15 ms·
Goodreads wasn't "the future of book reviews", it was a good review site that might have innovated great new things or might not have at all. But regardless, A
by crazygringo 3y ago
Goodreads wasn't "the future of book reviews", it was a good review site that might have innovated great new things or might not have at all.
But regardless, Amazon should never have been allowed to acquire it -- it was incredibly anti-competitive.
Amazon never wanted to do anything with Goodreads at all -- as demonstrated by the fact that it hasn't done anything. It was a purely defensive move to prevent anyone else from acquiring or partnering with Goodreads, because their database of books and reviews could be used to instantly start competing with Amazon's book business. Amazon snuffed out that threat of competition in an instant.
- sdfghswe 3y agoWhy do you think that Amazon is concerned that a database is enough to threaten their business?
- tivert 3y ago> Why do you think that Amazon is concerned that a database is enough to threaten their business? Didn't the GP already answer the question you asked of them? >> It was a purely defensive move to prevent anyone else from acquiring or partnering with Goodreads, because their database of books and reviews could be used to instantly start competing with Amazon's book business. Amazon snuffed out that threat of competition in an instant. A catalog of user reviews is a pretty important feature for a successful eCommerce site. To the point where I've seen some "review sharing" between non-Amazon sites (the specific case was an eCommerge platform showing reviews from their own site and the manufacturer's direct-to-customer site). Goodreads was ready-made to provide that to a competitor, which would give them a shortcut around that moat.
- mikestew 3y agoDidn't the GP already answer the question you asked of them? Do you really that the question was asked in good faith? I know, I know, HN guidelines, but that question was asked to rephrase the question in overly simplistic terms, willfully ignoring that there is more to Goodreads than a mere DB.
- sdfghswe 3y agoIt pains me to learn that I'm so dumb you can't even conceive I'm asking in good faith.
- SoftTalker 3y agoWeirdly I've rarely bought a book based on reviews on the selling site. I don't go to Amazon and browse for books, reading reviews. I go to Amazon when I've already determined from other sources which book(s) I want to buy. Maybe I'm in the minority.
- dageshi 3y agoAmazon's carousel of books related to the book being viewed is fairly decent at finding books in the same genre you might like in my experience. I have found and read a fair few from that method.
- mynonameaccount 3y agoWeirdly, I ONLY even look at books are best sellers. If I had to wade through books randomly, I'd rather not read a book at all.
- SoftTalker 3y agoI'm just saying I don't really rely on Amazon for reviews. I know what books I want, based on recommendations from people I trust, or sites like this one. I presume that any review on a seller's site is fake.
- andsoitis 3y agoOn Goodreads, the Buy button allows you to buy from: - Amazon - Audible - Barnes & Noble - AbeBooks - Walmart - Libraries
- tivert 3y ago> On Goodreads, the Buy button allows you to buy from: Interestingly, 3/6 of the places you list are owned by Amazon. And all those options are hidden behind a menu. I checked a few books on that site, the button itself is always either "Buy on Kindle" or "Buy on Amazon" (if Kindle isn't available).
- scrum-treats 3y agoAmazon, Audible, and AbeBooks are owned by Amazon.
- sdfghswe 3y ago> Didn't the GP already answer the question you asked of them? You think that to start an Amazon competitor you need a book database?
- tivert 3y ago> You think that to start an Amazon competitor you need a book database? Obviously. I can't conceive of a modern-day online bookseller not having a book database, and one pre-populated with human-written reviews gives you a head start in that area.
- blackoil 3y agoIts not database but customer gateway that matters. If Goodreads has B&N link prominently some customers will move.
- atlasunshrugged 3y agoIt also gives them significant power over authors (and therefore publishers). If you know that a huge portion of demand via Amazon purchases (where many people will purchase your book) will be correlated to the goodreads review, you're going to optimize for that platform. I've seen this before with friends who are new authors that send out their books and their biggest ask is to give it five stars and a good review on goodreads... which drives more traffic to Amazon and creates a flywheel for them. Plus, the direct integration after you read a book on Kindle to quickly give a book a star rating means that you want your Kindle version to be optimized/prioritized not just because of the market of Kindle readers, but because it'll send more traffic to feed into your rankings and therefore affect your demand more.
