3 ms·
"And so it makes me feel diminished. It makes me feel, in some sense, like a very imperfect, flawed structure compared with these computational systems that hav
by Animats 3y ago
"And so it makes me feel diminished. It makes me feel, in some sense, like a very imperfect, flawed structure compared with these computational systems that have, you know, a million times or a billion times more knowledge than I have and are a billion times faster. It makes me feel extremely inferior."
Although he did real work in physics, Hofstadter's fame comes from writing popular books about science which explain things others have done in more saleable words. That particular niche is seriously threatened by GPT-4. No wonder he's upset.
Large language models teach us that absorbing large amounts of text and then blithering about some subject that text covers isn't very profound. It's just the training data being crunched on by a large but simple mechanism. This has knocked the props out from under ad copy writing, punditry, and parts of literature and philosophy. That's very upsetting to some people.
Aristotle wrote that humans were intelligent because only they could do arithmetic. Dreyfus wrote that humans were intelligent because only they could play chess. Now, profundity bites the dust.
- kilolima 3y agoThe parent comment strikes me as an uninformed smear. Have you read any Hofstadter? It's hardly mass market scientific summary as you seem to think. And his career was in philosophy of mind and computer science, not just as a somewhat popular author. His writing is a bit more complex than the hallucinations of an llm.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- svieira 3y agoAristotle was right - or else the electronic calculator, the abacus, and rocks know how to do arithmetic too. (One needs to specify what "knowing" means before smiling at the hairless apes of the past).