3 ms·
> “Since the movie “Inconvenient Truth” the amount of ice of the world has increased significantly toward the mean.” > That is 100% accurate. You’ve assume I s
by godelski 3y ago
> “Since the movie “Inconvenient Truth” the amount of ice of the world has increased significantly toward the mean.”
> That is 100% accurate. You’ve assume I said something else and constructed a straw man argument.
No, I assumed you said that. I think what you intend to now say is "Comparing the arctic sea ice levels between 2006 (the year "An Inconvenient Truth" came out) and today, there is little to no difference in levels." That statement is true and unarguable. It is fact. But it is also very precise and I'd argue not useful.
You are extrapolating by using the word "trend" as that incorporates a more continuous nature of things. That is why we looked at multiple years. Because we need to see a trend. Systems are noisy and if we just take two samples we can't compare them that well because we haven't really incorporated the error/uncertainty associated with those data points. By incorporating more years we are doing just that. We could be much more rigorous and tighten our error bounds, but the process we did is sufficient to discredit your claim.
The truth is that 2023 is only just starting. If we look at 2020-2022 we see that up until... July 1st, that they are near identical to the 2006 values. But that's when they all diverge and there becomes a large gap (July 1st till about Dec 1st).
The 60s comment is addressed in the other comment. Let's not merge two threads.
Re Mars: That article is about methane and not about global temperatures. I'm not sure why this is relevant. Doesn't even mention the delta.
Re Pluto: It explains the difference right there in the article. Earth's eccentricity: 0.017; Pluto's eccentricity: 0.249. A 15x difference seems to play an important role and makes for good explanations about different mechanisms. I mean the fucking thing gets closer than Neptune during its orbit and this was one of the reasons it was downgraded to a dwarf planet.
I'm no longer assuming good faith. You're not even reading your own sources and considering other opinions. I have made the mistake of trying to play chess with a pigeon. I should have expected my board to be full of shit, but I tried to be nice.