6 ms·
Let's have a chat about Java licensing, says unsolicited Oracle email
- TazeTSchnitzel 3y agoI'm genuinely curious what kinds of companies pay for Java SE, other than out of goodwill. Do some of them have frequent problems with the VM, for example?
- blueshirt 3y agoIf your company is selling a product and you want to package the JRE with it, you have to pay for the license
- Nathanba 3y agoit is strange why anyone would pay for the oracle jre when you can pick from one of many implementations that are free. There are some tiny differences in the oracle jdk but just try to swap them out, it should be pretty easy
- tetromino_ 3y agoBut couldn't you package an OpenJDK JRE build with your product instead of using the Oracle JRE, and thus not need to pay anything?
- blueshirt 3y agoProbably yes, depending on the license of OpenJDK, but if you want Oracle JRE, you have to pay
- krzyk 3y agoBuy why you would want OracleJDK instead of OpenJDK? Those are nearly identical. Also is this the case if you use jlink (and/or jpackage)? BTW. JRE is no more since JDK 9, and Oracle doesn't offer it (but other vendors do) - so in case of Oracle builds one hase to use jlink or package whole JDK.
- blueshirt 3y agoMy guess would be you have some kind of safety net by having a company to turn to in case of issues, you probably can request new features, you may have better performances (since the implementation is different) etc... Not saying what is best/worst, it's mostly a matter of opinion / contracts in the end.
- piperswe 3y agoThe implementation isn't different, so there shouldn't be any performance difference - the Oracle JDK is a lightly modified build of OpenJDK.
- SpaghettiCthulu 3y agoWhy not just auto-download the openjdk?
- microflash 3y agoThat only applies if you're using a commercial distribution. You can always use a free distribution like Eclipse Temurin or Amazon Corretto for most of the usecases.
- wongarsu 3y agoMy guess would be ones where the cost of internal processes to change to a different JRE/JDK is more expensive than the cost of Oracle's license. Or where incentives are misaligned enough that it appears that way for whoever has to make the decision. Probably some overlap with companies using Oracle's Database.
- OJFord 3y agoI imagine one case is those that outsourced app development to some consulting firm, get the software back complete with 1y licence (+licence admin fee for the consultant's trouble, naturally) and then just renew it when prompted because of course. Or it's not supplied with one, but when contacted by Oracle the only negative thought they have is directed it at the consulting firm (grr why didn't they tell us about this).
- mrighele 3y agoFrom what I understand, a Java SE Universal Subscription (which should be the one at 180$ /year per employee) gives you the right to use GraalVM Enterprise [1], which has a number of feature not available in the Community Edition [2]. This may be worth something to some, although it may be cheaper to use Oracle Cloud which gives you the same right. (This is assuming that I understood the things correctly, which is not a given at all with Oracle) [1] https://www.oracle.com/java/graalvm/ https://www.oracle.com/java/graalvm/ [2] https://www.oracle.com/a/ocom/docs/graalvm_enterprise_community_comparison_2021.pdf https://www.oracle.com/a/ocom/docs/graalvm_enterprise_commun...
- kaba0 3y agoYou can use Graal Enterprise for free, since a few months ago.
- mrighele 3y agoAh good to know, although I am a bit wary of a license from Oracle that is not a standard open source one :-) (The FAQ says it is free also for commercial use, so I will investigate)
- exabrial 3y agoI believe everything in Graal is now free to use, as of a month ago or so
- ilikerashers 3y ago"Hi there, it seems that you are using a computer. You owe us money" Oracle must really be desperate.
- ozim 3y agoThey are not desperate, from what I recall that is their modus operandi for quite long time.
- temporallobe 3y agoYeah it seems like this communication is maybe more targeted towards non-tech businesses where they wouldn’t necessarily know if the solicitation or inquiry applies to them, since “Java” is and has been bundled with tons of desktop and server software for decades. A tech-focused company would be better-informed and possibly already using openJDK, possibly allowing then to safely ignore or respond with a polite “fuck off”.
- Semaphor 3y agoIt’s hard to tell from the article, but it sounds like these are all people who have existing licence deals with oracle for Java, and this is about getting them to pay more.