- michaelmrose 3y agoPresumably if it is effective enough people might start their search for a book on the site and if so why not finish it there? The vertical integration is fairly obvious you basically need a buy link and a way to deliver. With kindle if I understand correctly all you need is the email address required to send to it. If you had enough customers you could work with other ebook reader hardware as well.
- AlbertCory 3y agoI think this is correct. The acquisition was anti-competitive, and Lina Khan's FTC would probably challenge it.
- TheRealPomax 3y agoWhy? The FTC has shown time and again it has no interest in enforcing the rules, whether that's under Pai, Khan, or going back every administration since the Microsoft anti-competition days.
- atlasunshrugged 3y agoIn general historically I'd agree with you but the FTC under Khan has been prolific, not to mention there was recently news that they specifically are going to target Amazon for a large antitrust case and Khan wrote what is considered her most important paper specifically on Amazon. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-06-29/amazon-major-ftc-antitrust-case-expected-in-coming-weeks https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-06-29/amazon-ma... https://www.yalelawjournal.org/pdf/e.710.Khan.805_zuvfyyeh.pdf https://www.yalelawjournal.org/pdf/e.710.Khan.805_zuvfyyeh.p...
- TheRealPomax 3y agoProlific in what, though? Actual fines instead of peanuts? Preventing mergers of companies that at the federal level don't lead to monopolies, but at every local level do? It speaks volumes to how little power the FTC has in the modern day if it still doesn't have enough on Amazon to have forced them into reform on Khan's first day in office. Their business practice isn't exactly a secret. It's not that they haven't gotten better, but "better" and "what they should be" are very different things. One only hopefully leads to the other.
- tzs 3y agoTo be fair to Pai, he was Chair of the FCC not the FTC. He didn't have much say in FTC rule enforcement.
- teamspirit 3y agoUnfortunately that's exactly why so many startups get bought. Not to become part of the parent company's business, no, just not to become a competitor later. Would stronger (and enforced) anti trust laws be a solution? I believe businesses would just lie and say they are going to be part of the business but then just bury them anyway.
- berkes 3y agoEven if they'd lie, that's still a lot more effort and a lot more risk than not having to lie in the first place.
- tivert 3y ago> Would stronger (and enforced) anti trust laws be a solution? I believe businesses would just lie and say they are going to be part of the business but then just bury them anyway. Stronger anti-trust laws would just block many of these sales in the first place (e.g. identify that Goodreads competes with Amazon's existing dominant user book-review feature, and kill the acquisition for that reason).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ljm 3y agoOne version of that even got its own jargon: acquihire. One incredible journey later and the product is already on the sunset.
- fsckboy 3y ago> I believe businesses would just lie and say they are going to be part of the business but then just bury them anyway. That's where my pet antitrust solution succeeds where others fail: ban all M&A. Companies only engage in mergers to consolidate market share, but their market share consolidation (i.e. monopolization) not only decreases competition, but also comes at the expense of employees and customers of the acquired businesses. Nobody wins except the monopolist, and monopolies are already bad, so why help them? (I think of monopoly and market concentration on a gradient scale, from a little bit monopolized to completely monopolized, so don't get stuck on a monopoly being a single entity)
- bryan0 3y agoAnd this wasn’t Amazon’s only acquisition in this space. They bought Shelfari before this and also drove it into the ground.
- scrum-treats 3y agoSame thing with Book Depository, AbeBooks, and Avalon Books. And more generally Whole Foods, Alexa Internet, IMDB, Fabric.com, Woot, Zappos, Evi, Graphiq... When will consumers have protection against this degrading of the marketplace already?
- paganel 3y agoI’m still very bitter about what Amazon did to Book Depository.
- jimmySixDOF 3y agoYou skipped Audible which I would add to the list of give it just enough oxygen to stay alive but no innovation allowed strategies. You can't even connect your Audible account to your GoodReads. Audible is the app I would most like to replace that I use almost everyday.
- Mordisquitos 3y agoIf you are based in the UK you may be interested in XigXag as a replacement for Audible: https://xigxag.co.uk/ https://xigxag.co.uk/ As a disclaimer, I have never used it myself but I have heard good things of it.
