5 ms·
> This can lead to absurd outcomes. The UK had a very hot day last year, with the Met Office reported a "record breaking" temperature. The problem is that this
by godelski 3y ago
> This can lead to absurd outcomes. The UK had a very hot day last year, with the Met Office reported a "record breaking" temperature. The problem is that this temperature was recorded by a thermometer right next to a military airbase runway at the exact moment three fighter aircraft were landing. The temperature spiked up to the record level for 60 seconds and then dropped again, with the spike+drop being quite massive. Finding this out took a year of FOIA requests, done by independent bloggers of course, not journalists.
I'm going to need a source on this. This doesn't even really make sense to me, because a single 1s spike (in either direction) should be filtered out. It also doesn't make sense how this would significantly affect a model which is performing a multi-decade analysis unless that single 1s spike was used to represent at least a month's worth of temperature. Which as far as I know the data is being pulled at at least a daily rate if not more, so the spike would disappear.
For the "no warming" part, let's adjust things a little bit to be more clear. First, let's clear that noise. It is all jiggly and difficult to read and trend going on. Let's select the month of June (middle of the year) and then select a 12-month time scale. Interesting, the beginning and end have the same point. Let's now find out if this is a coincidence or not (current window should be 2006-2022). If we move our window to 2010-2022 we see a clear trend line up over the last decade, but it is noisy (-1.07 -> +0.96). So let's go in the other direction. 2000-2022 seems down, slightly. Let's keep going. 1990-2022, okay, very clear upwards. 1980-2022, very upwards. 1970-2022, we're now at -1.65 -> +0.96. 60's, seems we've stabilized. 50's, oh, difference is decreasing again. And we keep going and see a clear trend of increasing.
I think when we're talking about a multi-decade effect we need to look at... multiple decades and be a bit more careful to not only look at one single window. Especially with numbers jumping around a lot.
- SideburnsOfDoom 3y ago> 'm going to need a source on this. This doesn't even really make sense to me I was in London all last summer, as I am now. You are correct. The idea that the record breaking temperature of 19 July 2022 (1) was some kind of fake or artifact of measurement, is horseshit, plain and simple. There's no other way to put it. This is a glib but nonsensical assertion. It's just deliberately wrong. That 1 day was the worst of it but the whole several weeks were bad. I myself measured 41C in my back yard on the 19th. Others had similar. 1) https://www.independent.co.uk/climate-change/met-office-uk-weather-today-heatwave-schools-closed-b2127060.html https://www.independent.co.uk/climate-change/met-office-uk-w... https://www.theguardian.com/world/live/2022/jul/19/uk-weather-extreme-heatwave-forecast-temperature-today-latest-live https://www.theguardian.com/world/live/2022/jul/19/uk-weathe... https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-63244353 https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-63244353
- revelio 3y agoOK here are the sources. Note that I said the spike was 60 seconds, not 1 second, not sure where you got a 1 second spike from. Re-reading the stories it seems it was more like a few minutes rather than one minute. Anyway, the RAF Coningsby investigation was done by Chris Morrison over the course of about a year. I suspect you or others will reject the source for ideological reasons, but here's how he developed the story. This brief spike mattered because it was widely covered in the UK as irrefutable evidence of climate change, it being the hottest temperature ever recorded there. It's not about inclusion in monthly averages. It begins here, with the BBC lying about where the record temperature was observed. Not a great start: https://dailysceptic.org/2022/07/20/climate-alarmists-turn-up-the-heat-as-temperature-records-broken-at-british-airports/ https://dailysceptic.org/2022/07/20/climate-alarmists-turn-u... "The BBC noted on Radio 4 last night that the record temperature arose in the “village” but co-ordinates on the Met Office site place the device halfway down the runway at RAF Coningsby, home of two squadrons of frontline, combat ready squadrons and a training base for Typhoon pilots." Here's where they discover the record was set during a brief spike: https://dailysceptic.org/2022/11/27/fresh-doubts-emerge-about-40-3c-u-k-temperature-record-next-to-airfield-runway/ https://dailysceptic.org/2022/11/27/fresh-doubts-emerge-abou... "Over six minutes, the temperature jumped suddenly by 1.3°C to 40.3°C at 15.12 (3.12pm), and was 0.6°C lower just a minute later. In just two minutes from 15.10 the rise was 0.6°C." Here the Met Office claims that they have a rigorous verification process, and maybe a break in clouds was the reason for the spike, but Morrison got a satellite photo that showed it was a cloudless day: https://dailysceptic.org/2022/12/04/doubts-remain-about-40-3c-record-at-u-k-airbase-after-met-office-fails-to-respond-to-questions/ https://dailysceptic.org/2022/12/04/doubts-remain-about-40-3... Here's where they FOIA the logs and find the 3 planes landing at the time the record was set: https://dailysceptic.org/2023/06/28/exclusive-three-typhoon-jets-landed-next-to-measuring-device-when-britains-record-temperature-of-40-3c-was-recorded/ https://dailysceptic.org/2023/06/28/exclusive-three-typhoon-... Re: no warming. Someone else was confused by this, maybe my language wasn't clear enough. The US CRN only has data back to 2005 because that's when it was opened. The point is that the older network is garbage, with lots of heat-causing corruption in the record and very low data quality. Climatologists in the 1990s were drawing totally different temperature graphs to today's, yet they are both supposed to be based on the same observations. This is clearly a terrible situation to be in for any field, and a big driven of distrust in climatology. Good scientists care about instrument accuracy, they don't collect low quality data and then constantly rewrite the collected data in a never ending attempt to retroactively fix it! So if we restrict our view to the data collected by the trustworthy weather station network, what do we see? No warming at all, even though CO2 rose constantly over the time period in question. That's a serious problem and the attempts at debunking it aren't convincing.