- shaftoe444 3y agoI've had these from Docker too, assume they just blast out to companies hoping to get some incriminating replies.
- cinbun8 3y agoCompanies using the OpenJDK should be fine[1]. If you're using the OracleJDK with LTS though, you'll need to pay up. I wonder how Oracle knows which contacts to email. Does the Oracle Java SE phone home? 1 - https://medium.com/@javachampions/java-is-still-free-3-0-0-ocrt-2021-bca75c88d23b https://medium.com/@javachampions/java-is-still-free-3-0-0-o...
- Laaas 3y agoWhat point is there in using OracleJDK over OpenJDK?
- vbezhenar 3y agoSome people feel it's more "original" or "pristine" build. Oracle develops Java, surely they know better how to build it and surely they'll patch it before others. Though at that point I wouldn't touch anything Oracle with a long pole.
- aardvark179 3y agoIt used to have some differences in UI and text rendering because those components could not be open sourced. Now they are effectively the same for the current version, but obviously older versions may differ in the number of security or performance fixes that get Back ported.
- AllegedAlec 3y agonot everything runs on OpenJDK.
- orra 3y agoI wonder what the handful of exceptions are. There can't be many, but maybe they are Enterprise applications.
- AllegedAlec 3y agoI've posted one example in the other reply to my post.
- dktnj 3y agoThis is really great marketing for Microsoft and .Net
- Someone1234 3y agoModern .Net doesn't really have a similar concept to the Java Platform anyway. The Windows-only .Net Framework did, but the last major release of that was back in 2019 (it still gets security updates, but not feature). These days .Net applications are fully self-contained, cross-platform, with everything you need in the bin. Unlikely Microsoft could go after people similarly even if they wanted to. I definitely feel bad for Java developers, Oracle has ruined Java's reputation and made companies more careful around it even if they may not be impacted.
- vasac 3y agoHmm, Java is more open than ever, and the development of the JVM is more vibrant than ever. For over 99% of people, OpenJDK (or any other similar distribution) is all they will ever need. As a Java developer, I am certainly much happier now than I was 15 years ago when Sun couldn't invest more in Java development. Disclaimer: I work for Oracle, but not on Java/JVM.
- backendanon 3y agoAs a Java developer I'm quite pleased, happy with Oracle's stewardship. Tired of the articles and commenters on articles that use FUD to smear Oracle. Guess Microsoft and Amazon are really worried about Oracle Cloud's rise, Java gets stronger and .net still sucks.
- t0mas88 3y agoThis is a lot of FUD around Java with no substance at all. If you're afraid of the platform owners being in your way you should go with Java and not with Microsoft. The JDK is under the same GPL 2.0 license as Linux, which is a rock solid way to ensure nobody can ever make it less open source. Several big players are contributing to Java and due to it being GPL licensed everything is open source. For the .NET ecosystem it's still 99% Microsoft with virtually no others contributing. And it's only MIT licensed so anybody picking it up in the future can do so without contributing back to open source.
- CoastalCoder 3y agoOracle's modus operandi is why I try to be vigilant against installing their VirtualBox extensions. It seems like the kind of trap in which one could easily ensnare himself.
