4 ms·
Are you really attempting to say that going to war is just as serious as public education or elderly care-giving? The gist (which seems to be going over your h
by pyre 15y ago
Are you really attempting to say that going to war is just as serious as public education or elderly care-giving?
The gist (which seems to be going over your head), is that the decision to go to war is not one that should be made lightly. If you don't have any 'skin in the game,' then you're more apt to make the decision lightly (or just be apathetic, letting others make the decision).
Instituting a draft increases the chances that someone you know may die as a result of the decision to go to war. It's easy to make the decision to go to war if someone else's friends/family are the ones making the actual sacrifice. For example, how many politicians are willing to put their kids on the front-lines?
- yummyfajitas 15y agoAre you really attempting to say that going to war is just as serious as public education or elderly care-giving? I'm addressing this reasoning: "In my opinion, it's unlikely that $POLICY is just if the citizenry is unwilling to submit to a draft [to provide necessary labor for $POLICY]." Nothing leot said is specific to war, so I don't see why you are attempting to contrast war to other policies. Also, regarding the chances someone may die, forced labor on construction projects increases the chance that someone you know may die as a result of the decision to engage in construction (to select one particular non-war policy with real physical risks). It's easy to make the decision to build roads if someone else's friends/family are the ones making the actual sacrifice. So should roads be built with forced labor? For example, how many politicians are willing to put their kids on the front-lines? This is unknowable, since we (thankfully) don't allow parents to enslave their children.
- pyre 15y ago>> For example, how many politicians are willing to put their kids >> on the front-lines? > > This is unknowable, since we (thankfully) don't allow parents to > enslave their children. I'm sorry if this comes across as harsh, but this really seems like you're trying to troll me here. "How many [GROUP OF PEOPLE] are willing to put their children in [DANGEROUS SITUATION]" is a common idiom that has nothing to do with slavery. In this specific case, it means things like: 1) How many policitions would be happy to see their children on the frontline? 2) How many policitions would support [WAR AGAINST X] if they knew that their child would be on the frontlines (or killed in action)? 3) How many policitions would implement a draft, and then pull strings to make sure their children exempt? It's a matter of the people making decisions only reaping the benefits, but being divorced from the costs.