5 ms·
This is a false comparison. Uploading your address book to Path is not the same as an app locally reading the contents of your clipboard and asking if you want
by untog 15y ago
This is a false comparison.
Uploading your address book to Path is not the same as an app locally reading the contents of your clipboard and asking if you want to use that data. It's not even in the same league.
And, loathe though I am to defend PandoDaily, the OP misses the point of their article. Uploading your address book to an app is different than posting it publicly because people trust Path their their data. If they didn't then the really shouldn't be using it in the first place.
- davewiner 15y agoSorry but I think you're missing some data here. Every app on the iPhone can upload your address book, pictures and calendar data to their servers, whether or not they have anything to do with contacts. Every app. It's worth taking a look at the trivial crap we put on our iPads and iPhones thinking they're harmless, when each of them could be leaking all our private bits everywhere.
- untog 15y agoNo, I'm aware of that. What I am saying is that uploading data to an app, no matter what that app may be, is not the same as posting it publicly. When you upload to an app, the makers of that app have access to your data. Don't get me wrong- that's a bad thing. But if you upload your data publicly, anyone in the world has access to your data. Drastically different.
- davewiner 15y agoNothing personal, but I think it's naive to assume that. I once did a deal with a software publisher that required me to turn over the source code. One day I came into the office and found a disk clearly labeled as the source for my product, on the receptionists desk. That was pretty close to public, and I remember that every time I let something sensitive out of my control. Also every few months I have to change my credit card number because a charge appears that I didn't make. Luckily the credit card companies have developed good algorithms for detecting these. Now you might assume that every company that you give your CC to is being careful not to make it public, but if you believe that, you aren't reading the news.
- untog 15y agoWell, the credit card example you give is a good one- you can go through life without paying for anything by credit card, and your credit card will never be stolen. If you do pay for things by credit card, there is a chance that it will be stolen. If you post your credit card details publicly there is a 100% guarantee it will be stolen. I think the same applies to apps. There is a sensible middle ground in there somewhere, and the new permission request alerts from Apple will go a long way to helping with that. But no, never any guarantees about anything.
- davewiner 15y agoBut this is like someone on the subway reaches into my pocket and takes the credit card, copies the number and then publishes it in a blog post.
- smacktoward 15y agoBecause there's no way that your data, once uploaded to the app vendor's servers, can ever leak out. Right? No way they are running their operation on the cheap and don't have their servers secured against intrusion. No way they can be inexperienced developers and build an API that leaks information to improperly authenticated requests. No way they can have a disgruntled employee throw a torrent of it all up when he gets fired. No way they can get bought by someone with fewer scruples and hand your data over to them as part of the acquisition.
- icarus_drowning 15y agoThese are all perfectly valid critiques of the notion that "my data is protected by Path's privacy policy", and they are excellent reasons why Path was right to apologize and correct a genuine problem with their app's behaviour. But they aren't really relevant to the parent comment's point, which is that, even with these (potential) holes giving your address book to Path is fundamentally different than posting it publicly. In one instance, your data is public, immediately and unconditionally. In the other, there is potential for abuse that could result in your data becoming public if an arguably unlikely sequence of events were to occur. So it doesn't make any sense at all for Winer to be challenging PD to engage in a behavior that is simply not analogous to the issue at hand. All that Winer's post does is distort the issue, intentionally or not, and distract from the important debate/conversation that Path's policies initiated. I honestly don't see how that's helpful at all. [UPDATED: Minor correct for clearer syntax]
- smacktoward 15y ago> Uploading your address book to an app is different than posting it publicly because people trust Path their their data. Are you sure about this? Has every Path user really reviewed Path's data security policies and deemed them satisfactory? Do Path users even have access to that information? And if they did, would most of them be in any position to evaluate it knowledgeably? Or isn't it more likely that they trust Path because they don't know the full scope of what Path has access to? Blind trust is easier to extend to someone the less information you're trusting them with, after all.
- drumdance 15y agoI didn't read all the disclosure documents on my mortgage, but I bought the house anyway. I'm not saying Path is right for what they did, but neither do I think it's the same as publishing everything where identity thieves can get at it. Such black & white thinking is of little use in creating policy.
- charlesarthur 15y ago"I didn't read all the disclosure documents on my mortgage, but I bought the house anyway." You should have read them. All those people who got stung by Adjustable Rate Mortgages? Didn't read the terms either. Now imagine that an app has terms that are a bit like Adjustable Rate Mortgages.
- moadeel 15y agoYes, I think it is quite a clear statement. Uploading to an app is not the same as posting it publicly. Other points that you are mentioning have more to do with user's willingness to take privacy seriously. Most don't take it seriously because a) it's tedious and time-consuming b) they probably don't understand it c) it is easier to trust the company like everyone else and get onto using the app and 4) ... as long as it does not include criminal, financial, health or their telephone records, everything is pretty much a go go for a user. Users don't care about their privacy unless it has elements of the 4 categories stated above. Users hate hassle and they have pretty much resigned from the fight for privacy mainly because they have found that the benefit of sharing things with others outweighs the willingness to be clear of a trouble that rarely every shows up in their conscience anyway .... think about it ... when was the last time a major security breach occurred that compromised so many millions and devastated so many thousands that it has left a blip or a bad mark on users conscience. We maybe very techi ... but average users are far more occupied with other concerns. So blind trust plays a strong role for them.
- rickmb 15y agoIt's different in that having your address book uploaded without your permission is actually being the victim a crime in most countries. At least posting it publicly is a voluntary act. Putting yourself in a situation where you are very likely to get mugged would be better comparison. Winer is being mild in his challenge. So yeah, I agree it's not in the same league, but not in the way you mean.
- rsanders 15y agoI trust Path with some of my data -- most of it generally created for the specific use within Path.