3 ms·
I'd love for a distributed, third-party, comment system to gain some traction, but there are at least a few major challenges: * Ease of use: Getting someone to
by xnx 3y ago
I'd love for a distributed, third-party, comment system to gain some traction, but there are at least a few major challenges:
* Ease of use: Getting someone to install an extension is really hard (and doesn't even work on mobile for most users), and getting them to use a specialized browser app is even harder. Firefox would be in a good position to do something on this front. Conceptually, it could even fit in with Pocket. (e.g. "Pocket saves content from everywhere, and allows you to make comments on anything.")
* Canonical addresses: A page/topic/article story can exist at many slightly different urls. How do you properly/automatically consolidate comments? The problem becomes adversarial as soon as it gains any bit of success. No company wants competitors to have the ability to communicate with their site visitors, and will do everything they can to keep comments from being discoverable.
* Spam/moderation: Lots of options here, but none I know of that don't involve big tradeoffs between cost and usefulness.
The good news is that there's probably some opportunity for an "AI" assistant to serve much of the same function as a web-wide commenting/annotations system. The bad news is that if it comes from any of the major players, it might be too sanitized/milquetoast to be useful.
- evolve2k 3y agoFor this community, I’m sure a more fully realised HN browser plug-in that pulled up the article or helped you make a new submission could be useful. In my experience these browser plugins have come and gone likely due to being more an exploratory coding project rather than a multi dev community supported endeavour. No idea if the real demand is there tbh.
- akomtu 3y agoThis looks like a feature in web archive: it already keeps snapshots of web pages, so it could add a comments section. It can dodge the moderation problem entirely by not hosting the comments: instead it would render comments from rss sources provided by the user agent, and the user will be responsible for discovering those sources. Personal rss sources could be pinned to domain names, and there need to be some aggregator that combine thousands of sources - those will be moderators of their "herd". Users would advertise their rss comments just like they advertise their twitter pages. There won't be a global view on all comments on a specific page: everyone will see something different, and that's good. All this hinges on the will of the admins of web archive to implement a comments renderer. Another thought is that such a comments platform already exists: bitcoin. Anyone can attach a message to a hash associated with a url (for a fee). It's gonna be awfully slow, though. And since it's global, any popular url will be buried under mountains of trash, including stuff that will make govs shut down bitcoin completely.
- jerf 3y agoThose aren't the real challenge. The real challenge is annotation software has an anti-network effect: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23576213 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=23576213 An AI system that tries to summarize the annotations to tame the chaos might be interesting, though whether people are willing to "engage" with a system that takes their input and merely feeds it into an averaging model such that nobody will ever see their actual comment might be a tough sell.