23 ms·
Goodreads was the future of book reviews, then Amazon bought it
- NelsonMinar 3y agoThere's a little bit of discussion from when I posted this a few days ago: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36550687 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36550687
- steedsofwar 3y agoBezos also owns the Washington Post. Make of that what you will.
- moomin 3y agoI think large corporations are typically fine with criticism that doesn’t affect their bottom line.
- synetic 3y agoNo well done review site will remain good once it reaches a critical mass. Private, small scale networks of friends are the future of trusted reviews and recommendations.
- NelsonMinar 3y agohttps://archive.is/TVPWD https://archive.is/TVPWD
- crazygringo 3y agoGoodreads wasn't "the future of book reviews", it was a good review site that might have innovated great new things or might not have at all. But regardless, Amazon should never have been allowed to acquire it -- it was incredibly anti-competitive. Amazon never wanted to do anything with Goodreads at all -- as demonstrated by the fact that it hasn't done anything. It was a purely defensive move to prevent anyone else from acquiring or partnering with Goodreads, because their database of books and reviews could be used to instantly start competing with Amazon's book business. Amazon snuffed out that threat of competition in an instant.
- sdfghswe 3y agoWhy do you think that Amazon is concerned that a database is enough to threaten their business?
- tivert 3y ago> Why do you think that Amazon is concerned that a database is enough to threaten their business? Didn't the GP already answer the question you asked of them? >> It was a purely defensive move to prevent anyone else from acquiring or partnering with Goodreads, because their database of books and reviews could be used to instantly start competing with Amazon's book business. Amazon snuffed out that threat of competition in an instant. A catalog of user reviews is a pretty important feature for a successful eCommerce site. To the point where I've seen some "review sharing" between non-Amazon sites (the specific case was an eCommerge platform showing reviews from their own site and the manufacturer's direct-to-customer site). Goodreads was ready-made to provide that to a competitor, which would give them a shortcut around that moat.
- mikestew 3y agoDidn't the GP already answer the question you asked of them? Do you really that the question was asked in good faith? I know, I know, HN guidelines, but that question was asked to rephrase the question in overly simplistic terms, willfully ignoring that there is more to Goodreads than a mere DB.
- sdfghswe 3y agoIt pains me to learn that I'm so dumb you can't even conceive I'm asking in good faith.
- SoftTalker 3y agoWeirdly I've rarely bought a book based on reviews on the selling site. I don't go to Amazon and browse for books, reading reviews. I go to Amazon when I've already determined from other sources which book(s) I want to buy. Maybe I'm in the minority.
- CaptainZapp 3y ago> By joining Amazon, Goodreads has accelerated their mission to delight customers with the help of Amazon’s resources and technology. Seriously, reading the diarrhea vomited out by corporate PR shills nowadays seriously makes my teeth hurt. Do those people actually believe the bullshit they're spouting to the general public?
- CrampusDestrus 3y agoAmazon's resources and technology to display a static web page with a few low resolution images and a bunch of text.
- garciansmith 3y agoI wish news organizations would not give direct quotes when pure marketing nonsense was written. Just say something like "Amazon did not give us any substantive comment on the matter."
- batch12 3y agoI suspect it's a case of one hand washing another. They publish the fluff so they can be on the list of publications that get early dibs on 'news' that will drive engagement.
- cratermoon 3y agoDon't forget the Jeff Bezos owns the Washington Post. If they didn't give Amazon's side unquestioned, someone would be in trouble.
- chipotle_coyote 3y agoThe article’s entire theme is “was this purchase a good thing” and the subhead (“raises questions about [Goodreads’] longtime owner”) strongly implies the answer is no. I get why “well, journalists never critically report on the people who directly or indirectly sign their paycheck, dontcha know!” is such a popular take (particularly in cynical times with a skeptical crowd), but the history of news shows journalists reporting on things that could potentially piss off their owners pretty repeatedly, and the Washington Post reporting on things relating to Amazon doesn’t seem to be a serious exception. Amusingly, I just did a DuckDuckGo search on “washington post reporting on amazon”, intending to see if there were critical takes on said reporting, and what came up instead was: a plethora of WaPo articles with headlines like “Bernie Sanders launches investigation into Amazon labor practices”, “Lawmakers: Amazon may have lied to Congress”, “Perspective: How Amazon shopping ads are disguised as real results”, “FTC sues Amazon over Prime enrollment without consent”, “Amazon’s OSHA data shows its workers injured at higher rates than rival companies”, and “Tour Amazon’s dream home, where every appliance is also a spy”.
