4 ms·
I'm trying to understand your point. What is fake about those caravans? Those are real people as far as I know, who are going to have a real impact on others an
by carlosjobim 3y ago
I'm trying to understand your point. What is fake about those caravans? Those are real people as far as I know, who are going to have a real impact on others and by others. If such a caravan was passing through your town or coming to your town, wouldn't it be odd if nobody reported on it?
- PaulHoule 3y agoIt's the sense of crisis associated with it and the continuous drumbeat about it. My Uncle Nick immigrated to the U.S. together with much of his family including his mother, his brother, cousins, etc. They wound up around Binghamton NY and did very well in this country as did their children. Today he watches Fox News and it's breathless coverage of "chain migration" and doesn't make the connection that his family is a case of "chain migration" Immigration is quite interesting because it's case where popular opinion is solidly to the right of both elite opinion and where elites think the public is https://theconversation.com/politicians-believe-voters-to-be-more-conservative-than-they-really-are-208053 https://theconversation.com/politicians-believe-voters-to-be... but also that people's support or lack of support for immigration is frequently the opposite of where their "bread is buttered". Somebody retired like Uncle Nick benefits from a growing labor pool which can help take care of them directly and also pays taxes and generates economic activity to support social programs and private pension plan values. People like that tend to hate immigration because they know they'll be dying in a world different than the one they were born in. On the other hand, young college-educated Americans are enthusiastic about it but if they thought critically about it they might conclude they're getting screwed because they're competing with people who can get a college education for much less than them. Overall politicians are constantly getting blindsided by the appeal anti-immigration policies have on people both when it is taken up by somebody like Donald Trump and when they drive support for parties like AfD and the Rassemblement National. --- Again, if you were trying to build an automated filter for pernicious "fake news" such a thing would wind up detecting emotional tones and structural motifs that are common to fake news as the process of "fact checking" is much more difficult as it involves comparing multiple sources and doing very problematic logical inference. If you held real news to the highest possible standard (e.g. in logical inference one bad apple ruins the whole batch) I think you'd find a very high fraction of articles are "wrong" in some way. Hateful, angry and hostile content is highly viral on platforms like Twitter and Mastodon and is harmful whether or not it is factually true.
- carlosjobim 3y agoBeginning from the end of your comment, I don't think that hate or anger is wrong. It is a human emotion as valid as any other, and closely related to empathy. You are angry at the villain because you feel sympathy with the victim. There is a reason we are born with the capacity of these emotions and that they never go away. The same goes for all mammals. Only reptiles lack emotions and will always keep their cool. With that said, hate and anger are very unpleasant emotions, and it clashes completely with the idea of watching or reading the news to wind down in the evening or night. The above is meant about news that makes you angry or makes you hate because they are reporting on something horrible that has happened: Wars, crime, corruption. Not news that makes people angry just by the style. I don't watch televised news, because it is pure poison on all channels. Even if you didn't understand the language the anchor was talking, you feel bad just from the hatred and disgust of the presenters directed at their viewers. It is psychological war and it is completely on purpose. If somebody entered your house and talked to your face in the same manner as the news anchors, you'd think it was an escaped psychopath or punch the person in the face. But people tune in every night to watch these freaks, or even worse - leave them on all day. But back to text news and articles, if you strip out all emotion and just stick to the facts you end up with basically a bunch of Excel spreadsheets for your reporting. This much money was spent on that, so many soldiers died in that offensive, that many years in prison was given to the murderer. What about interviews? Pretty much all politicians, business owners, and other influential people are so well media trained now that interviews have little value. They have endless phrases of lies that sound good to answer any question. This is where the journalist instead will have to inform the reader what's going on and that means inserting some of his or her own views and opinions. And it's good if it's done in a transparent way. It is completely ridiculous how print media today are snaking and slithering around with their words to convince their public that somebody is a bad guy or good guy, instead of just stating their opinion and getting over with it. With all this, I think any respectable media should report on things such as immigrant caravans and immigrant fleets. It's a huge difference between that and the individual immigration that is more common. When masses of people (mostly men) arrive in this way, it is more akin to an invading army, especially when gang members and terrorists mix among the crowds, and especially when they proudly wave the banners and chant the slogans of the nations they are supposedly escaping from. Another aspect is the human trafficking involved with this kind of mass migration. Where is the investigation into the human trafficking lords when their ships sink, killing hundreds? Where is the responsibility of the human trafficker when they've helped a murderer over the border? All in all a huge deal everything and nothing to be hidden from reporting.