In life, people often say unjustified things about people they don't know, and I fear this branch of the discussion is only noise. But I choose to believe GP i

In life, people often say unjustified things about people they don't know, and I fear this branch of the discussion is only noise. But I choose to believe GP is serious, and you might consider that if your best retort is a variation of "but if you got what you wanted, you'd move the goalposts", you might be replying to a valid point.