- pessimizer 3y agoThis article starts off pretending to be a criticism of Amazon, and this is highlighted in the headline. After a few vague critical gestures towards Amazon in the first four paragraphs, it gets to its real point: Goodreads, a social network, has woefully inadequate censorship, which can lead to financial losses to authors and publishers. According the the WaPo, Amazon's crime with Goodreads seems to be that it hasn't kept the site up with changes in censorship standards and technology, and just lets whoever say whatever about books.
- drxzcl 3y agoThat’s only true for extremely small values of “censorship”.
- pessimizer 3y agoThe values that include commenting on writing in general aren't small to most people. I can't imagine a larger value. edit: hopefully somebody reading the WaPo has some sort of connection to Amazon, and can really commit to making sure that people's inappropriate opinions on the quality of books, the subjects of books, or whether books should have been written at all - will be corrected promptly and repeat offenders banned in future.
- lkbm 3y agoDo you consider it censorship when Amazon removes fake reviews from their products? This is something most people are in favor of. You can write what you want about books elsewhere. On Amazon, product reviews and ratings should be from people who have used the product. On Goodreads, reviews should be by people who have read the book.
- pessimizer 3y ago> Do you consider it censorship when Amazon removes fake reviews from their products? This is something most people are in favor of. This isn't about fake reviews, this is 1) partially about reviews from people who haven't read the book, but object to the subject matter or something else about the book, and 2) about "review-bombing," a phrase that is used a lot in this article without an argument being made as to exactly what constitutes review bombing (do the people involved have to collude?), or whether it's illegitimate. It just assumes that it is. You've said "fake reviews" in this comment when the word "fake" wasn't used in the article a single time. They depend on you doing that for them.
- arvidkahl 3y agoBesides Goodreads falling into complete disarray, it is equally painful to know that Amazon owns the .book TLD (https://icannwiki.org/.book https://icannwiki.org/.book) and has yet to make that available to anyone. A lot of Amazon's publishing-related acquisitions tend to stray from what they were intended to be.
- fastball 3y agoEh, Goodreads has always suffered from the same problem that plagues every other review system which uses "score out of X" ranking. Humans just aren't very good at ranking things on a normal distribution, so you invariably end up with every item (books in this case) being ranked somewhere in the 3.5-4.5 range (since Goodreads is out of 5). For IMDB the rankings all hover around 8ish. When in reality the average book should have a 2.5. If you don't rate like this then you just end up with garbage. Just allowing a boolean rating (ala Rotten Tomatoes when aggregated) is much better, assuming you can get enough reviews for that system to actually work (probably > 30 is required for most applications). I think "aggregated personal Elo" would be a fun way to rank things: I just give you two books that you've read and you tell me which is better. Do this loads of times and eventually you have a solid ranking of every book you've ever read. Aggregate everyone's rankings and you have a much more robust system then "please rate this book out of 5 stars".
- fourmajor 3y agoI disagree that stars should be evenly distributed between 1 to 5 stars. I think it's quite possible that most books that people choose to read end up being a 3 (good with some flaws) or 4 (good but not all-time great). It's kind of like the same thing with pizza. I'd give most pizza a 3 or 4. Very few 1s and 5s to be sure. 1 doesn't have to mean bottom 20% of pizzas. It can mean "awful, couldn't finish," where very few pizzas would fall into that category. 5 doesn't need to mean "best 20% of pizzas," it can mean "telling strangers about it the next day," again where very few pizzas would fall into that category.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- LVB 3y agoI had a debate on the Criticker site about this topic since they try hard to turn your raw ratings into a normalized span. The fact is that because of ratings sites, I'm very rarely watching 1-star movies. That's good! So the low end was dominated by a 2.5/3 type ratings, which per my scale meant "just OK," but they were mapping it to "bad," somehow inferring that my rating range is 3-5.
