2 ms·
There are some great moderators on Reddit who are selflessly keeping their communities afloat. There are also those who are power hungry, routinely abuse their
by paxys 3y ago
There are some great moderators on Reddit who are selflessly keeping their communities afloat. There are also those who are power hungry, routinely abuse their power, accept payments from corporations, and generally make the site a worse place. Mods of most popular/default subreddits more likely than not fall in the latter category.
- Gualdrapo 3y agoFrom all the drama that has happened in there, there were at least an upside - u/awkwardtheturtle, the mod behind the power trips at r/art (allegedly who took down posts from people who according to said mod were "ai generated art" but actually they weren't), was banned.
- dimmke 3y ago>There are also those who are power hungry, routinely abuse their power I see this argument all the time, but isn't this just human nature? In any organized structure, some people are going to seek out "power" and abuse it. You will find people making the same complaint about their neighbor who is the head of the homeowner association. It's also part of why people become cops, or if they can't get there, security guards. Every broad "type" of community on the internet has had this problem. I remember growing up, there were plenty of capricious IRC moderators and admins as well as moderators of individual forums. Little dictators. I will say, I feel like there was a concerted effort to frame these API changes as specifically being harmful to those with disabilities and moderators (I guess in an attempt to point to short term, immediate concrete harms that would come from this), which opened things up to reframing the whole discussion around as a referendum on moderation. And apparently most people can't make a simple connection and ask "Why did Reddit not care about these flagrant power abuses before? Will they keep caring after this is over?" And it seems like that's been fairly successful. But I still think Reddit has doomed itself with this move.
- msla 3y agoYes, it's human nature. The fact Reddit didn't allow bad moderators to be removed played into it, too, which resulted in some oddities of the website: /r/Marijuana was run by assholes, so /r/Trees became the marijuana subreddit. /r/WorldPolitics was run by moderators who didn't actually moderate the content (other than for the absolute "Sitewide Rules" the admins will remove a subreddit for violating) so it wound up with an absurd amount of cartoon porn, which lead to /r/Anime_Titties becoming the subreddit to discuss world politics. It's funny lore and it lead to the site having culture of a sort, but it points to a failure in upper-level administration. Reddit simply doesn't care about the product it's putting out, beyond some very basic rules aimed at trying to prevent the site itself from being sued, and it shows.
- dimmke 3y ago>The fact Reddit didn't allow bad moderators to be removed played into it, too I tried to "play the tape through" on this, and imagine what it looks like. If Reddit had proactively tried to implement some kind of intervention system to remove abusive moderators from subreddits. It puts Reddit as an organization in a tough position, because they have to mediate disputes. And it opens up a bunch of other questions. How big does a subreddit have to be before they qualify for this intervention system? Does one submit an organized case like filing a lawsuit? What if the accused moderator is the only moderator of the subreddit? And what new rules does Reddit add to try to curb abusive moderators? There'd have to be some kind of ethical guidelines drawn up. So now unpaid moderators can be disbarred like lawyers? Every thing I think of (admittedly not having spent a ton of time thinking about this) is open to potential abuse. Even if you set the trigger to be a 90% vote of "no confidence" by subscribed members of the subreddit, the subreddit would be vulnerable to "raids". If you gate it to "you have to have been subscribed for X amount of time" the time will either be too short and leave raiding or create a new "class" of "landed gentry" that have a disproportionate say in how the subreddit is run. So I don't know if it's actually a failure. Some of the stuff Reddit did early on, things like vote fuzzing etc... show a willingness to experiment with using the platform itself to enforce better behavior. They might have been able to figure something out, eventually. But then I think of really simple stuff that even Hacker News has implemented (ex. you can't downvote a direct reply to one of your comments) and how Reddit doesn't have that.
- tomohelix 3y agoI have a different opinion. If you had experienced with the mods on reddit, you will notice that Reddit official stance is: Mods are allowed to do anything they want with their subs. That is the line Reddit as a corporation has endorsed and is the main reason for the "landed gentry" comparison. It is also the problem that caused abusive mods being untouchable. Reddit does not want to control its moderators in any way. Because of that, they dont even have any willingness to try to make the mods more accountable.
- wkat4242 3y ago> It puts Reddit as an organization in a tough position, because they have to mediate disputes. And it opens up a bunch of other questions. How big does a subreddit have to be before they qualify for this intervention system? Does one submit an organized case like filing a lawsuit? What if the accused moderator is the only moderator of the subreddit? Yes. It's not easy. But Reddit knowingly went into a community moderated forum industry. It's not as if this situation was forced on them. Having some plans for this would have been normal business planning. A lot of this sounds like the plan was: 1. Cool website 2. ????? 3. Profit!!! Except they never got to 3 and now are scrambling.
- rvba 3y agoSpez had a lot of time to solve problems with bad mods.