3 ms·
1. Win a lawsuit establishing that training AI is not fair use, or 2. Put it behind a click-wrap agreement that provides that it is provided to the user in exc
by dragonwriter 3y ago
1. Win a lawsuit establishing that training AI is not fair use, or
2. Put it behind a click-wrap agreement that provides that it is provided to the user in exchange for an agreement not to use it to train AI.
3. For images, using on of the AI-poisoning techniques and publicizing that fact may encourage people to exclude your content from training sets; OTOH, it may backfire, especially against people looking specifically to defeat the AI poisoning technique in use.
Otherwise, those operating under the theory that training AI is Fair Use will have no reason not you use the content for training AI.
- JohnFen 3y ago> Put it behind a click-wrap agreement that provides that it is provided to the user in exchange for an agreement not to use it to train AI. Such a thing is only as good as your ability to enforce it, though. Are you in a financial situation that allows you to afford to sue Google? I'm not.
- landemva 3y agoSet a price list for this type of usage, then pick a jurisdiction friendly to your cause of action.
- JohnFen 3y agoYour ability to pick and choose jurisdictions is pretty limited (at least in the US). But ignoring that... Having a price list doesn't change the fact that if someone ignores your demands, your only recourse is to sue them. If they have a bigger warchest than you, and are sufficiently motivated, they can drag the whole thing out until you run out of money and can't pursue the lawsuit anymore. This is why such an approach is of limited value in terms of protecting yourself against companies that are sitting on a ton of money. In memory of Don Lancaster, he made a point about this sort of thing: many companies would rather spend $100,000 on legal fees than stoop to paying you a $10,000 fee or royalty.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- landemva 3y agoA small jurisdiction with dislike of USA hegemony may be a start, like .ch or .se. Somewhere with a Google presence and where you host your website.
- dragonwriter 3y agoI was rather explicit that the list was designed for dealing with “those operating under the theory that training AI is Fair Use”. If your threat model is “those only concerned with what they can be forcibly compelled not to do, after evaluating the capacities of each content supplier to resist”, things are different. Which category Google falls into on this is a debate I’m not interested in engaging in.
- dllthomas 3y agoA variation on 1 is to get laws passed clarifying when it isn't fair use (in a way that allows you to exclude your work).