5 ms·
> I don't see any sign Meta understands what made Twitter great I mean, it's extremely clear that current Twitter leadership doesn't understand that either. Th
by rsynnott 3y ago
> I don't see any sign Meta understands what made Twitter great
I mean, it's extremely clear that current Twitter leadership doesn't understand that either. They're not competing with Twitter at its prime (or at least its peak influence; personally I preferred it when it was a lot smaller in the early 10s) from a few years ago; they're competing with a website that just went completely dark to the public internet and appears to be barely usable even if you're logged in.
- version_five 3y agoTwitter is monetized outrage. A lot had to fall into place for that to work. Of course they need a working website, but beyond that I believe they are way sticker than pundits claim. That unique combination of echo chamber plus the ability to reach across and mock, abuse, or become enraged by the other side, all while having a community, is not easily replicable.
- rsynnott 3y ago> Twitter is monetized outrage. I wonder, do you actually use it, or more to the point, did you pre-Musk? That's certainly a belief people have about the site, and it is certainly a facet of Twitter, but Twitter is (or was) only monetized outrage in the same way that Twitter is cat pictures or Twitter is porn or Twitter is celebrities. It was there, but unless you chose to engage with it you likely wouldn't see much of it (as the recommendation stuff started to break down under Musk, many people were surprised to see porn in the algorithmic feed; despite porn on Twitter being a huge deal, many users were surprised it was allowed because The Algorithm(TM) used to be good at hiding it from those who didn't engage with it). I do think post-Musk that this effective auto-segmentation has become less of a thing, particularly for outrage/political stuff; the algorithmic stuff seems increasingly broken, and the auto-promotion of blueticks shoves all sorts of nonsense in your face. But for most of Twitter's lifespan, unless you were in that world, you didn't really see much of it.
- lnxg33k1 3y agoI wonder if you used it, in order to think that it was not monetized outrage, Twitter for me was like the french revolution, one guillotine a day, without trial, where the population was judge jury and executor
- soneca 3y agoI still use and barely see any outrage on it. I am just selective with who I follow and stay in the feed where I mostly see tweets of who I follow. I agree with GP, it’s very easy to stay out of outrage sight.
- blitzar 3y agoIts even easier when you only get to see a few tweets a day.
- isykt 3y agoIn order to do this, you must assiduously avoid mainstream news as well. I think that’s the point where the two sides of this debate are talking past each other. There is the Twitter you see on Twitter (your customized feed) but there’s also the That that is reported on in the news, screencapped on Reddit, shared on WhatsApp and iMessage, etc. If the sense memory of those non-platform Twitter interactions is stronger than the on-platform ones, especially when it comes to negative senses like hate, it tarnishes the users’ experience with it.
- jonathanstrange 3y ago> is not easily replicable What makes you think so? Twitter has no moat, the functionality is easy to replicate. It's all about the user base.
- carafizi 3y agoThe user base is exactly what's not easily replicable. And trying to "migrate" a user base from Instagram seems like a shot in the foot in this context, even if the whole mechanic of the platform is pretty much the same as twitter, the user base is already completely different
- hombre_fatal 3y agoHaving that community and culture is the moat. Even like things like “ratio” and “subtweeting” are part of the moat if you’re trying to create a clone. However, that doesn’t mean there can’t be a next big thing out of nowhere like TikTok.
- throwaway894345 3y agoIncidentally, I feel like Twitter has done more recently to pivot away from outrage (though there is still plenty of only because the culture of billions of users doesn’t change overnight)—when I go to the “For You” page, I no longer exclusively see the most idiotic representations of the views I disagree with, for example—instead it’s mostly just “big conversation topics”, often still controversial and with plenty of idiocy from all sides, but no longer seemingly designed for provocation. Community Notes is probably the most visible example, and something that kind of opened my mind about possibilities for non-censorious forms of moderation (for those who don’t know, Community Notes allows the Twitter Community to collectively identify and label mis/disinformation—it works by finding consensus among people who normally disagree with each other, which seems quite a lot saner than leaving it to the judgment of Twitter staff and has worked out pretty well in my experience).
- jacobyoder 3y agoCasual twitter user here and have heard about 'notes' but not actually seen it in the wild yet? It sounds moderately reasonable; one of my concerns is that there's so much other upheaval going on that whatever effectiveness it might have will be lost in the shuffle or essentially impossible to measure well.
- throwaway894345 3y agoYeah, I don’t know how you could reasonably measure it and there’s lots of other stuff going on. I was initially pretty “meh” on notes, but a lot of the content that would have otherwise been boosted by algos and endorsed via blue checks now gets cooled off pretty quickly because Notes set the record straight. Having seen this in action a few times, I wish it were around for the 2015-2020 timeline. I could easily see it being more effective than outright censorship at addressing Trump’s election fraud claims or the various claims about policing in America (particularly egregious information a la Michael Brown “hands up, don’t shoot” stuff). Probably could have reduced a lot rioting and cooled a lot of racial strife / election denialism. Of course, this is all hypothetical speculation and I can’t prove it.
- hersko 3y ago
- throwaway894345 3y agoI haven’t had any problem using Twitter recently (hardly “barely usable”). They had a technical hiccup that affected some users, but meh, Reddit serves 5XXs for up to an hour a couple of times a month and people don’t hyperventilate about its impending doom. The thing about social networks is that it doesn’t matter much if Twitter isn’t as great as it was in the early 10s, it still has the users and it’s obscenely difficult to pull users away en masse. Threads can probably carve out a big enough swatch to justify its own existence, but whether those users come from Twitter or other Meta properties (cannibalism) remains TBD and in any case I don’t think it will take enough users from Twitter to sink the latter. All of the doomsday prophesy about Twitter feels a lot like motivated reasoning, much like the smug certainty of the media running up to the 2016 election (and I say this as a someone with a “Trump for Prison 2024” yard sign). I’ve been hearing the same people saying (mostly on Twitter) for many months that it’s a sinking ship and they’re leaving and I’m still waiting for the big exodus.
- QuantumGood 3y agoMaking a Twitter-like service profitable is difficult. To attempt it, you need (1) Network effects (2) Infrastructure competency I think Facebook can provide these faster at a higher level than anyone else who is attempting it. For profit, things that would help include: (1) No need for profitability (2) Profit synergies with an existing business Again, Facebook is a strong competitor here. They can start at #1 and integrate to achieve #2 To get people to switch from Twitter to your service it helps to have: (1) Brand recognition (2) Also be a social network (3) A marketing budget However, I think getting people to switch is the hardest part for any network; it's affected by many factors. There is also the consideration of getting them to switch, stay, and not be pulled away by a future competitor.
- afavour 3y agoFacebook can provide network effects but by leveraging your existing social graph. To me it feels like there’s a risk they’ll just cannibalise social activity on their existing apps rather than create a lot of new activity. Twitter with my Instagram friends won’t feel like Twitter.
- rumblerock 3y agoIf only a small % of Meta's users start using the app, it'll quickly become an audience too big to ignore. Anyone with Twitter clout will have to maintain a presence there, and being there on Day 1 is an opportunity for them to possibly get more clout.