3 ms·
I disagree with her interpretation on fair use. Adding something to your favorites is "commenting on it"; inclusion is an implicit comment along the lines of "
by jrockway 15y ago
I disagree with her interpretation on fair use. Adding something to your favorites is "commenting on it"; inclusion is an implicit comment along the lines of "I like this."
A court would have to decide if that's good enough. In the mean time, ignore obscure laws and enjoy your life. The worst case is that you'll get a nastygram. The best case is that you'll be able to make other people's lives more enjoyable by curating a list of good work.
- arkitaip 15y agoThe key word is interpretation. Why would she risk facing the justice system simply because someone else's interpretation differs from hers?
- jrockway 15y agoWhy risk doing anything? If I go outside, I could get hit in the head by a meteor, killing me instantly. But I go outside anyway, because I like to.
- petegrif 15y agoI don't think your position would be very compelling in court. By analogy you could argue that adding a movie to your hard drive is 'commenting on it' because its inclusion represents an implicit comment of liking it. And the courts have already ruled on that. Basically I find it hard to believe that you will get away with copying something by arguing you like it and that's a comment. If you could anyone could copy anything.
- bgilroy26 15y agoI disagree, I think the situation you're talking about sounds like the classical napster/kazaa/bitorrent kid with a ton of songs on their hard drive who is ripe for legal action, whereas the pinterest situation -- even in a worst-case martial-law scenario -- is more like you've streamed a movie to your hard drive from Youku or something like that. The end user, when they don't have anything sitting in their house, is much less liable to be prosecuted.
- rprasad 15y agoThe difference, though, is that adding something to your favorites is simply adding it to a list; copying is incidental. Adding a movie to your harddrive by necessity requires the act of copying. And in the courtroom, that distinction makes all the difference.