- charles_f 3y agoGoodreads had already stopped innovating before it was acquired by Amazon. What's sad is that they have a good user base, data on who reads what, I'm sure they could do a good recommendation engine, but somehow the closest they ended up with is poorly user curated lists.
- CalRobert 3y agoI interviewed with Goodreads in 2012. If there's one thing I learned it's that when you give people weird gimmick problems ("How many Starbucks are there in Manhattan?") in an 8 hour interview that was supposed to be 2 hours, you're going to produce an awful lot of ill will when you reject people because they're "too technical". The whole thing was the most bizarre interview experience of my life.
- hospitalJail 3y agoI had a 1 hour interview go for 3 hours because they couldn't get the HR, hiring manager, and engineer at the same time. Ended up telling the sameish stories 3 times. They offered me a job, then covid happened, then they offered me it at a 10% decrease, then they canceled the contract, then they called me 6 months later. I already had a job at that point and they were begging me to leave.
- JohnFen 3y ago> because they couldn't get the HR, hiring manager, and engineer at the same time. I think you dodged a bullet. If a company doesn't have their act together enough to actually gather the people they need for a meeting that they themselves set up, it hints that there are deep management-level problems there.
- hospitalJail 3y agoFor sure, the company was a Zombie company, but the title was somewhat impressive for my age. I even worked at that company 8 years before, they were so petty when I didn't take a pay cut to be a direct hire, and they got rid of me. (Got a 30% raise at my next job, doh!) Ended up getting my dream job to be a programmer instead of a (real) engineer. Now I make more money than ever, as you can imagine.
- registeredcorn 3y agoI'd love to hear a bit more about the interview, if you're willing to share. Weird interviews are always fun to listen to! :)
- ar_lan 3y agoI think sharing a Washington Post article about Amazon is... probably not a good thing to do at all. This article probably isn't worth reading, to be honest, the bias is too high.
- dvt 3y agoCalling "contextualizing a piece of literature in its broader sociopolitical context" review-bombing is pretty myopic. For example, if you decided to write a book on how awesome the Nazis were, you would rightfully raise some eyebrows. But in any case, the problem with crowd-sourced reviews is that this is a "live by the sword, die by the sword" kind of game. It's great when a bunch of lemmings love your book, cause it to catapult in ratings, and go viral. But, some are now discovering that it can go both ways: the masses being "negatively viral" or purposefully trolling, or brigading. You can't have your cake and eat it, too. This is the main reason I've never seriously used Goodreads as a source for pointed literary criticism. Like most social media, it's a bunch of self-important folks trying to be more self-important.
- notatoad 3y agoi've been "using" goodreads since long before amazon bought it, and it's always just been kind of terrible. It was a clunky, not terribly nice to use site full of absolutely garbage-tier book reviews. the only redeeming quality was the authors who would leave honest reviews on each other's books. i wish there was a site like goodreads, but good. but goodreads was not on track to be that site before amazon took it over.
- jbaber 3y agoI've been liking the recommendations from https://thestorygraph.com https://thestorygraph.com a lot. They can import your goodreads reviews.
- costanzaDynasty 3y agoFAANG, because it sucked the internet dry.
- mcpackieh 3y agohttps://www.librarything.com/ https://www.librarything.com/
- Nemo_bis 3y agoYou know that's Amazon too, right?
- sn9 3y agoAs far as I can tell, Amazon got a 40% share in LT when they bought AbeBooks. I don't know that a minority stake in a company counts as "that's Amazon" in any meaningful sense. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LibraryThing#Ownership https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LibraryThing#Ownership
- Nemo_bis 3y agoAmazon can shut them down any time by cutting their access to data, AFAIK.
- AlbertCory 3y ago> But Goodreads allows any user, not just those who’ve received advance copies, to leave ratings months before books are released. Authors who’ve become targets of review-bombing campaigns say there’s little moderation or recourse to report the harassment. Writers dealing with stalkers have pointed to the same problem. "Problem": chicken-and-egg problem. Until it's actually published, there's little or no way for a review site to verify that you actually got it, let alone read it. Once it's published, people look at the reviews to decide whether to buy it. So where are those reviews going to come from, for a self-published book? Solution: the publisher gives advance review copies to readers. Yes, the system IS ripe for abuse. But if you're reading a review, it ought to be apparent whether the reviewer actually read the book, or whether they have anything interesting to say. And Goodreads should remove the bad ones.
