2 ms·
OK, let's spitball. Maybe too much for an HN comment, but here we go: - Define an open protocol - There are multiple viewers (browser plug-ins), so different
by crazygringo 3y ago
OK, let's spitball. Maybe too much for an HN comment, but here we go:
- Define an open protocol
- There are multiple viewers (browser plug-ins), so different users can choose a different viewing/comment ranking interface experience
- There are multiple "channels" of comments for any piece of content, but usually channels will be topic-wide, sitewide, or even internet-wide. All content for a channel comes from a single server. If channels were pulling from existing sites, an episode of TV might have a channel of Reddit comments, a channel of Vulture comments, a channel of AV Club comments, and anyone can create a channel. (Maybe Reddit and Vulture don't participate at all)
- The person/group who runs a channel does/delegates all of the moderation for that channel. They do this out of the good of their hearts, much like Reddit moderators
- Each plug-in gives you a default, or a choice of, approved/blocked channel lists according to your political/cultural/etc. preferences. These lists are maintained similar to adblock lists, each of which are curated by groups with those preferences. So you can avoid unmoderated toxic channels or view them exclusively
- And so each viewer will combine all of the comments from all approved channels into a single comment list. Each top-level comment can come from a different channel, but all subcomments always belong to that same channel. When you leave a top comment, you can choose which channel to leave it in (or have it default to whichever channel is most popular, similar to picking the most popular subreddit on a certain topic)
- User accounts are managed by separate servers, but user servers don't hold comments/upvotes/etc. They merely provide signing to prove comments came from the same user, index comments left by that user, sum the user's received votes (which can be independently verified by the channels), etc. These servers are similarly moderated to kick out abusive users. Channels don't allow comments from users from user servers that don't kick out abusive users. Ultimately your identity is proved by a private key you can always take to a new server. Probably, the groups behind the most popular channels and/or most popular lists will provide these user servers as well
Whaddaya think?
- Blackthorn 3y agoI thought about this sort of thing as a reddit replacement. Browser extension that creates a forum on any arbitrary page. Backend is just nntp so pick your own server. Can't work on it because of corporate ip ownership and all that nonsense. It's a pretty trivial idea though, pretty much anyone could implement it if you don't bother writing a bespoke news client.
- Philip-J-Fry 3y ago>Can't work on it because of corporate ip ownership and all that nonsense. Is this an American thing? I'd understand that being an issue if you were using company provided equipment, doing it on company time, or creating a competitor. But if you're just doing a side project in your own time on your own computer, how can your employer assert any sort of ownership over that?
- Blackthorn 3y agoYes, it's an American thing.
- bastawhiz 3y agoThe details are immaterial. Who stores the data at rest? If it's distributed, you have a cesspool of spam and nonsense. If it's controlled by a central authority, it's subject to the whims of that authority. If you choose a federated hub (a la Mastodon), you're stuck in your echo chamber or an empty room. The protocol doesn't matter. Right now, those are the only three options (minus crypto) given our current technology. Without going into the technical feasibility of your solution of federated identity with distributed storage or deciding who becomes a moderator or how to avoid a bad actor spinning up thousands of servers to create millions of fake users to spam or any of the other problems, the issue is social: people choose to be in the place where the moderation is most agreeable to them, which will become the natural partition for how the users divide themselves. Whoever those moderators are responsible to (how do you get "fired"? who decides?) ultimately answers the question of centralized, federated, or distributed, and decides the implications and downsides of that approach.
- crazygringo 3y ago> Who stores the data at rest? Each channel stores all the comments left on it. (They're not copied anywhere else, except for caching clients might choose to implement.) > If it's distributed, you have a cesspool of spam and nonsense. Channels that moderate will not, and most people won't be viewing channels that don't moderate. > people choose to be in the place where the moderation is most agreeable to them Yes, those would be the lists of approved channels that clients use, like I said maintained analagously to adblock lists. There would probably be one or two popular "mainstream" lists, and then various "progressive-only", "right wing-only", "lulz" etc. ones. Think of it basically like Reddit, except each subreddit is its own server (channel) that moderates according to its own policies, and whenever you view a NYTimes article you pull up combined comments from the well-moderated subreddits and not from the badly/un-moderated ones. Does that make sense?
- bastawhiz 3y ago> Yes, those would be the lists of approved channels that clients use Who moderates the list of channels? Who decides which curated lists of channels are available? > most people won't be viewing channels that don't moderate. Who decides the moderation policies? Who enforces that the moderators are doing their jobs, nominates new ones, and fires ineffective ones? > Does that make sense? Nothing you described is technically infeasible, it's just you're trying to describe a federated system while avoiding storing data on federated servers. The problem is not in storing or distributing the bytes, it's about policy and governance. What you're describing is a federated system, with power being put in the hands of the people who maintain the lists of channels and the people who decide which lists to publish to their users (assuming they're different people). Someone is still in charge, just not a singular centralized authority. That's a federated system, and they exist already, and the social and political problems with running them are well known.
- Accujack 3y agoI agree with your idea - I've been working on a similar one for a while. However, what you write above could almost completely describe USENET news groups. Learning what worked for USENET news and what did not will give you a starting place for this idea. For the most part, USENET discussions worked just as well as Reddit discussions according to the skill and motivation of the moderators, although that was the very early net and most of those involved were educated white men, not teenagers or nations engaging in information warfare. I'm continuing to work on a design for a federated discussion system just because I think the world needs discussion boards that aren't bound by national law or corporate desire any more than necessary. However, I think the original intent of the sidewiki stuff was slightly different. That said, they could be a combined system, with one presentation of the various groups/subs/channels being via a reddit like website, and another being a side bar attached to a web browser window. It depends on what is being discussed.