3 ms·
> Ahh yes the no historical precedent of gay people existing, forming life long partnerships, and raising children (sometimes their own, sometimes not). There
by rayiner 3y ago
> Ahh yes the no historical precedent of gay people existing, forming life long partnerships, and raising children (sometimes their own, sometimes not).
There is little to no historical precedent for the community sanctioning those relationships as “marriage.”
> Also whose definition of marriage?
All the world’s major religions. Christianity and Islam, obviously. But also Hinduism: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marriage_in_Hinduism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marriage_in_Hinduism. And Buddhism: https://academic.oup.com/book/28469/chapter/229097470 https://academic.oup.com/book/28469/chapter/229097470.
Religions and cultures around the world disagree on many things. But “marriage” being a social structure for having and raising children is an idea that virtually all of them embrace. Prohibitions on interracial marriage, by contrast, exist in virtually no cultures or religions.
And you don’t even need to get into religion. Procreative sex is necessary for the survival of the human species. It has biological significance. Race by contrast is a social construct. Saying that interracial marriage is the same thing as same-sex marriage is flippant.
> Civil marriage in the US is a joining of assets and has nothing to do with love or sex.
Civil marriage recognizes and gives legal effect to something that exists outside of civil law. Why do we have this legal construct for joining assets anyway? For the same reason the law imposes child support obligations or OSHA requires employers to provide restroom facilities. It’s a nod to certain biological realities that underpin human society.
Of course, much of western society has adopted a radically different view of marriage. Most in the west think of marriage as being about commitment between people who love and are attracted to each other. Same-sex marriage is a natural consequence of those beliefs.
But remember the question before Justice Thomas isn’t whether the government can give legal effect to relationships based on this modern reconceptualization. The question he’s dealing with is whether a document written by Christians in the 1700s requires legislatures to embrace that modern conception of marriage.