- scrum-treats 3y agoWe see this with Amazon Music offerings as well. Focus on acquisition and accumulation, not innovation. For Books, Amazon has (1) Kindle, (2) Kindle Unlimited (... a direct competitor to Audible), (3) Kindle Vella (somewhat of a Goodreads competitor), (4) Audible, (5) Amazon.com (retail), (6) Prime Reading, and externally (7) Abe Books, (8) Comixology, (9) Book Depository. And then there are Children's versions... For Music, Amazon has (1) Amazon Music Unlimited, (2) Prime Music, (3), Amazon Music Free, (4) Amp, and has just acquired (5) Wondery. I'm cool with checking out audiobooks from Libby, and whatever music app opens consistently when I want it to (i.e., not Amazon Music). Support your local libraries!
- crossroadsguy 3y agoI see many startups claiming, and in fact starting their existence with the very declaration or on the pretext, that “We are not like X. We are not going anywhere. We are not for sale” et cetera, I am pretty sure most of those founders would have been spending sleepless nights giddy fantasising about the moment when X acquires them. So now any social network kind of service, which isn’t legally non-profit and open source and preferably federated, doesn’t get any cookie from me including the ones like LetterBoxd and StoryGraph. But the problem is federated services, where you have to “choose” an instance among other frictions and all, are kinda doomed to fail. So I just use the established ones until they are unusable and keep my data regularly exported if it’s worth exporting, that is. It’s just sad.
- lkbm 3y agoTen years of no improvement and gradually getting slower and slower (perhaps because my "Read" lists is now several thousand items), and it's still the number one spot. I've tried a few other places, but my friends use Goodreads, so if I want to evaluate books based on ratings from friends whom I know have similar taste, Goodreads is the only viable option. Goodreads is the present of book reviews, and in the past it was the future of book reviews.
- weego 3y agoGoodreads was the future of aggressively biased people shouting their opinions to other people with no discernable value in theirs over others. Rose tinted view.
- abc_lisper 3y agoCan't tell your post is sarcastic or not. Good reads is a valuable resource, especially for avid readers - without it I wouldn't have read as many good books as I did.
- edgyquant 3y agoI really don’t think so. It’s been awhile since I was on there but there recommendations was the same thing you’d get anywhere (e.g. audible.) Maybe the reviews were better, but I think in general the trend of trying to replace discussing things with people with an automated service or social network leads to a poorer result. I read a ton and have never used a recommendation tool to find them, I just read books, go to bookstores and talk to people about them.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- BaseballPhysics 3y agoYou mean like what you're doing right now?
- abc_lisper 3y agoCan this not be reversed. Force amazon to spin it out?
- biggoodwolf 3y agoAnd who would do that? Even if technically possible, there is no one willing to do it.
- RoyGBivCap 3y agoFTC, if they weren't captured.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- cratermoon 3y agoAmazon's inshittification of everything continues. They also own AbeBooks, have their own cargo airline, Twitch, Audible, Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer, Kindle, Ring, Whole Foods, IMDb, Zappos, Egghead, the late lamented DPReview, and a few others. > incredibly anti-competitive. A description of Amazon in general.
- jzonedotcom 3y agoIn my opinion Amazon’s purchase and immediate dismantling of the vaunted Stanza was most egregious & anticompetitive. I loved that app. And then poof gone.
- cratermoon 3y agoThat purchase would not have been allowed to go through in the pre-Reagan monopoly legal era.
- CobaltFire 3y agoDPReview was bought and saved, at least. So let’s not label them late and lamented yet! https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36409566 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36409566
- jurassicfoxy 3y agoWhaaat I didn't know they owned AbeBooks. I love AbeBooks. I wonder how much of a cut they take from booksellers?
- cratermoon 3y agoI love AbeBooks, too. I started to go there as Amazon's listings got more enshittified. Rather than fixing their product, they just bought the competition.
- RoyGBivCap 3y agoFull disclosure, I'm an author who has self published a few things on Amazon and setup author stuff on amazon and goodreads. >as demonstrated by the fact that it hasn't done anything. There are links between the two. You can buy my books on amazon (the dropdown supports other vendors) from their Goodreads pages. But to your point about anticompetitive, I completely agree. Why are corporations even allowed to just buy other corporations, at all? A shitty bank bought my bank and promptly made everything about it shittier. Why is this even allowed at all? Companies buying other companies is about the most fundamentally anti-competitive thing there is.
- matthewfcarlson 3y agoIt hasn't done nothing with it. Not nearly as much I'd like but when reading a book on my kindle, it's easy to hit the button to mark as currently reading and progress updates as you go through the book.
