4 ms·
> a slippage between tectonic plates so powerful that it moved Honshu, the main island of Japan, 2.4 meters to the east. The earthquake generated a tsunami 14 m
by troupo 3y ago
> a slippage between tectonic plates so powerful that it moved Honshu, the main island of Japan, 2.4 meters to the east. The earthquake generated a tsunami 14 meters high
The definition of a black swan event.
And yet the conclusion is, unsurprisingly, indistinguishable from "nuclear is bad, be very very wary".
Imagine if any other tech had the same fear-mongering. We'd never have a single hydroelectric plant after Banqiao dam failure that killed anywhere from 25 000 to 240 000 and left 11 million people homeless.
- otherme123 3y agoYou can still build nuclear reactors, they are not banned. But you want to build them ignoring safety lessons. The aeronautical industry is improving safety all the time, and accidents prompt new safety measures. They don't scoof accidents without analysis and adaptation, saying "if you want to fly you must accept that some 787-MAX are crashing down from time to time, but still safer than traveling by car, we did the math". No, they landed the plane and adapted.
- troupo 3y ago> But you want to build them ignoring safety lessons. No, I don't > The aeronautical industry is improving safety all the time, and accidents prompt new safety measures. Yes, they do. Note: we're still flying. The number of aircraft is increasing. And we don't turn aircraft into boogey men. Had aircraft been treated the way nuclear plants are treated, we'd stop building most of them in the early 80s, and the construction of each new one would be met with strong opposition and campaigns to shut the entire thing down.
- nerdponx 3y agoYou're ignoring the fact that humans generally do not think in terms of expected value, nor should they. An improbable outcome of widespread catastrophe (irradiating a million people) is and should be treated as something worse than a more-probable outcome of localized catastrophe (plane crash). You can't just do "loss x probability = cost".
- troupo 3y ago> An improbable outcome of widespread catastrophe (irradiating a million people) is and should be treated as something worse than a more-probable outcome of localized catastrophe (plane crash). Quoting myself again: Imagine if any other tech had the same fear-mongering. We'd never have a single hydroelectric plant after Banqiao dam failure that killed anywhere from 25 000 to 240 000 and left 11 million people homeless.
- nerdponx 3y agoFair about the dam. If that happened in the West then yes, it'd change things. The biggest dam failures in North America for example have never been that big. And you'd surely never get a major new dam built today anywhere near any kind of populated area in the USA. Also, it's worth noting that nuclear disasters remain dangerous for amounts of time ranging from "one generation" to "longer than human history so far", adding an extra element of catastrophe.
- zarzavat 3y agoThe crucial difference is that people consent to get on a plane. There are quite a few people who are afraid of flying, so afraid that they refuse to fly. That’s of course their prerogative. The problem with nuclear power stations is that when they have serious accidents they don’t just affect the people who wanted to build them, they affect everybody, including the people who didn’t want them to be built, and even people in neighboring countries who didn’t even get a vote on it - depending on which way the wind blows. So the nuclear power station has to be built as safely as the most fearful person demands.
- troupo 3y ago> The problem with nuclear power stations is that when they have serious accidents they don’t just affect the people who wanted to build them, they affect everybody Why do we keep building hydroelectric plants (and dams in general)? Why do we keep building coal plants which are more radioactive than niclear plants, and are often located in densely populated areas? Why don't you apply the same logic to other things?
- Gwypaas 3y agoWe are not? We are building renewables where the risks all come from the people working on the equipment. Fitting the analogy of airline safety nicely.
- XorNot 3y agoAnd yet nobody consented to climate change. I certainly didn't. They also don't consent to PM2.5 from uncovered coal trains running through residential areas. Nobody consents to being downstream of a hydroelectric dam...
- zarzavat 3y agoI wasn’t saying that we can’t have nuclear power at all. I was saying that we can’t nuclear power that is as risky as aviation. If that makes nuclear unviable, then so be it. Getting on an aircraft involves taking a risk. You may die. People die every year because they boarded an aircraft. The risk is small, but it’s not zero. We are okay with people taking this risk because they chose to do it. For nuclear power, small is not good enough, the risk of a serious incident such as Chernobyl has to be effectively zero. This is very expensive. Hydroelectric is not really comparable, if you are not happy living downstream of a hydro plant then you can move somewhere else. Nuclear fails in unpredictable ways. When Chernobyl happened, the whole of Europe held its breath to see which way the fallout would blow. The only way to escape the risk is heavy regulation or bans.