- prox 3y agoThere is also a problem with quotes; you have these nobody self-help book writers adding hundreds (?) of quotes that are very poor, and gamed with upvotes. So you some see some nobody authors quote next to Plato.
- AlbertCory 3y agoWhat does that last sentence mean? Edit: the current comment is not what I was responding to. It's clearer now after editing.
- prox 3y agoI changed the wording. Basically you get noname brand authors quotes next to really legendary figures quotes because it’s all gamed.
- atlasunshrugged 3y agoThat implies people will read the reviews rather than just seeing something with a star rating lower than a 4 and automatically discount it (or that it won't be dramatically deprioritized in Amazon's recommendations because of it).
- manuelmoreale 3y agoPotentially good alternative is https://literal.club/ https://literal.club/ Not affiliated, just a happy user of the site.
- crossroadsguy 3y agoI don’t think GoodReads has any real alternative. Amazon knew that. That’s why they bought it.
- manuelmoreale 3y agoIt’s been 10 years since Amazon bought it. Maybe it’s time for alternatives to go online.
- sidmitra 3y agoAs others have pointed out, alternatives do exist. They just lack the network effect. I've recently moved to Bookwyrm. I was able to move import my Goodreads list, although many books were missing. Any new books i'm reading, go on Bookwyrm first. I had to add the ISBN details etc. for some. It's a bit of work initially, but atleast i feel my contribution is going to a non-walled garden. ---- https://joinbookwyrm.com/ https://joinbookwyrm.com/ - Social Reading and Reviewing, Decentralized >BookWyrm is a social network for tracking your reading, talking about books, writing reviews, and discovering what to read next. Federation allows BookWyrm users to join small, trusted communities that can connect with one another, and with other ActivityPub services like Mastodon and Pleroma.
- gaius_baltar 3y agoBeware that Bookwyrm is neither Open Source (as per OSI definition) nor Free Software (per FSF definition). It is legally impossible for a lot of people to deploy it, I think it even include myself (I am employed by a company, does it counts as "laboring for myself" in my country?)
- 3y ago
- BowBun 3y agoI think we're seeing increased scrutiny towards any social network remaining after Reddit and Twitter have been anti-consumer in their monetization practices. Personally, I've taken a great interest in ultimate-guitar.com, which I consider the equivalent of Goodreads for guitar and other music tabs. Networks like UG and Goodreads are the juiciest targets for corporate takeovers, and both those sites were entirely started on the contributions of non-employees. It doesn't matter if they have now started to produce the content themselves, they wouldn't have had the chance to without the work put in by others already. I encourage you, reader, to look into the social networks you use and to think about how you can archive the data submitted by the public. UG caught my attention because I refuse to allow them to steal their users' content after the fact just because they added some lines to their ToS. I don't know that that's their plan, but based on everything I've seen it seem inevitable. I hope someone else is looking to download all of Goodreads' data to make it available to future hobbyists and grassroots websites.
- MandieD 3y agoThis is the sort of thing the folks behind ArchiveTeam.org live for. I’ve not looked at their site in awhile because it’s heartbreaking what they didn’t get the chance to archive, but they’ve managed to rescue an awful lot, and provide the means for even not-very technical people to help out.
- frankfrank13 3y agoWaPO covering Amazon's Goodreads acquisition is really something.
- javier_e06 3y agoA WaPo article talking about Amazon exploits. What a bizarre world we live in. I made the mistake to join Goodreads. Makes reading a books a some sort of sport. I was not aware that it was owned by Amazon but now it makes sense on how the approach the action of reading a book into a data mining affair.
