3 ms·

> Their main supposed advantage, that they mitigate glare, is just false. It is very true, contrary to what you claim. The glare on my old trusty Dell U2413 ma

> Their main supposed advantage, that they mitigate glare, is just false. It is very true, contrary to what you claim. The glare on my old trusty Dell U2413 matte display is next to non-existent compared to Apple M1 Air that is hooked to it.

bernawil 3y ago
maybe I wasn't very clear in my point. I'm not saying matte doesn't attenuate glare. I'm saying that it does some, mainly by diffusing it and spreading it around and I personally can't stand any amount of it. It's binary for me: If I get any amount of glare I tilt my screen away until there's none. Another issue is the nature of the reflection. In a glossy screen, the reflection often is a mirror effect that, at least for me, is easier to ignore. Reflections in matte shine up the surface's tiny individual indentations and that blocks more of the screen under it. And what about screen protectors? You can make a glossy screen matte with one, but not the other way around.
- Andrew_nenakhov 3y ago
  That's just like, your opinion, man. It is clear that you don't like matte screens, but it is a far road from your preferences to universal statements like "Matte never made sense at all." Also, screen protectors? Last time I saw one was ~1994.
  - bernawil 3y ago
    haha, oh of course all of this is implicitly prefaced with "In my opinion". > Also, screen protectors? Last time I saw one was ~1994. Ugh, I think you're thinking of those tinted glass things you'd hang on old CRT monitors? Never heard of those being called "screen protectors" though. By screen protector I mean replaceable covers for flat screens: https://www.aliexpress.us/item/3256805177079468.html?spm=a2g0o.productlist.main.5.5c3c5afcC0OOHj&algo_pvid=ddbacf3e-c08d-4c13-b998-24ff8f9fb517&algo_exp_id=ddbacf3e-c08d-4c13-b998-24ff8f9fb517-2&pdp_npi=3%40dis%21USD%215.53%214.42%21%21%2139.78%21%21%402102160416885621066078188d07bc%2112000032748579574%21sea%21US%21781257429&curPageLogUid=uK2oNBhOApdm https://www.aliexpress.us/item/3256805177079468.html?spm=a2g... My proposal for the industry: ship screens as glossy and add the matte as an optional screen protector. Note that before around 2010 this was already how they shipped displays: the matte was a plastic layers that you could frequently peel off. Nowadays, most matte displays have the surface finish done right on the polarizer layer.

bernawil 3y ago

maybe I wasn't very clear in my point. I'm not saying matte doesn't attenuate glare. I'm saying that it does some, mainly by diffusing it and spreading it around and I personally can't stand any amount of it. It's binary for me: If I get any amount of glare I tilt my screen away until there's none. Another issue is the nature of the reflection. In a glossy screen, the reflection often is a mirror effect that, at least for me, is easier to ignore. Reflections in matte shine up the surface's tiny individual indentations and that blocks more of the screen under it. And what about screen protectors? You can make a glossy screen matte with one, but not the other way around.

Andrew_nenakhov 3y ago
That's just like, your opinion, man. It is clear that you don't like matte screens, but it is a far road from your preferences to universal statements like "Matte never made sense at all." Also, screen protectors? Last time I saw one was ~1994.
- bernawil 3y ago
  haha, oh of course all of this is implicitly prefaced with "In my opinion". > Also, screen protectors? Last time I saw one was ~1994. Ugh, I think you're thinking of those tinted glass things you'd hang on old CRT monitors? Never heard of those being called "screen protectors" though. By screen protector I mean replaceable covers for flat screens: https://www.aliexpress.us/item/3256805177079468.html?spm=a2g0o.productlist.main.5.5c3c5afcC0OOHj&algo_pvid=ddbacf3e-c08d-4c13-b998-24ff8f9fb517&algo_exp_id=ddbacf3e-c08d-4c13-b998-24ff8f9fb517-2&pdp_npi=3%40dis%21USD%215.53%214.42%21%21%2139.78%21%21%402102160416885621066078188d07bc%2112000032748579574%21sea%21US%21781257429&curPageLogUid=uK2oNBhOApdm https://www.aliexpress.us/item/3256805177079468.html?spm=a2g... My proposal for the industry: ship screens as glossy and add the matte as an optional screen protector. Note that before around 2010 this was already how they shipped displays: the matte was a plastic layers that you could frequently peel off. Nowadays, most matte displays have the surface finish done right on the polarizer layer.