3 ms·
Two reasons: 1. The proponent of the new law wants the support of the police union, appear to be tough on crime, and point to his support for law and order in
by dsr_ 15y ago
Two reasons:
1. The proponent of the new law wants the support of the police union, appear to be tough on crime, and point to his support for law and order in the next election. 'Protecting people' -- with a subtext of 'people like you, my campaign donors'.
2. The rest of the legislators are either in on party lines, want to show law-and-order support, or just didn't pay attention. Yes, I'm serious about that last bit.
When was the last time you heard of laws being repealed voluntarily rather than being found unconstitutional? Massachusetts' knife laws read as though the person who wrote them had just been watched a 1970s martial-arts film marathon and called it research. In New York you can sell slingshots that you can't legally possess.
Look at the incentives for legislators: they're not well-aligned with the goals of having a good government, no matter what you think that means. All the incentives are to pass more legislation or to score political points that bear little resemblance to what ordinary rational citizens want.
It's not just Illinois.
- ww520 15y ago'Protecting people' include protecting people from people abuse. I don't know why the politicians think it's a one-way treatment.
- pyre 15y ago> When was the last time you heard of laws being repealed For the most part, laws aren't 'repealed' anymore. They just pass a new law that says the old law doesn't count anymore, making the legal code even more obtuse.
- shabble 15y agoOn occasion I've idly wondered about what would happen if you started enforcing a relatively strict '1 in, 1 out' policy. There must be plenty of crap on the books that either is completely outdated, subsumed by other more recent statutes, or could be implemented as an amendment to another item. Extreme refactoring! (also potentially life imprisonment if you fail a test-case)
- philwelch 15y agoThat's exactly what a repeal is.