- ryzvonusef 3y agoFor anime we have myanimelist.com, for (asian) dramas we have mydramalist.com; and both seems to work, for both tracking and for recommendations... but something like that for books does not exist. Goodreads acts as the tracker for me, but a recommendations engine it absolutely sucks. It has never recommended me a book ever, I have to rely on /r/fantasy to churn out new recommendations for me. In the age of AI and LLM and whatever bullshit, how hard is it for Amazon (owner of AWS) to see my read list (which I diligently update) and recommend me something based on the things I've read before, give more weight to my latest reads, and match the sentiments with the text of other books (which they have access too, and it's just text no audio/video bullshit)? If Youtube can do it, if god damn Twitter can do it, why can't Amazon? ---- (we do have mybooklist.com, but it simply does not work properly, it just seems to be a simple and literal "list" aggregator, from other sources, like newspaper etc.)
- ausp 3y agoMay I suggest that you try TheStoryGraph? I've found it fills that need for me nicely and, as a bonus, offers an import service for Goodreads data - no need to start over. The recommendation engine hasn't steered me wrong yet, and the roadmap/developer interaction and feedback are very good indeed.
- riazrizvi 3y agoIt's a good sign to me that the Washington Post, a Jeff Bezos company, is able to criticize a Jeff Bezos business.
- hospitalJail 3y agoThis is small fries though. I'm sure a truly critical post about Amazon's cash maker wouldn't make it past the editors.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- boxcarr 3y agoGoodreads seems to be the Craigslist of the book world: many attempts by others to make a better Goodreads, but none good enough to displace it.
- sidibe 3y agoMy absolutely inane contribution I'm sharing only because it contrasts with everyone else commenting: I think Goodreads is fine, I do glance at it before any book I read to see what kind of reviews it has. The Amazon site I used all the time that sucks now is IMDb.
- r721 3y ago>The Amazon site I used all the time that sucks now is IMDb. Did you try enabling "Show reference view" setting? (Account Settings -> Content Settings)
- mg 3y agoFor me, it was always more important to discover authors than to discover books. When I find a author whose thoughts and theories I am interested in, I usually read everything from this author. Usually their most popular book is the best one. How is this for everybody else here? Any examples of books you discovered on GoodReads where the book itself was the important discovery and not the author?
- ZacnyLos 3y agoNow Bookwyrm is the future of book reviews. Because it's FOSS and federalised with ActivityPub protocol.
- nologic01 3y agoCame here to say the same. Bookwyrm is a good example of how the fediverse architecture is more profound than social media (and definitely more profound than mastodon that is in the end of the day a twitter imitator). People may tire of social media inanity, whether it is centralized or decentralized. But there will always be communities that want to exchange information, thoughts, feelings, whether that is about movies, books or any other creative artifact. Its important that those conversations don't take place inside a giant automated vending machine.
- sidmitra 3y agoOne caveat for new users is that it requires some effort to use it. In many cases, if you're reading non mainstream books then it's on you to add those books and ISBN details + cover page etc. You're essentially contributing to the site content, but hopefully it's worth it. My profile is here, as an example: https://bookwyrm.social/user/sidmitra https://bookwyrm.social/user/sidmitra
- gaius_baltar 3y ago> Because it's FOSS It's not FOSS, my other comment on the issue: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36578294 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36578294
- flenserboy 3y agoIron Law of User Orientation: User-driven & -oriented sites & organization will inevitably be taken over, worn like a skin-suit, & used by corporations for their own ends.
- phillipcarter 3y agoAs a certifiably "normie" book reader, I find Goodreads useless. Whenever I look at a book's reviews to figure out if it's worth it to buy, the reviews are filled with book enthusiasts (and often enthusiasts of that author). It makes sense, since they're probably the most likely to write a review of a book online in the first place.
- dopa42365 3y ago80% of reviews being "got the ebook for free before release in exchange for a very honest review" or "here're my 10000 words thoughts on spoiler spoiler spoiler" and overuse of goddamn inline gifs everywhere made the review section unreadable. It's more like a social network with gamification of book reviews. Looking at a random book: 4.36 stars, 74 ratings, 28 reviews. Release date: 18. July 2023 (in 15 days) No comment on that required heh. Goodreads is semi-useful to keep track of upcoming book releases, but don't bother reading the reviews, and the score is at best a vague indicator (and definitely misleading until months after the book is actually available).
- kawera 3y agoNot to mention reviewers with 3k+ reviews. Who in their right mind properly read and review 3k books?
