3 ms·
What a bunch of... Look, don't act like RHEL is the only distro in existence. There's also Debian, Ubuntu, Gentoo, Arch, and tons of other distros. Even for b
by cyberax 3y ago
What a bunch of...
Look, don't act like RHEL is the only distro in existence. There's also Debian, Ubuntu, Gentoo, Arch, and tons of other distros.
Even for boring old enterprise stuff there's Ubuntu LTS.
Yeah, it sucks that RH doesn't want to make life easy for rebuilders. But ultimately building your entire business model on copying the work of some other company verbatim is not a great idea.
- izacus 3y ago> Yeah, it sucks that RH doesn't want to make life easy for rebuilders. But ultimately building your entire business model on copying the work of some other company verbatim is not a great idea. It's an amazing idea - copying RH meant no work had to be put into actually supporting the Linux community and keeping all the profits. Massive margins were made. It's just that the angry HNers think that RH should continue to just give things away to repackagers for free and let them profiteer off their work.
- AlotOfReading 3y agoThe implication here is that people were getting rich off RH's hard work, but who else is rich in the Linux community? The only people making serious money that I can see are RH themselves, maybe Google if you want to count Android. They're earning $3.4B a year in revenue, compared to $140M for Canonical. Everyone else is scrounging around between the couch cushions for spare change by comparison. RH deserves kudos for being the biggest corporate OSS contributor (by far), but I'm just not buying this argument at poor RH can't sustain themselves against freeloading competitors when they seem to be the only ones making serious money.
- tm-guimaraes 3y agoThey were very profitable before IBM (now i dunno if IBMs splits the accounting) so poor Redhat doesn’t make sense.
- mschuster91 3y ago> Yeah, it sucks that RH doesn't want to make life easy for rebuilders. But ultimately building your entire business model on copying the work of some other company verbatim is not a great idea. Indeed. But the thing is that Red Hat is veering on the abusive edge of exploiting the work of FOSS contributors just the same - the "classic" and accepted FOSS monetization way was to provide paid support with SLAs for customers. This work cannot be copied by anyone else, just the business model - but that's ordinary business competition.
- FireBeyond 3y ago> Indeed. But the thing is that Red Hat is veering on the abusive edge of exploiting the work of FOSS contributors Which FOSS contributors? The repackagers? Who are free to repackage Ubuntu, Debian, etc.?
- mschuster91 3y agoUpstream as well. The spirit of the GPL and other FOSS licenses of its kind is that any modifications to a package have to be published as open-source as well if someone publishes a binary package. The reason is pretty simple: when a company makes a profit from using an open-source package, it should be forced to contribute its improvements back to the community in turn. The best example of why that's needed is Apple.
- happymellon 3y agoThe upstream that is mostly Red Hat funded development? My biggest concern is that Red Hat funds so much, so we are at the mercy of Red Hat doing well. I'd much rather an ecosystem of enterprise Linux, such as Ubuntu and SUSE rather than a pile of free Red Hat clones.
- mschuster91 3y ago> The upstream that is mostly Red Hat funded development? Yes, RH (and others) are doing pretty significant work in the open-source space. I'm not denying that. But without the previous work that all the other non-Big Money-funded people did, RH, SuSE, Oracle MySQL and others wouldn't even be in business. > My biggest concern is that Red Hat funds so much, so we are at the mercy of Red Hat doing well. Agreed on that one. Open Source in general lacks decent funding mechanisms.
- happymellon 3y agoIt's not even the only RPM Enterprise distro.
- brightlancer 3y ago> But ultimately building your entire business model on copying the work of some other company verbatim is not a great idea. RedHat's current business model is selling (via copying) the work of millions of other people, then refusing to adhere to the license terms they used to copy all of that work.