3 ms·
> I'm not a free speech absolutist[0], but if there's one speech one ought to be free to do, it's to write mean things about a government body (or deals with on
by lelanthran 3y ago
> I'm not a free speech absolutist[0], but if there's one speech one ought to be free to do, it's to write mean things about a government body (or deals with one) in a country that has a constitutional right to free speech.
Right, understood. But it is the right of every company to have the freedom of association[1] to determine what sort individuals they want to associate with, no?
Just because someone has the freedom to say something, it doesn't mean that their employer has to provide a platform to say it. It also doesn't mean that the employer has to allow its employees to disparage paying customers.
Like I kept hearing over the last few years[2], "freedom of speech doesn't mean freedom from consequences".
[1] Much like your Free Speech position, I'm not being absolutist, only maximalist in this position; IOW, no dissassociation on illegal grounds, like protected class members, for example.
[2] Not that I agree, just that it seems to be acceptable.
- ben_w 3y agoIndeed, that's another and more extended example of why I'm a maximalist rather than an absolutist. In the context of the DoD… if people, online or offline, get to them just by swearing, then North Korea should have saved money and developed an f-bomb instead of an a-bomb.
- em-bee 3y agoit is the right of every company to have the freedom of association[1] to determine what sort individuals they want to associate with not when it comes to employees and also not when it comes to customers. employees have a right to share their opinions. and discrimination on political opinion is illegal in many countries. i am not sure if that is the case in the US, but it is in the EU and the UK at least. doesn't mean that their employer has to provide a platform to say it the employer didn't provide the platform. they said it on their own personal twitter account not on the company blog. It also doesn't mean that the employer has to allow its employees to disparage paying customers depends on whether the statement is factual or not. in germany there was a court case that clarified that it is legal and not an insult to claim that "soldiers are murderers" as long as it is not making that claim about a specific person. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soldiers_are_murderers https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Soldiers_are_murderers according to the german court: "sharing opinions to public controversies is a sign of a free democratic order" companies can not restrict the rights of their employees to share your opinion because that would essentially prevent any public discourse about controversial topics.
- lelanthran 3y ago> not when it comes to employees and also not when it comes to customers. employees have a right to share their opinions. and discrimination on political opinion is illegal in many countries. i am not sure if that is the case in the US, but it is in the EU and the UK at least. I said that in the post you replied to. > the employer didn't provide the platform. they said it on their own personal twitter account not on the company blog. They said it while being a paid representative of the company, at an event that they were paid to represent the company. > depends on whether the statement is factual or not. in germany there was a court case that clarified that it is legal and not an insult to claim that "soldiers are murderers" as long as it is not making that claim about a specific person. This was made about a specific person. > companies can not restrict the rights of their employees to share your opinion because that would essentially prevent any public discourse about controversial topics. Of course they can, they just can't do it while representing the company. I'm a little confused about why you replied; are you clarifying my position by disagreement?
- em-bee 3y agoThey said it while being a paid representative of the company, at an event that they were paid to represent the company. it is still their personal twitter account. they are not representing their company on twitter. the time and the location of the person should not matter. This was made about a specific person. that is debatable. i interpreted it as a general statement about the military that the recipient of the message is a part of. i can see that it can be read as a personal accusation, but i believe that this was not the intent of the sender. are you clarifying my position by disagreement it appears that i am. it did help me better understand your position, so i hope that's ok.