2 ms·
Personally I'd love to see no more legacy admissions, but realistically there's no legal basis to change that. There's nothing the Supreme Court can do, Congres
by crazygringo 3y ago
Personally I'd love to see no more legacy admissions, but realistically there's no legal basis to change that. There's nothing the Supreme Court can do, Congress would have to pass an explicit law against legacy admissions.
The reason affirmative action was struck down is because the are certain federally protected classes of people protected from discrimination -- race, religion, sex, etc. And affirmative action is discriminatory along the race dimension.
But a private university is allowed to discriminate along anything else they want as long as it's a not a protected class. They can discriminate on grades (as they do), SAT score, essays, extracurriculars, athletics, geography, and yes -- legacy.
It's true that legacies are usually whiter relative to the general population, but a lot of factors skew towards racial proportions that are different from the general population (e.g. good grades skew Asian). But as long as the purpose of the discrimination doesn't have racial intent (or intent along another protected class), then no law is being broken. And if the intent of legacies is raising money, then there's no winnable case here. Alas.
- stcroixx 3y agoPutting all their dirty laundry out there should be useful towards tarnishing the reputations of the Ivies. If it can be spun that they’re white supremacist institutions, well, good luck to them.
- ashwagary 3y agoHistory of these institutions makes it clear, spin is not required to land the point.
- musicale 3y ago> if the intent of legacies is raising money Precisely. It is the same reason that they give special consideration to the children of large donors. (The main reason universities objected to recent admissions bribery schemes is that they sidestepped the official system and the money did not go directly into the university's coffers.) And it's why they engage in price discrimination based on "ability to pay." As has been noted elsewhere, universities - especially elite universities - are ruthless capitalists.
- TheCoelacanth 3y agoYou're ignoring the concept of disparate impact. A facially neutral criteria can still be illegal discrimination if it has a disproportionate adverse effect on a protected class. Lack of intent is not a get-out-of-jail-free card. Grades might fall into that category except that they have a demonstrable connection to the student's academic abilities. It would be much harder to prove a connection for who the student happens to be related to.
- reaperman 3y agoI’m not sure they personally ignore it, so much as predict that the Supreme Court majority will ignore it.
- aksss 3y ago> It's true that legacies are usually whiter relative to the general population Maybe that will start changing now as/if graduation demographics change.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 3y agoThe supreme court could do something, in fact it can do anything it wants without any accountability at all. That's the system. For example, it could say that because the constitution didn't explicitly state that Hazard could allow legacy admissions, then it isn't constitutional. If you think that's a stretch, read up about how the supreme court defines how 'qualified immunity' works.