3 ms·
Macbooks had absolutely atrocious performance once the CPU heated up, masked by turboing extremely quickly to make short bursts of performance feel responsive.
by jeroenhd 3y ago
Macbooks had absolutely atrocious performance once the CPU heated up, masked by turboing extremely quickly to make short bursts of performance feel responsive. This was made worse by Apple's absolutely terrible cooling design. Their user-hostile form-over-function designs are also typically Apple. They made great devices for quick demos, but terrible professional workstations.
I actually suspect Apple sabotaged their own Intel-based products when M1 was on the horizon to make performance look better in comparison. Their attempt to basically passively cool an i3 that had a thermal output that clearly couldn't be cooled in such a way can only be described as either intentional or incompetence somewhere in the chain.
With the new ARM chips, things have changed for Apple. Their cooling solution is still worse than the competition, but their excellent CPUs don't need nearly as much cooling. The GPU sucks, but that doesn't matter for most productive use by using hardware acceleration (in select applications, for select formats). You're not going to be doing CAD work on a Macbook Air anyway.
The sad truth is that Apple's competitors are doing worse these days. AMD is doing relatively well, beating Apple in most benchmarks, but with lower performance per watt in the end. Intel is still trying to compensate for their inferior CPU designs by squeezing more power into their silicon, leading to impressive numbers for anyone hooking their computer up to the wall, but terrible battery life if you try to use that performance in a laptop.
I expect AMD to eventually get competitive based on the direction their mobile CPUs and GPUs are taking, but they still lack the production capacity to make a dent in the laptop space.
What I don't understand is why even people working in the office all day every day end up with laptops hooked up to docks and dongles. Even the excellent Macbooks get beaten hands down for cheap by normal desktop components that are available prebuilt with excellent warranty and on-site service for very similar prices. Just use a desktop! You don't have to pick between top-of-the-line laptops and bargain bin desktops!
- throwaway42401 3y agoWell, everyone is hybrid working now, but even before that, a laptop says "now you can't refuse to hotdesk or work evenings/weekends"
- hiq 3y ago> What I don't understand is why even people working in the office all day every day end up with laptops hooked up to docks and dongles. I just need to connect one USB-C cable to get all the devices when I'm at my desk, and I still have my main machine with me in meetings or anywhere else. I also have a dev machine I can ssh into for any heavy process. That does mean I can't work without internet (well at least I can't program), but in practice it's not a problem, and I actually like this setup, at least more than the alternatives I can think of.
- Miraste 3y agoIntel deserves a lot of blame for the last few x86 MacBooks too. The TDPs on those i9s are completely imaginary. Out to lunch. If one were to, say, design a cooling system based on the specs and then receive a production sample that ran twice as hot at half the speed, one would have to do things like downclock it below a gigahertz to avoid burning the user's hands off. That entire generation of Intel chips was a trash fire that demanded a whole car radiator to stay cool just to provide two hours of battery life if you were lucky.
- jeroenhd 3y agoIntel's cooling specs certainly aren't great, but Apple did mess with the power profiles a LOT. People also often misread the TDP numbers (it's for describing the thermal load of a certain performance threshold, NOT the maximum power output of the chip) and that doesn't help.. I completely agree that Intel's chips were consuming way more power than they had any right to, but Apple knew that when they were designing their computers, and they also had complete control over the performance characteristics, so they could've compensated (or picked more appropriate chips). AMD's Ryzen was the proof that Intel's designs were flawed. I suspect that AMD's impressive Ryzen performance spooked Intel and they responded by making their existing designs faster by just pumping more power through them.