- qingcharles 3y agoWTF. I spent 10 years in jail reading endlessly and only managed about 900 in total. And I had LITERALLY nothing else to do.
- therealdrag0 3y agoYou read 90 a year. I’ve read 75 a year while going to school or working full time. So it’s possible to read more, and for more than 10 years. (However I might lose my mind if I did that. Even at 75 I started to feel like I was wasting my life with over consumptions.)
- xhevahir 3y agoI've read 56 books this year--keeping track of them is pretty much all I use GoodReads for--and it's feeling like too much. Not many of them stand out in my memory. I've seen people on GoodReads reading 200+ a year, which sounds insane to me.
- 3y ago
- linusg789 3y agohttps://ghostarchive.org/archive/kp8A4 https://ghostarchive.org/archive/kp8A4
- AniseAbyss 3y ago[dead]
- NotYourLawyer 3y agoBut Amazon is otherwise so good at rooting out fraudulent reviews!
- cpncrunch 3y agoExactly. The same problem happens on amazon all the time. The only difference is that amazon shows who has a verified purchased the book, but still, it is very easy to review-bomb a book on amazon, and they do absolutely nothing about it. So, I don't really see this as an issue with goodreads per se. It's just a general problem with moderating user generated reviews, or at least it's a problem with large companies such as amazon moderating (or not) those reviews.
- jillesvangurp 3y agoGiven that the article is on the Washington post, it's worth pointing out that that is another thing that Jeff Bezos owns.
- kunalgupta 3y agoI don’t think amazon gas touched their UX much since 1998 so it’s not like Goodreads is receiving unpreferential treatment
- koboll 3y agoHere's what Amazon.com looked like in 1998: https://web.archive.org/web/20060522143937/http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/subst/home/home.html/002-9382263-3415808 https://web.archive.org/web/20060522143937/http://www.amazon...
- vvpan 3y agoI know it is really easy to disparage blockchain but in my opinion smart contracts can mitigate much of the startup buy-up problem. They allow describing a system as an autonomous protocol that is not "owned" by an entity. Yes, the company that builds tooling around the protocol could be bought but unless the protocol is explicitly backdoored nobody can pull the rug from under the users' feet and data ownership remains in the protocol participants' hands. Blockchain UX is not yet where most people would like it to be but it is improving fairly quickly and I think we could see adoption of autonomous protocols in the next couple of years.
- hnburnsy 3y agoI've always suspected that journalists get story ideas from Hackernews top posts... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36533153 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36533153
- stevebmark 3y agoWhat’s the insider report on the Goodreads technical staff? Did they all quit after the site was bought? Did they stay, and they’re just coasting? Did Amazon nix the tech team? The site has received almost no technical improvements, so there’s clearly not an effective tech team anymore. Can someone at Amazon share the the gossip?
- ggwareago 3y agoNothing salacious. People left over time. Maybe higher turnover than other Amazon orgs because change is harder there. >The site has received almost no technical improvements, Not true. Theyre under the surface or not webfacing. (Like Kindle integration) The biggest technical issue with Goodreads is this: the site was originally built as a giant pile of Rails spaghetti with views mixed with business logic and such and then a fuck ton of weird features built and left to sit there. Like way WAY more than you'd think unless you actively hunted through the webmap. There is an ongoing metaproject to detangle the spaghetti into an api that sits in front of the databases and deprecate the Rails hell pit (derisively called 'the monolith' internally). It's taken years. It is still in progress. It was started far too late in the game. When people talk about tech debt at Goodreads thats mainly what they mean.
- iamsomewalrus 3y ago^ I can vouch for this. Worked at Goodreads from about 2013 to 2017 ish. I’m sure my name haunts git blame now.
- stevebmark 3y agoAs a non-useful aside: That's funny to me, the painful UI of Goodreads smelled like Rails to me. It's engineers trying to solve problems "the Rails way" which leads to poorly designed forms, UX, errors reported to the user, etc. It feels similar to Basecamp, which was notoriously so hard to update that they made version 3 and 4 instead of just improving the existing site. Another victim of a Rails monolith, nice. And a victim of Ruby and Rails' horrific magic that sounds like it's very dangerous to refactor. Unlike Github, I'm guessing Amazon doesn't have core Ruby and Rails maintainers on staff to help keep the thing afloat.