- FeepingCreature 3y agoHad nuclear plants been treated the way airplanes are treated, any fault in one plant would lead to steps to redesign all of them, present and future, to definitively avoid this fault; and frankly, the fact that this is not being done is such a massive fuckup that it's making me more anti-nuclear. My pro-nuclear position is based on an assumption of baseline competence! This doesn't seem to actually be the case!
- snovv_crash 3y agoIncorrect, old aircraft are grandfathered into new regulations. This is why it's so hard to get the GA industry to switch away from leaded avgas, because it's almost impossible to certify new engines.
- FeepingCreature 3y agoDoes this apply to safety issues as well?
- masswerk 3y agoHowever, it took less than 60 years of commercial nuclear power generation for that black swan event to occur. (Compare hydro-engineering, where it's common to design for 100-year events and even 500-year events. Also, compare tsunami stones marking flood levels from the 1930s.)
- troupo 3y ago> However, it took less than 60 years of commercial nuclear power generation for that black swan event to occur. Hmm... We've been building cities for millenia, but look, in this event "45,700 buildings were destroyed and 144,300 were damaged by the quake and tsunami". > Compare hydro-engineering, where it's common to design for 100-year events and even 500-year events The 1975 Banqiao Dam failure was the collapse of the Banqiao Dam and 61 other dams in Henan, China, under the influence of Typhoon Nina in August 1975. The dam collapse created the third-deadliest flood in history which affected a total population of 10.15 million and inundated around 30 cities and counties of 12,000 square kilometers (or 3 million acres), with an estimated death toll ranging from 26,000 to 240,000. The flood also caused the collapse of 5 million to 6.8 million houses.
- masswerk 3y agoYou may note the tsunami stones, marking flood levels from the 1930s with inscriptions like, "Do not build any homes below this point (…) Remember the calamity of the great tsunamis." Also, earthquakes, even sever ones (there had been 9 with magnitudes > 8 in the 100 years before), are expected and reoccurring events in Japan. They had been explicit design criteria for the power plant. This was quite literally a 100-year event with similar past events happening in the last 100 years before this. So this is hardly a black swan.
- troupo 3y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36560103 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36560103 and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36559760 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36559760
- Gwypaas 3y ago> The definition of a black swan event. An earthquake and tsunami in the country who coined the term is now a "Black Swan event" to make an attempt at painting the nuclear power plants failure in favorable light. Even more entertaining is that Fukushima lead to widespread changes across the industry around independent core cooling and gas filtration. The regulators found systemic deficiencies in the industry, but let's roll that back! As an example: A nuclear reactor in Sweden had a severe incident in 2006 when many of the "defense in depth" layers had been accidentally removed through freak occurrences and upgrades. Thus independent core cooling was not a Black Swan event, it was systemic. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Forsmark_Nuclear_Power_Plant#July_2006_incident https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Forsmark_Nuclear_Power_Plant#J...
- troupo 3y ago> An earthquake and tsunami in the country who coined the term is now a "Black Swan event" to make an attempt at painting the nuclear power plants failure in favorable light. How many earthquakes do you know that move an entire island by 2.4 meters? How many 14-meter tsunamis have there been? "A black swan is an unpredictable event that is beyond what is normally expected of a situation and has potentially severe consequences" > The regulators found systemic deficiencies in the industry, but let's roll that back! Of course that is not what I'm saying. But do let the FUD roll.
- Gwypaas 3y agoThe Indian Ocean one less than ten years prior? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2004_Indian_Ocean_earthquake_and_tsunami https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2004_Indian_Ocean_earthquake_a... Following that multiple studies showed that Fukushima could get hit by +15m tsunamis and suggested heightening the sea wall. Now you are trying to redefine Black Swan to fit your narrative. Take what the author said about COVID-19. > According to Taleb, as it was expected with great certainty that a global pandemic would eventually take place, the COVID-19 pandemic is not a black swan, but is considered to be a white swan; such an event has a major effect, but is compatible with statistical properties. Similarly, there is a great certainty that a +15m tsunami will hit any of the existing nuclear power plants in Japan. Fukushima was not a Black Swan, simply human negligence.
- verve_rat 3y agoAn earthquake on the Pacific Rim is far, far from being a black Swan. If you can't build a nuclear plant, or a dam, while accounting for expected events, then maybe don't.
- defrost 3y agoAn earthquake isn't a black swan event, correct. An earthquake of that magnitude, creating a Tsunami of that strength, striking in just the wrong place .. is very much a black swan event. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ilFEKSZQv5o https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ilFEKSZQv5o By your 'logic' no dam can be built as they all stand a chance of a direct hit from a meteorite. Risk-wise the Fukushima nuclear disaster cause less direct and indirect death than many accidents and natural disasers .. including deaths from, say, fertilizer depot explosions, oil rig accidents, etc.