3 ms·
Being tracked is different, and does not negate openly available. You don't get into every library in the world simply by turning up: identity has been a part o
by ggm 3y ago
Being tracked is different, and does not negate openly available. You don't get into every library in the world simply by turning up: identity has been a part of access since writing was invented. You can't request books from many libraries without identifying yourself and the works requested.
- Genghis_Khan 3y agoIn most libraries in the US, browsing the collection--even taking books from the shelves to a table for a while to read and make notes--does not require any sort of identification whatsoever. It's only when we temporarily deprive the library of a copy of a work, i.e., borrow it, that we have to identify ourselves.
- boesboes 3y agoThat's not quite the same. I'm not required to make an account with Google to go to the library. Being registered by a government agency and being tracked by multi-national that is famous for abusing tracking data are on a different planet imo. The problem, for me at least, is that I do not use google products. I do not have an account and do not want one. So for me, this is not openly available. We could argue about the merits of being so principled in not using google, but that seems besides the point :) I should be free to no do business with Google and if that precludes me from accessing something, it is not openly available I'd say
- kwhitefoot 3y agoOn the contrary in every library I have been to you just walk in and browse the books. Last time I went to a university library a librarian was more than willing to help me find the books I needed and didn't ask any questions at all regarding my identity. I dare say that she would have refused to let me walk out with the books but that's understandable and anyway I wanted to refer to them not take them away.