, if you want to reduce proliferation risks, PWRs are better. 2. Usage of unenriched uranium. It's not like you just put in the reactor uranium straight out of a mine. You need to process it, if only to clad it in zirconium. You buy the nuclear fuel from approved sources, like Westinghouse. The enriched fuel will be more expensive, but you get more energy out of it. Put it differently, for the same amount of energy PWRs produce less spent fuel than CANDU reactors. 3. Thorium. In principle you can put thorium in a Candu reactor and get uranium-233 which you can then burn to get energy. In practice, this idea was talked about for many decades, but for some reason nobody does it. Including India: they have lots of thorium, lots of Candu reactors, but they don't burn thorium in their Candu reactors. Why? Very likely because of the contamination with uranium-232 which gives strong gamma radiation. But let's say that you do actually find a way to use thorium to breed U-233. That increases the proliferation risk tremendously. Here's an interesting quote from [1] The half-lives of the protactinium isotopes work in the favor of potential proliferators. Because protactinium 232 decays faster than protactinium 233, the isotopic purity of protactinium 233 increases as time passes. If it is separated from its uranium decay products a second time, this protactinium will decay to equally pure uranium 233 over the next few months. With careful attention to the relevant radiochemistry, separation of protactinium from the uranium in spent thorium fuel has the potential to generate uranium 233 with very low concentrations of uranium 232—a product suitable for making nuclear weapons. Your last point about Candu creating lots of jobs: I think a PWR reactor would create exactly the same number of jobs. And now, the biggest reason in favor of a PWR reactor: all reactors have various feedback effects. Some of these effects are negative, some positive. You want to have more negative feedback effects (i.e. passive safety features) and few positive feedback effects (i.e. possible instability scenarios). PWR reactors are the most stable reactors among the current generation reactors. Candu reactors have many of the same negative feedback effects as the PWR reactors, but there's an exception: positive void coefficient. The Canadian nuclear regulator is aware, obviously [2], and thinks this is not a biggie. But when you can choose between two designs, one with more passive safety features than the other, why not choose the first? [1] https://thebulletin.org/2018/08/thorium-power-has-a-protactinium-problem/ https://thebulletin.org/2018/08/thorium-power-has-a-protacti... [2] https://nuclearsafety.gc.ca/eng/resources/videos/player/index.cfm?videoid=void-coefficient-of-reactivity https://nuclearsafety.gc.ca/eng/resources/videos/player/inde...