- triangleman83 3y agoMaybe I am behind but isn't ChatGPT a great option for an automod which can read reviews and determine whether or not they should remain up? I tried it on a few examples with a simple prompt and it gave great reasoning why the nasty reviews I fed it should be removed.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- chiefalchemist 3y agoWhile I understand Bezos is not Amazon (and vice versa), am I the only one grinning at the irony of this coming from The Washington Post?
- mt_ 3y agoWhat happened to Book Depository was disgusting.
- muhammadusman 3y agowhat happened to them?
- mkl 3y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35439673 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35439673
- habosa 3y agoI’d love to move off of Goodreads but their export function is pitiful, to the point that I’d say it’s deliberately hobbled. All I do is mark books 1-5 stars and record the date I read it. I recently tried to export to StoryGraph and 1/3 of my books were missing finished dates. If youre owned by Amazon and can’t put a date in a CSV I suspect malicious intent over incompetence.
- electroagenda 3y agoOMG... Did not know Amazon was the owner of Goodreads. There is practically no way you can buy a book online outside the Amazon ecosystem.
- Nicholas_C 3y agoThere are certainly ways, I switched to a Kobo reader instead of a Kindle and haven’t bought a book off Amazon in years.
- jamilton 3y agoThere's Smashwords. I wish more authors used it, I don't know why they don't.
- raydiatian 3y agoWashington Post was the future of news then Jeff Bezos paywalled it
- intesars 3y agoAgree, it was a preemptive buy to keep the competition out.
- zerkten 3y agoIs there a relationship between the application of product management "techniques" and the outcomes for many of these sites? It seems that many of these sites hit this wall when they get acquired. It feels like they start experimenting incoherently with things that don't align with the vision, or even the goals of the acquirer. My personal theory is that this stems from many disjointed experiments where the experimentation is viewed as being more important than anything else. Their mission is to deliver revenue, or some other metric, that isn't visible to users, so perhaps they do achieve their goals.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- garfieldnate 3y agoI don't really understand the sentiment in the article about Amazon not doing anything with it. When Goodreads was acquired, general opinion was "oh no, I hope they don't ruin it -- don't worry, Amazon is known for acquiring working businesses and letting them be." I don't want new social functions on Goodreads; I get an email digest with activity of my friends, and I keep the friend list very, very short so I'm not overloaded with activity. And why on Earth does the author of the article want Amazon to get more involved with detecting bad reviews? As if their track record on their main site would provide any evidence of their being good at that!
- birdymcbird 3y agoarticle puts goodreads problems on amazon. partially true but lazy journalism. much goodreads leadership same as when amazon bought them. i know because i work close to them before i leave amazon. tech was outdated ruby on rails. the engineering org has very low technical bar and love inventing things that amazon already solve at scale. more energy put into resisting amazon than thinking about innovation. lots and lots of waste. i do wonder how amazon layoffs affected goodreads. i would clean house.
- adolph 3y agoOr it could have gone the way of Wirecutter if NYT bought it. Nothing is permanent. Centralization is "better is worse."
- FalconSensei 3y agoAmazon buying it is one problem. But the other is the users, review-bombing books they haven't even read
- pentagrama 3y agoI hope no corporation buys https://letterboxd.com https://letterboxd.com which is currently similar to the good old Goodreads but for movies.
- Nemo_bis 3y agoLetterboxd is already owned by a corporation, Letterboxd Ltd. https://opencorporates.com/companies/nz/3628371 https://opencorporates.com/companies/nz/3628371
- pentagrama 3y agoYou are right
- codazoda 3y agoI wasn’t a Good Reads user but Amazon purchased and then shuttered my favorite music discovery site, Amie Street. They simply redirected the site to Amazon’s MP3 store. This happened back in 2010 and I still miss the ability to discover and buy music from the independent artists who published there.
- yellow_postit 3y agoIt’s been in stasis for so long but is “ok-ish” at what it provides me that I’ve had no need to look for alternative.
- karaterobot 3y agoLibrarything has always been better than Goodreads, with a better community, better leadership, a better mission, and a more confusing UI. You can import your library from Goodreads, or pretty much anywhere else.
