8 ms·
A dispute over IPv4 addresses blew the lid off an effort reshape allocation
- josephcsible 3y agoIt sounds to me like this "NRS" is advocating for a textbook rent-seeking system that would obviously favor themselves, just like how taxi drivers' take-home pay is so low despite taxi fares being so high since they all have to make their exorbitant taxi medallion lease payments.
- sgjohnson 3y agoThe difference between IPv4 addresses and taxi medallions is that IPv4 addresses are a finite resource and taxi medallions are an outright scam.
- Retric 3y agoMedallions cover various externalities. You need to go back before they where introduced and see why almost every major city added them.
- sgjohnson 3y agoCounterargument: virtually no Uber has a medallion.
- nunuvit 3y agoMedallions artificially restricted supply so that drivers could reliably earn a living. Does Uber achieve that goal?
- josephcsible 3y agoBut medallions don't actually do that, because all of the extra revenue that drivers get due to the limited supply, and then some, gets paid out as rent for the medallion.
- nunuvit 3y agoHow can you have extra revenue if you're not earning a living?
- josephcsible 3y agoI'm saying the increase in pay due to medallions restricting the supply of drivers is less than the decrease in pay due to having to make payments to keep the medallion, so they'd be able to earn even more of a living without that system.
- nunuvit 3y agoI agree with you that it sucks, and I don't see any disagreement with what I said. Again, the medallion only goes as far as ensuring that all drivers get a sustainable wage. Ride share has driver attrition because they don't. Whether it's a fair system is a different question.
- josephcsible 3y ago> Again, the medallion only goes as far as ensuring that all drivers get a sustainable wage. I'm saying that no, it doesn't do that. Taxi drivers are staying afloat despite medallions, not because of them.
- nunuvit 3y agoThe purpose of the medallion is to create a guild. In practice, the coexistence of ride-sharing defeats that purpose, subjecting all drivers to the risk of unlivable wages, and penalizing guild members with dues.
- josephcsible 3y agoEven before Uber and Lyft existed, taxi medallions didn't accomplish their goal.
- Qwertious 3y agoUber drivers aren't strictly speaking taxi drivers, in that they don't actively drive around looking for fares but instead wait for users to contact them via app - in other words, they're pull-based and not push-based. Medallions were a response to the push-based taxi market, which was 100% necessary as smartphones didn't exist in the 1930s.
- Xelbair 3y agoThe core issue is that they are unnecessary now.
- colonwqbang 3y agoWhat kind of externalities do you mean? The Wikipedia page is completely silent and I didn't find anything with a quick googling.
- zokier 3y agoI think its less rent-seeking and more colonialism; trying to extract African ipv4 resources to better paying foreign clients. Afrinic was allocated those addresses in some modicum of fairness even if Africas internet infrastructure is not yet in state to fully utilize them, and now this NRS seeks to undo that. This is problematic because if the addresses are strip-mined from Africa it makes developing that internet infrastructure there even more difficult.
- gbil 3y agoThis. NRS seems to be stepping on some regional situation in order to get the big profit with whatever consequences this might have for the development of the region. At the same time I doubt they can go the same way in other regions, like in Asia with APNIC
- supriyo-biswas 3y agoContext: https://mybroadband.co.za/news/internet/318205-the-big-south-african-ip-address-heist-how-millions-are-made-on-the-grey-market.html https://mybroadband.co.za/news/internet/318205-the-big-south...
- ajsnigrutin 3y ago2023, year of the IPv6 for residential users? :)
- zapdrive 3y agoYou wish! The ISPs will not do it until mandated by the government. Petition your representative to push for mandated IPV6 adoption.
- austin-cheney 3y agoMy ISP, AT&T, is IPv6 to the house.
- eppp 3y agoAnd yet I bet you still have an ipv4 address too and half your things attached to your wifi dont support ipv6.
- zapdrive 3y agoIf every ISP had an IPV6 to the house/mobile, we wouldn't be having this debate. The argument is for the ISPs who still don't have it.
- eppp 3y agoISPs have ipv4 because our customers want to get to sites that are ipv4 only. We can't just tell them "oops we dont support ipv4 sites anymore" The fix the content side and the isps will migrate.
- viraptor 3y agoGetting an ipv6 address doesn't mean you lose your ipv4. You can use both at the same time. (And even if you don't, you can still proxy the traffic to ipv4 networks - mobile networks do it)
- sgjohnson 3y agoI wouldn’t even be opposed to this. It would perhaps be just another nail in IPv4’s coffin, and we can’t have too many of those. Full disclosure: I do have skin in this game. I have a /32 and several /40s of IPv6 and no IPv4 at all. For a hobbyist IPv4 is already prohibitively expensive. $14k for a /24? Miss me with that bullcrap.
- 5d41402abc4b 3y agoHow do you buy an IPv6 address?
