5 ms·
I also desperately want something like this to succeed. I want to be able to see others' reactions on all NYTimes articles, for example, not just the handful ea
by crazygringo 3y ago
I also desperately want something like this to succeed. I want to be able to see others' reactions on all NYTimes articles, for example, not just the handful each day they enable comments on, or the occasional one submitted to HN.
And I want it to have all of the standard functionality -- hierarchical comments (like HN and Reddit), upvoting and downvoting, auto-collapsing tangential threads with less votes (like Reddit), giving more weight to users who are consistently upvoted, etc.
But also, I'm not sure if URL's are exactly the right pieces of content to associate with. Not only do you have the problem of determining canonical URL's when sites themselves don't provide them as metadata, but there's a lot of content out there that isn't a webpage: TV episodes, TV series, movies, podcast episodes, podcasts, music tracks, music albums, and so forth. Right now the closest thing there is for some of those (some TV episodes, some podcast episodes) are official posts in dedicated subreddits.
It almost makes me wonder if it would need some kind of dedicated URL scheme that could be managed by Wikipedia or MediaWiki or something, like tv://startrek-strangenewworlds.us.2022/s02/e03#tomorrow_and_tomorrow_and_tomorrow.
- paradaux 3y agoYour url comment reminds me of the concept of the semantic web [0] Whereby we can have a structured machine readable and pure URL structure backed by ontology and linked data. There's a project that is working on this for Wikipedia called Dbpedia. [1] [0] Unfortunately this concept has been completely bastardized by random research groups shoehorning the technology for EU grants, from my experience working in one such group. [1] https://www.dbpedia.org/ https://www.dbpedia.org/
- _def 3y agoThat reminds me of Wikidata[0], which aims to be a general purpose semantic knowledge graph, which runs on Wikibase[1], a MediaWiki extension set that you can run yourself for any collection of data. [0] https://wikidata.org/ https://wikidata.org/ [1] https://wikiba.se/ https://wikiba.se/
- TillE 3y agoFunny, I've always hated scrolling down and accidentally seeing comments on news articles, which are almost uniformly garbage. I think it's a terrible way to present any kind of serious story, it makes for a worse experience. If I want to discuss an article, there's Twitter, Reddit, etc. The NYT used to have a good public editor (Margaret Sullivan) you could complain to, but she's long gone. I will say that The Verge has a good approach, where there's a comment section on every story but it's hidden behind a button at the bottom you have to actively click. That's a fine compromise.
- enobrev 3y agoOne of the nice features of Google reader was that you would see discussions of urls by people in your contacts. A similar filter could be really useful for this sort of discussion plugin.
- crazygringo 3y ago> If I want to discuss an article, there's Twitter, Reddit, etc. Most articles don't have a Reddit thread, and it's impossible to view commentary around a URL on Twitter in any kind of cohesive forum-like way. Also, I don't want to have to constantly be copying and pasting URL's into other sites. I just want it right there automatically.
- squirtlebonflow 3y agoYep, the main problem is that whatever.com could be a completely different page for user A and B, and if they both commented on it, they'd be commenting about different things, then user C goes to view it, and is confused. Which could be helped by storing the page source or something (which still has a ton of issues associated with it) but then you have a problem of discovery, and how do users tell the pages apart with the same URL? Simple version numbers? Another problem is you might have 2 URLs that are basically the same page, but with some query parameters that subtlety distinguish them - they are different URLs though. Should there really be two discussion sections for a page that's only differentiated by a referral link or a stylistic preference? Probably not, but there is not an objective metric here we can use to make the call. What if we use just the base path, e.g. facebook.com? It could be useful for small sides but for large sides you'll run into issues with scoping topics. it's a really hard problem IMO
- andrepd 3y ago>And I want it to have all of the standard functionality -- hierarchical comments (like HN and Reddit), upvoting and downvoting, auto-collapsing tangential threads with less votes (like Reddit), giving more weight to users who are consistently upvoted, etc. This is what I most certainly would not want to see. The prioritisation of "upvoted" content and comments is the number one source of all kinds of perverse problems with modern social media (echo chambers, manipulation, incentivisation of simplistic or short-form content, promoting base anger and outrage, etc)
- mbreese 3y ago> The prioritisation of "upvoted" content and comments is the number one source of all kinds of perverse problems with modern social media I (unsurprisingly) like the HN method… the public can’t see the exact number of votes for a comment, but the comments are still ordered by number of votes. And comments with negative votes are styled differently, but you don’t know exactly what the vote totals are. Yes, you can still have echo chambers and manipulation, but it’s more difficult to effectively manipulate. (At least without a lot of external coordination, in which case the site is already fighting a losing battle).
- bastawhiz 3y agoI desperately do not want this to succeed. Who moderates it? No moderation means a fractal of spam, hate, propaganda, and low-value posts. You cannot have a system like this that's resistant to Sybil attacks without centralization or federation (or at least not without forcing users to get into crypto to use it... No thanks). You either accept that it's centralized, and it becomes siloed (see: reddit, Twitter) or you federate it and it's an echo chamber or nearly empty.
- LightBug1 3y agoWho moderates wikipedia?
- spondylosaurus 3y agoUnpaid contributors who care a lot about maintaining the quality of articles (and spend a lot of time doing so).
- bastawhiz 3y agoEditors, controlled by a (mostly benevolent) centralized authority
- _def 3y agoI really don't think that is the case, but I'm interested to hear why you think it is. In my understanding the community is not controlled by a central authority.
- bastawhiz 3y agoThe rules for how Wikipedia is edited are ultimately set by the people who run Wikimedia. They have the final say. It's a centralized service (there is a single Wikipedia at a singular domain, being the sole source of truth). In the context of this discussion, there is no such notion of a federation of wikis on various hosts contributing to the content. There's obviously no decentralization of Wikipedia. Wikimedia is therefore the centralized authority.
- wpietri 3y agoFunnily, this is an idea that keeps recurring. I talked with a would-be founder circa 1999 who wanted a discussion sidebar for every website. He too was excited about wresting control of the experience of a site from the site's owners. My memory is kinda fuzzy here, but I think this is what the idea turned into: https://web.archive.org/web/20000301142549/http://www.shoptok.com/index.html https://web.archive.org/web/20000301142549/http://www.shopto... It looks like it went from being a global community (which raises lots of questions, both the ones you mention and things like who moderates it) to something with a much clearer revenue model, one where companies pay for add-on forums. And then blew up at the same time Bubble 1.0 did. The fact that people keep trying this but that we still don't have it makes me suspect there are fundamental flaws, but I've been wrong about that before.
- defrun 3y ago> a much clearer revenue model can you please explain the business model?
- rvba 3y agoYou want the reddit sidebar back... I miss the reddit sidebar. But it got blocked because new technology does not allow it.