- maximinus_thrax 3y agoLibrarything is partially (40%) owned by AbeBooks which is an Amazon subsidiary. Spalding has the lion's share and I'm sure this matters for the direction of the product while he holds it, but I'm skeptical about the whole thing in general. It takes just one person to change their mind and the enshittification starts. Also, see https://www.librarything.com/privacy https://www.librarything.com/privacy > Certain content that appears in on this site comes from Amazon Services, LLC. This content is provided "as is" and is subject to change or removal at any time. Ugh..
- karaterobot 3y agoDo you think either of those facts affect the site in any way? I'll be honest, it just sounds like problematizing to me.
- Guthur 3y agoThe case in point highlights that this is not a problem specific to online media, it's just made it more obvious. There is nothing different between how NSDAP whipped up a nation to go on a 6 year rampage across Europe than what's happening now. I've witnessed otherwise reasonable people justify the description of Russians as Orcs as a reasonable dehumanising racial slur in light of the Ukraine Russo conflict. I like Iain McGilchrist thesis that we seemed that have become overly left brain dominated and so are starting to exhibit an increasing inability to process nuance.
- _kbh_ 3y ago> There is nothing different between how NSDAP whipped up a nation to go on a 6 year rampage across Europe than what's happening now. I've witnessed otherwise reasonable people justify the description of Russians as Orcs as a reasonable dehumanising racial slur in light of the Ukraine Russo conflict. You must have the thinnest skin to imaginable to actually think this. And the irony of this palatable considering how the Russians are acting similar to actual Nazis and mirroring some of their rhetoric. Insulting a fascists invading force committing some of worst crimes imaginable is not the same as what the Nazis did.
- Guthur 3y agoDehumanising is Dehumanising, nothing to do with my skin, I'm not Russian or Ukrainian.
- _kbh_ 3y ago> Dehumanising is Dehumanising, nothing to do with my skin, I'm not Russian or Ukrainian. Regardless of what your background is saying someone making light of fascists invaders is dehumanising requires you to have a super thin skin. If they didn’t want to be called orcs maybe they should stop acting like them.
- Guthur 3y agoYou really believe that's how it works? that russians can just choose not to be involved. Like the east Ukrainians can just choose to be autonomous?
- gkanai 3y agoSame thing with DPReview- the digital camera review site. Amazon bought it, ran it for a number of years, and then shut it down a few months ago. Owner of the site exited. Employees got a few years of salaries.
- athst 3y agoThe problem at Goodreads is not that they haven't made any improvements over the past decade that Amazon bought it. The problem is that they've only made technical improvements and other changes under the hood that no user ever notices. They weren't able to drive a strong product vision forward under Amazon because of poor product vision and poor organizational incentives. It should be a cautionary tale to the people who always complain about not working enough on tech debt - too much of that can be fatal too.
- xvilka 3y agoTime to spin up a Fediverse alternative?
- Nemo_bis 3y agohttps://bookwyrm.social https://bookwyrm.social is very easy to use (but unfortunately it's proprietary software).
- EchoReflection 3y agoso one doesn't have to deal w/ WaPo paywall nonsense: https://web.archive.org/web/20230701144801/https://www.washingtonpost.com/technology/2023/07/01/amazon-goodreads-elizabeth-gilbert/ https://web.archive.org/web/20230701144801/https://www.washi...
- dirtyid 3y agoI find the best review system for books/media is the amount of effort fans put into their wiki or tvtropes entries.
- HeavyStorm 3y agoNobody finding it strange that wp is slamming Amazon?
- CatWChainsaw 3y agoNot really. Although I live in the DC area and subscribe to the Post, and every article that has so much of a whiff of conflict of interest includes a parenthentical aside that Bezos owns the Post. We're used to it. This isn't likely to do financial damage such that Bezos would care, and both Bezos and WaPo "win" if WaPo looks "impartial" enough to criticize Bezos - WaPo gets to show that off for journalistic credibility and Bezos gets to show off that the media org he owns is totally willing to speak truth to power, which makes him One Of The Good Billionaires.
- consultSKI 3y ago#sad
- francisangus 3y ago[dead]