- Qwertious 3y agoAFAICT, the answer is that you don't buy an IPv6 address. You're not even supposed to buy an IPv4 address, but a market for IPv4 addresses sprung up due to their scarcity. Now, I'm not trying to be pedantic here. To obtain an IPv6 address, you need to be allocated one. And that's the job of your ISP, apparently. Which kind of makes sense since 1) that's how your home computer gets an IPv4 address (a dynamic one, these days), and 2) unless your ISP supports IPv6 you'll need to set up some sort of IPv6-over-IPv4 tunnel anyway. Now, you may say "oh dear god are there any options that don't involve my ISP", and, well, good luck: https://www.apnic.net/get-ip/get-ip-addresses-asn/ https://www.apnic.net/get-ip/get-ip-addresses-asn/ By default when you're allocated an IPv6 address you get at least a /96 block and thus you'll never run out of sub-addresses, so you really only need one.
- AndroidKitKat 3y agoI investigated and even begun the process of getting an IPv6 allocation from ARIN, but after setting up an LLC in my state ($300 + annual fees) and then jumping through the hoops ARIN (usually involved paying a fee or two), I eventually gave up just due to how much money it seemingly was going to take. The final straw for me was proving that I was going to acquire some % of address utilization or be a multi-homed site (would have required getting a second ISP to my residence, I believe?). I just didn't have the willpower (or wallet) to see it through. I was merely doing it for fun and burning a bunch of money for addresses that I would barely use didn't sound fun after thinking about it. Still, it was fun chatting with my friends on IRC about it and it is a very interesting icebreaker!
- swinglock 3y agoIPv4, the original decentralized Internet currency. Just get on IPv6 already! These numbers wouldn't be worth enough to fight over if we just upgrade.
- sgjohnson 3y ago> decentralized The internet might be entirely decentralized, but IP address allocations are very centralized.
- swinglock 3y ago> AFRINIC is one of the world's five regional internet registries, or RIRs: AFRINIC; Asia-Pacific's APNIC; North America’s ARIN; Europe’s RIPE; and Latin America’s LACNIC. These are the organizations that manage, allocate, and track the use of internet number resources – IP addresses and autonomous system numbers. Which one is the central authority?
- autoexec 3y agoThe Number Resources Organization is the body which represents the regional internet registries. You could maybe consider that to be the central authority, but when you're talking IP addresses, IANA is the central authority.
- sgjohnson 3y agoThe one assigning numbers to the five regional authorities. That would be IANA. And even if there was no IANA, the 5 regional authorities would still very much be centralized.
- zapdrive 3y agoThe ISPs dragging their feet on IPV6 implementation are the biggest culprits in holding back progress. Western governments should step in and mandate IPV6 adoption for ISPs
- eppp 3y agoNo, we keep being required to have ipv4 so our customers can reach the sites they are trying to get to. If it was just as simple as deploying ipv6 and retiring ipv4 we would have done it already. But someone just had to make them not interoperable.
- Dagger2 3y agoThey're not non-interoperable though? My desktop has no v4 and it has no trouble reaching any sites.
- eppp 3y agoThere are still massive amounts of consumer grade equipment that have no ability to deal with ipv6 addresses. How much modern iot stuff even supports it?
- Dagger2 3y agoYes, and that's unfortunate, but it's not because "someone just had to make them not interoperable", it's because v6 addresses are bigger than v4 addresses and so can't fit into the same APIs/fields/data types, which means new APIs etc are required. It's not v6's fault that people refuse to stop using the old ones.
- eppp 3y agoNo its the fault of the architectural astronauts that decided to reinvent the whole thing instead of slowly phasing in the changes needed to add more addresses.
- stravant 3y agoPutting a price on IPV4 would be great. Actual monetary incentive for people to finally make IPV6 work.
- zapdrive 3y agoAnd at the same time incentivise IPV4 horders to delay IPV6 adoption. Since biggest ISPs are also biggest IPV4 owners, they are not going to devalue their holdings until mandated by the government. Why is FCC not acting and forcing ISPs to adopt IPV6? All modern equipment manufactured in the last 15 years supports dual stack. I doubt there's a huge percentage of routers/switches currently running that are older than 15 years. There is practically zero reason to not have dual stack, other than the obvious anti-competitive practices.
- Sankozi 3y agoAre ISPs IP owners? I think they should be one of the main payers in this scheme. Question is who should get the money. Definitely not the companies currently having IP assigned.
- afiori 3y agoThe only way to manage scarce bounded resources fairly is with georgist taxation https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgism https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Georgism
- the_mitsuhiko 3y agoConsidering the uneven distribution of IPv4 addresses I have doubts that this would play out in a healthy way.
- danpalmer 3y agoThere is already a price, which is often significant given the lack of supply. I've read about several ISPs moving to IPv6 explicitly due to cost, and mobile carriers are well known to use v6 only (with gateways) to grow their market.
