3 ms·
Shutting off the good engine after an engine failure is an error that has caused at least three previous crashes.[1][2][3] It can be surprisingly difficult to t
by Animats 3y ago
Shutting off the good engine after an engine failure is an error that has caused at least three previous crashes.[1][2][3] It can be surprisingly difficult to tell which engine failed.
[1] https://www.airforcetimes.com/news/your-air-force/2021/01/21/broken-fan-blade-shutdown-of-wrong-engine-led-to-fatal-e-11-crash-in-afghanistan-report-says/ https://www.airforcetimes.com/news/your-air-force/2021/01/21...
[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kegworth_air_disaster https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kegworth_air_disaster
[3] https://aerossurance.com/safety-management/bua-bac11-g-asjj-human-factors/ https://aerossurance.com/safety-management/bua-bac11-g-asjj-...
- Animats 3y agoOf those, 1) was a USAF aircraft, a 2-engine Bombardier aircraft. Despite the name, this is a small civilian jetliner. "Loud bang" and engine failure in cruise. "Because the warning signal did not immediately light up for the catastrophically damaged left engine — it took several seconds for its RPMs to drop below the point that would have triggered the signal — the crew didn’t immediately know which engine had blown. The pilots thought the right engine had experienced the emergency, leading them to shut it down instead of the left one. The shutdown meant the plane now had no engines operating, and happened relatively quickly, about 24 seconds after the fan blade broke." A restart of the wrong engine was attempted while the good engine was kept shut down. 2) is a well known disaster. "The aircraft was on a scheduled flight from London Heathrow Airport to Belfast International Airport when a fan blade broke in the left engine, disrupting the air conditioning and filling the cabin with smoke. The pilots believed this indicated a fault in the right engine, since earlier models of the 737 ventilated the cabin from the right, and they were unaware that the 737-400 used a different system. The pilots mistakenly shut down the functioning engine. They selected full thrust from the malfunctioning one and this increased its fuel supply, causing it to catch fire. Of the 126 people aboard, 47 died and 74 sustained serious injuries." 3) is from 1969, and is something of a period piece. This plane had three pilots; two in seats with controls, and a third one as "pilot in command" supervising but with no access to the controls. His comment, afterward, was “It is perhaps not quite correct to be ultimately responsible for the safe handling of an aircraft in an emergency unless occupying a seat from where this can be done. I feel, somehow, that had I been occupying either of the pilot’s seats I might have reacted differently; on the other hand, it is possible that had I not been present the two pilots might also have reacted differently.” That strange setup may have been a holdover from the British early WWII "aircraft commander" concept. This was borrowed from naval practice, where the officer of the deck tells the junior people who are actually driving the ship what to do. It turned out to be a terrible idea in the air, where things happened faster. But somehow British United Airways was doing it in 1969. Nobody questioned the pilot in command deciding, wrongly, which engine had failed.
- rpeden 3y agoThe was also the Dover C-5 crash where a good engine was left at idle and the throttle for the failed engine was advanced instead.
- Animats 3y agoHm? A C-5 is a four-engine plane. There was a C-5 crash at Dover after an engine failure, but it wasn't caused by shutting down the wrong engine.[1] [1] https://theaviationgeekclub.com/an-in-depth-analysis-of-infamous-dover-c-5-crash-part-1-the-lead-up-to-the-accident-and-crash-animation-with-cockpit-recorder-playing/ https://theaviationgeekclub.com/an-in-depth-analysis-of-infa...
- rpeden 3y agoYour link mentioned it as one of the causal factors: In this confusion, induced by the rushed approach, they did not catch that the copilot had brought up the throttle for the dead engine, and left the throttle for the good inboard engine at idle power. This made them a two-engine heavyweight aircraft without enough power to save themselves.
- cyberax 3y agoEven more than that. There were a couple of incidents in the USSR. One with Tu-104 in 1961, when the pilot turned off the wrong engine, although in that case, instrumentation also failed properly to indicate the malfunctioning engine. Then there was a Tu-154 flight ЮХ372 in 2010, where incorrect engine failure indications prompted rash actions that resulted in a crash landing. And the TransAsia Airways Flight 235 in 2015 with a very similar story to the one in the article.
- jnsaff2 3y agoThere is also the very high profile Taipei crash [0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TransAsia_Airways_Flight_235 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TransAsia_Airways_Flight_235
- c7DJTLrn 3y agoI realise that the circumstances might not always allow for this and the issue may not always be visible, but if the plane is able to climb up to a stable altitude, why not have the captain or first officer leave the cockpit to go and visually confirm?