- rzwitserloot 3y agoTo be clear: OpenJDK refers to different things. One of the things it refers to is an open source repository. (a git repo, to oversimplify things). It also refers to a 'packaging' - more on that later. OpenJDK (the repo) is source code, not something ready-to-install or distributable on its own. It's open source. Anybody can 'package' it - compile it, wrap an installer around it, put that on a website. Make some arrangement about keeping it up to date (which may involve putting in the license click-through: Hey, you're on your own). Lets call that a 'packaging' of the OpenJDK project. Packagings come in many flavours. They are all effectively identical, in that it's just a different party running the build script and sticking it on their website. Some _do_ add tweaks (generally, in the form of backports of security patches) but they either don't or these tweaks are in such exotic areas you are extremely unlikely to run into them. Some versions are blessed by oracle as 'LTS' - Long Term Support. In theory this is a made up thing that only applies to one of the 2 packagings oracle releases. In practice every packaging that makes a distinction between support duration follows oracle's LTS schedule. The common packagings: * Oracle JDK - this is a __commercial__ offering, for all versions, though there is a 'developer release' that costs nothing, but __only__ for the most recent version. The concept of a long-term version applies partly to the actual commercial license (in that _all_ versions enjoy long support, with LTS versions longer) - and doesn't apply at all to the dev release, in that the day a new release of OpenJDK (the source repo) shows up is the day the dev release of the previous version ceases to be supported. LTS version or not. * Oracle's OpenJDK - this is a free release for developers that does not engage in LTS anything. The day the source repo has a new major version is the day the old OpenJDK version is no longer supported regardless of LTS. __Hence, do not use this, even though it is the most popular, unless you really know what you are doing__. * Adoptium is a packager that follows the LTS schedule, and is run with FOSS ideas. This should be your default choice. * Azul is a commercial entity that offers a boatload of packagings. Including JREs (JDKs without the dev parts, e.g. without a compiler) which aren't really a thing anymore. * Amazon offers corretto, which is a packaging that they explicitly test on AWS servers. Free, and follows the LTS schedule. In general I strongly recommend you get Adoptium or for AWS-specific interactions perhaps Corretto (but adoptium runs just fine on EC2 if you prefer this). If you do that, this 'java licensing' thing is completely irrelevant to you.
- 3y ago
- prepend 3y agoI think the OracleJDK costs $15/month/employee [0]. Can this be right? This costs more than Windows. Is the idea that only people who really need oracle will run it so they just jack the price up? This is very different from when I worked in Java and the jre was free. I can’t think of any reason to build in java if this is the price of the runtime. [0] https://www.oracle.com/java/technologies/java-se-subscription-faq.html https://www.oracle.com/java/technologies/java-se-subscriptio...
- gbear605 3y agoAnyone smart just uses one of the many different OpenJDK versions, which are free and open source. (I personally use Eclipse Temurin.) OracleJDK is a trap for enterprises that don’t have a connection between the decision makers and the license payers.
- rcxdude 3y agoIt's only the price for oracle's build, which is naturally the version they push. The source is still open, so there's plenty of third-party builds which are actually free. It's effectively an ignorance tax (which is ethically dubious at best), or a very expensive support contract (both of which fit into Oracle's MO nicely).
- prepend 3y agoIt’s more than an ignorance tax as most organizations (mine included) won’t install software without support. Even though the JRE doesn’t really have much support activity, (I’ve never experienced any bugs or done anything other than update in 25 years).
- jve 3y agoWell, one of reasons why I rather dodge the big-O. I wonder if this strategy came after they failed the case against Google...
- dr-detroit 3y ago[dead]
- kaba0 3y agoBefore all the FUD comments appear: - OpenJDK is the reference implementation, it has the same license as the linux kernel, and almost all of the “alternative” JDKs you might have used are all repackaged OpenJDKs with minimal patches. OracleJDK is also like that. - Java is completely free and libre. You can choose to pay for it the same way you can seek out Red Hat for a paid support license. The kernel/OpenJDK itself is completely open-source. - OracleJDK itself has a “freemium” model, where you can use the latest LTS release freely, until the next one comes along (plus one year). - Open JDK is being developed like 90+% by developers employed by Oracle
- mbStavola 3y agoThere have been a lot of really interesting developments in Java over the past few years, however I'm reluctant to actually build anything on the language because of the company attached to it. I don't think I've ever read about anything coming from Oracle which wasn't on-the-surface bad or something that at least makes me side eye them.
- kaba0 3y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36600512 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36600512 These articles are FUD with zero relevance to basically anyone. They build on fear/hate of Oracle, without any news content. Feel free to play with the language, it has improved a lot and the ecosystem around the whole platform is absolutely flourishing. Even if Java - the language - itself is not your thing, there are many high quality JVM languages that can make use of the fantastic ecosystem.
- jtotheh 3y agoOracle JDK 8 includes something called Web Start, which was a cool way of having a client Java executable that would be updated when you reloaded it from a web link. It used to be a real pain to manage updating clients in client-server apps before everything went web. I worked for a shop that had a complex GUI deployed this way. Web Start is not open source, and some of the free reimplementations didn't work. (OpenJDK does not include it).