- garfieldnate 3y agoAs I recall, there were arguments at the time saying that it would be good if Amazon did nothing with it. People wanted Amazon to leave the product alone and not mess with it. And I still feel that way. What would you have wanted them to do with it?
- threecheese 3y agoBetter API support, better moderation, evolution of product features instead of their deprecation, maybe some stack improvements to what I think is an ancient php codebase. Amazon has removed some features in the last year - with little notice - that cause a lot of us to rush and download data before it was killed off. As a side gripe, the “download” they offered was completely useless on its own, and some folks (like me) had to write code to augment it with more site data - which wasn’t available in an API (see above) and had to be scraped. Almost intentionally bad, a json file filled with internal IDs and URLs that anyone with more than a handful of books would be screwed. The feature I relied on was the ability to mark certain books as “owned”, with the specific edition and cover in my personal library. As an example, I have a 2nd printing of The Two Towers with this beautiful cover art, and I could use goodreads as my online virtual library for friends/etc. In good news though, a number of other products are starting to fill that feature gap, but because they simply don’t have the massive amount of title, edition, and cover data (which was community-sourced), it’ll be a very long time before those products will have parity with Goodreads circa 2015.
- majormajor 3y agoThe outcome we got is probably in the middle, badness-wise. Better would be an independent Goodreads with incentives to find features that fight spam and such. But it's hard to imagine them being able to make much money doing that, and them going under would be worse. And honestly I'd MUCH rather have a Goodreads that Amazon does nothing with than a Goodreads that chased growth from VC money or PE or whatever to try to turn into another retail site and abandoned the "your reading history" angle.
- vxNsr 3y agoGoodreads was a profitable business based on affiliate marketing links mostly to amazon. Amazon bought them to save money (basically the profit that GR was making). It didn’t just make sense from a protect our core business perspective it also made sense from a straight monetary perspective.
- rtbathula 3y ago"should never have been allowed to acquire it?" It's very funny the way you put it. Already government has too much power and you want further they take over the economy and do pulls and pushes. Free market means, freely allowing people to trade using persuasions — not government using its coercion. People also often forget other side of the picture. 1. Why don't they attack smaller companies who are ready to sell their companies to Amazon or Microsoft. 2. Why don't they ask government to put people in jail who are buying products from Amazon and making Amazon big? Recently EU also making plans to regulate the battery replacement. I covered that here briefly in my site political-ledger dot com
- canadianfella 3y ago[dead]
- f-securus 3y agoFree market capitalism only works when there is competition. Big companies buying out the competition to limit consumer choices and effectively stall innovation is exactly the things the government should be protecting against to keep the ‘free market’ thriving.
- bobbylarrybobby 3y agoThe free market elected a government with an FTC, so...
- ClumsyPilot 3y ago> Free market means, freely allowing people to trade using persuasions Have you ever heard of market manipulation, wash trading, self dealing, and other kinds of fraud in the 'free market'?
- rtbathula 3y ago"should never have been allowed to acquire it?" It's very funny the way you put it. Already government has too much power and you want further they take over the economy and do pulls and pushes. Free market means, freely allowing people to trade using persuasions — not government using its coercion. People also often forget other side of the picture. 1. Why don't they attack smaller companies who are ready to sell their companies to Amazon or Microsoft. 2. Why don't they ask government to put people in jail who are buying products from Amazon and making Amazon big? Recently EU also making plans to regulate the battery replacement. I covered that here briefly in my site political-ledger dot com
- dendriti 3y agoThe government is deeply involved in the "free market", like when it defends trademarks, copyrights, and contracts by force or threat of force.
- nemo44x 3y agoVertical integration at its finest. They pay the authors to write the books they publish which get sold in their store that they link to from the site they own that reviews the books and pays the reviewers an affiliation bonus. No one is buying books with bad reviews. Brilliant!
- grecy 3y ago> It was a purely defensive move to prevent anyone else from acquiring or partnering with Goodreads I think there's another angle you're missing here - Amazon wanted to stop paying so much in affiliate sales. At their size, they were easily taking in tens of millions a year from all the Amazon affiliate links. Now Amazon own it, they don't have to pay that out.
- mattm 3y agoThis is really all there is to it. I believe I recall reading that Goodreads was Amazon's largest affiliate.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mattm 3y agoIt's not true that Amazon hasn't done anything with Goodreads....they have sunset their API.