3 ms·
Shoshin and shoshinsha (beginner) are everyday words in Japanese, not special Zen terms.
by kazinator 3y ago
Shoshin and shoshinsha (beginner) are everyday words in Japanese, not special Zen terms.
- pzel_ 3y agoYes, in the same way as "evangelist" and "novice" are everyday words in English. This does not invalidate their original religious meaning. Daisetz Suzuki I'm sure was quite aware of both the everyday usage and the Buddhist origins.
- sctb 3y agoNitpick, but this article quotes Shunryu Suzuki—the other Suzuki—not D.T.
- pzel_ 3y agoBeginner's mistake!
- kazinator 3y ago"Novice" doesn't originally have religious roots; in the story of its etymology, it got sidetracked into religion. Quite likely because the only dudes who knew Latin in the Middle Ages were in monasteries, and so they applied Latin words they learned to their circumstances. "Hey, it says here that when Romans brought in a new imported, inexperienced slave, they called them novicus. Let's use that for our newcomers! After all, we make them do chores, like slaves, LOLZ!"
- pzel_ 3y agoI'm going off of this entry: https://www.etymonline.com/word/novice https://www.etymonline.com/word/novice Sure the root word might be Latin, (and so is a majority of European vocabulary), but the specific usage of "novice" meaning "newbie" in English, comes from the monastic orders, via French. Monastic orders, which, in fact, did not "do stuff, like slaves, LOLZ", but were instrumental in preserving (or rediscovering) knowledge and technology from the imperial era.
- thrdbndndn 3y agoSo are lots of other words. Really hate this trend.
- pzel_ 3y agoAre you referring to the trend of desacralization or resacralization of religious terms? This is the dictionary definition of shoshin from kotobank.jp: > ② (「しょほっしん(初発心)」の略) 初めて悟りを求める心を起こすこと。仏道にはいったばかりのこと。また、その人。〔法華義疏(7C前)〕 ※正法眼蔵随聞記(1235‐38)一「或は初心未入(みにふ)の人意得(こころう)
- chimpanzee 3y agoUh oh, sounds like somebody could use some shoshin!
- sctb 3y agoAnd this article is mostly talking about everyday concepts like learning. But there's no denying that the idea of beginner's mind is used within Zen in a special sense. From Dogen's essay On the Endeavour of the Way: > Because practice within realization occurs at the moment of practice, the practice of beginner's mind is itself the entire original realization.
- lanstin 3y agono special sense here, just experiencing things without the sense of knowing the outcomes to expect. just sit and see.
- hooverd 3y agoDoes Japan have articles like "Top 10 English concepts to live by" where they're all just regular words?
- lanstin 3y agoas a Zen trainee, i am pretty sure there is no secret meaning to the otherwise normal words. beginer's mind is just that mind when you have no experience to predict what is expected next.