7 ms·
“does not alone explain” means the same thing as “cannot be explained by.” I think your confusion stems from “is influenced by” being a much weaker statement t
by Retric 3y ago
“does not alone explain” means the same thing as “cannot be explained by.” I think your confusion stems from “is influenced by” being a much weaker statement than “can be explained by.” Being in prison for example isn’t ”explained by” people breaking the law as that would require nobody to be falsely imprisoned or be set free on a technicality etc.
The second statement follows from the first. If you can’t completely determine someones wealth from past decisions alone, then you can’t group the poor or wealthy by the history of their past decisions.
- tomcatfish 3y agoThis is not correct. If we want to explain why the sidewalk is wet, and 99% of the time it is because of sprinklers and 1% of the time it is because of rain, then "The sprinklers do not alone explain the wetness", but "The wetness cannot be explained by the sprinklers" is a foolish thing to say.
- Retric 3y agoEnglish is tricky around negatives and groups. “Wetness of all sidewalks globally can be explained by sprinklers.” <- obviously false. “Wetness of sidewalks can never be explained by sprinklers.” <- also obviously false The first applies to all sidewalks as a group, the second applies to subsets of the overall group so it’s false if any subset can be explained by sprinklers. Both quotes are using my first example due to being inclusive and including: “on a social level” and “population-level”