3 ms·
They all do it for money, or because of a sense of obligation/love. Soldiers also do it for money. You are advocating that we change this in order to make a po
by yummyfajitas 15y ago
They all do it for money, or because of a sense of obligation/love.
Soldiers also do it for money. You are advocating that we change this in order to make a policy you oppose less politically popular.
I'm just trying to determine whether you are willing to apply this logic in an intellectually consistent manner, or if it's just a political maneuver unrelated to your real motivation [1].
If the possibility of deaths is the justification for tying forced labor to another policy, then there are many government programs we should tie forced labor to - construction, policing and firefighting are all obvious examples.
[1] See, for example http://lesswrong.com/lw/wj/is_that_your_true_rejection/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/wj/is_that_your_true_rejection/
- leot 15y agoThe question a country needs to face before deciding to go to war is, "is it worth it?" The draft, and taxation, help to provide the needed reckoning. There is no comparison, here, to the provision of social services. Or to debt-financed infrastructure construction. War is categorically different.