- DeathArrow 3y ago
- PhilipRoman 3y agoIt amazes me that ipv4 addresses are still so cheap. Shouldn't they cost thousands of dollars per each address by now? It seems that the current price is roughly 50$
- zapdrive 3y agoAre you kidding? 50$ per address is cheap? These should be practically free! 50 is infinitely bigger than 0. IP address is just a number! There's no reason to charge money for a number. If you are out of numbers, make more numbers. There's an infinite amount of numbers. What's next? 1000$ per social security number, because we are running out of 9 digit numbers?
- cassianoleal 3y agoThat's obviously wrong. > IP address is just a number No it's not. It's exactly 4 octets. No more, no less. Which takes me to the next point. > If you are out of numbers, make more numbers You can't make more numbers and expect all systems that assume 4 octets to work. That's how we ended with IPv6, which actually provides us with a near-infinite amount of "numbers" as you call them. Mind you, they're still quite finite though - their numbers are just really really big. > There's an infinite amount of numbers No, and that's why they cost - scarcity. You could try to argue that it's an artificial scarcity, but the most likely answer is just that they never thought they'd need as many addresses as we've realised since.
- stock_toaster 3y ago4 octets is just the most common representation. https://www.hacksparrow.com/networking/many-faces-of-ip-address.html https://www.hacksparrow.com/networking/many-faces-of-ip-addr...
- cassianoleal 3y agoThis is a very thin hair you're splitting. :)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- belorn 3y agoWhat would happen to the contract between Cloud Innovation and AFRINIC if AFRINIC collapse? Since ICANN assigned AFRINIC to manage those ipv4 addresses, it seems logical to me that the contract between ICANN and AFRINIC would stop if AFRINIC is unable to fulfill that role.
- jmyeet 3y agoI will never stop being angry at the colossal screw up that is IPv6. Why? Because it literally had to solve one, and only one, problem: address space. All the other crap they did was completely unnecessary and nobody cares about it. Imagine if IPv6 had simply said: - An IPv6 address is simply an IPv4 address plus 2 or 4 octets - An IPv4 device would simply get routed an IPv6 address based on the IPv4 "prefix" We'd have a clear path forward with some level of backwards compatibility and this would've been over decades ago.
- Xelbair 3y agoThey did solve one more problem that leads to performance boost. IPv4 header contains checksum field which must be recalculated on each network hop, as the addresses change with each one. Other than that? i agree. IPv6 is an disaster, and it wouldn't be so if we moved early - but there were no incentives at all to move early.
- georgyo 3y agoIn your world, I have a service that speaks only ip4v2 and a client that speaks ip4v1. How does my packet get there? Everything in between me and them needs to understand how to handle this conversation. Old routers and switches may drop or misroute packets. What about prefixes. The vast majority of ipv4 has been allocated. It we just have more octets then we haven't actually made more available allocations because they will be under already assigned prefixes. The smallest globally routable allocations in ipv4 is a /24. Routing hardware has a limit on the number of prefixes it can route. Just changing that to a smaller size would ease pressure, but even that is impossible without upgrading all switching infrastructure to handle the space. The next version of IP was always going to be a brand new protocol. There wasn't even a realistic option besides that.
- jmyeet 3y agoThe point of an IP4v2 (to borrow your naming convention) address is that because it's prefixed with an IP4v1 address, then it can still get somewhere useful if an intervening router or even the destination gateway doesn't understand IP4v2. Think of IP4v2 as essentially embedding a NAT field into the IP header. This might work or it might not in any given circumstance but the path to make it work is a lot more straightforward. As for the routing table size issue, it's not really an issue at all. Assuming extra octets, a /24 block holds 16M addresses instead of 256 (or 254 realistically). You don't need a larger routing table. This would also allow an organization that might've had a /16 or /8 block or multiple blocks to get by with 1 (or a few) /24 blocks, allowing you to reclaim blocks without making external routing tables any larger.
- TDiblik 3y agoHey, recentlly wrote a little site that could be relevant here (ip-atlas.tomasdiblik.cz), basically, I download ip2asn list and list how many IPs (4s and 6es) are not routed yet and how many are owned by which entity (and what ranges). Idk it was an interesting weekend project :D (Although, I was kinda suprised that percentage-wise, number of IPv6 and IP4 is nearly identical, makes you wonder wether companies should own HUNDREDS OF MILIONS of IPv6es) PS: The site can get laggy on low end devices, because of the number of records (sorry :(, but I didn't want to spend too much time on this project)
- reincoder 3y agoA look into inter-country transactions of IPv4 ranges. > The top net-buyers organisations of IPv4s in March were Chinese and the top net-sellers were American. > The above produced 1,644 country pairs totalling 10,941,802 IPv4s. Below is the first record. https://tech.marksblogg.com/ipinfo-free-ip-address-location-database.html https://tech.marksblogg.com/ipinfo-free-ip-address-location-...
- 1letterunixname 3y agoCarpetbagging charlatans who intend to subvert freedom. These sort of fools should be exposed and ignored so that they can't derail or hijack the process of international and local stewardship of digital resources. OTOH, there are many class C IPv4 zombie ranges that aren't actively used for routable purposes. Those could be reallocated readily with an transparent, generous, fair process.