3 ms·
Only if (1) the proportionality is fine-grained enough to have a 2% party, and (2) the governing coalition is narrow enough to only have a <2% margin And “brin
by dragonwriter 3y ago
Only if (1) the proportionality is fine-grained enough to have a 2% party, and (2) the governing coalition is narrow enough to only have a <2% margin
And “bringing the government down” often just means a new coalition is formed with a couple cabinet seats changing hands; multiparty proportional systems have less cabinet change as a proportion of the cabinet than duopoly systems, though they have more frequent partial cabinet changes. The dramatic langauge may be appropriate with FPTP in a parliamentary system, but is less so in a multiparty proportional parliamentary system.
And, of course, since TFA addresses particularly the democrat-republican-independent dynamic in the USA, a proportional multiparty electoral system is actually a whole separate change from a parliamentary system, and the “a 2% coalition partner defecting can bring down the government” concern only applies to parliamentary systems, even if you adopt multiparty PR in US legislative elections (even for the elections of Presidential electors) it does not apply to the US without the separate and larger change of adopting parliamentary government. Multiparty PR (using, say, STV within states) for the House and even approximately (via the safe harbor statutes) as a norm for Presidential electors is viable by statutory change, a parliamentary system would take Constitutiional change.