4 ms·
How can you tell the difference between the same thing but updated packaging for the companies new brand from a whole new thing unrelated to the first? And in t
by bluGill 3y ago
How can you tell the difference between the same thing but updated packaging for the companies new brand from a whole new thing unrelated to the first? And in the grey area it is this years upgrades/version (is this still the same thing?)
Don't forget that it needs to be automated as Amazon is too big to do this manually. And whatever rules you come up with can't be gamed.by creative lawyers.
- viraptor 3y agoThere's a massive difference here between changing Widget v1 to Widget V2 and changing a pillow to an air conditioner. There are very simple things they could limit right now, like not allowing to change the listing category after N days without a review and hundreds of other things. > as Amazon is too big to do this manually Amazon allowed a guy to build a dick-rocket for a trip to space. They can hire a hundred people to review those requests. Don't worry about poor Amazon not coping.
- AlexandrB 3y agoI think even allowing changes from V1 to V2 while keeping reviews is pretty bad. It's not unheard of for hardware manufacturers to release a higher quality product initially and then "cost optimize" it to suck later. A good example is hard drives and SMR[1]. Why not allow linking back to the V1 version and its reviews from the V2 so shoppers can judge for themselves instead of having one take the place of the other? [1] https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2020/04/caveat-emptor-smr-disks-are-being-submarined-into-unexpected-channels/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2020/04/caveat-emptor-smr-di...
- heavyset_go 3y agoThis is why I think a new listing per SKU requirement would be great. You also see this happen with retailers, where manufacturers work with retailers to build exclusive cheaper versions of existing products that use those products' names and packaging. You end up with situation where the Walmart version of your specific product is actually different than the ones sold everywhere else.
- willis936 3y agoThen they just lie about the SKU. There is no rulemaking that will replace the need for more audits. Someone somewhere is accountable and if their illegal practices are made unprofitable the problem will go away.
- heavyset_go 3y agoDefinitely, the rule about SKUs is not enough at all.
- desmondfraser 3y ago[dead]
- pessimizer 3y ago> Amazon is too big to do this manually. Amazon is allowed to be smaller if it can't figure out how to do it profitably.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoAmazon is a company that makes a tiny amount of money a billion times a day. There is no sustainable way to increase costs without increasing prices. Regulatory overhead in competitive markets like retail gets paid for by customers, not corporations. It makes poor people have to pay more to buy stuff.
- autoexec 3y ago> There is no sustainable way to increase costs without increasing prices. This is beyond ridiculous. Any company pulling in 3.2 billion in profit can easily increase costs without increasing prices just by accepting a little less profit. Hell, they could increase costs and lower prices and still be both highly profitable and sustainable by any sane definition of those words.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoTheir net margin over the last year was 0.82%. That's the extent of how much costs could increase before they lose their entire profit, and companies are unsustainable well before that because they become worth more to sell off for their real estate and equipment than they are as an operating company. You might also be interested in the proportion of the operating income they do make that comes from AWS rather than retail: https://www.investopedia.com/how-amazon-makes-money-4587523 https://www.investopedia.com/how-amazon-makes-money-4587523
- ukuina 3y agoDoesn't Amazon claim to sink much of their revenue back into R&D?
- tornato7 3y agoAmazon created mechanical turk which would be perfect for this sort of moderation.
- justapassenger 3y agoMake completely changing product against the rules, let customers report it and ban sellers if manual review proves report was correct. Sprinkle some AI to it, and it becomes manageable.
- heavyset_go 3y agoA "new SKU means a new listing" rule should catch 99% of relevant cases.
- willis936 3y agoImportant things change just as often as packaging. Switched the recipe? Burn the listing.
- nkrisc 3y ago> Don't forget that it needs to be automated as Amazon is too big to do this manually. And whatever rules you come up with can't be gamed.by creative lawyers. That’s their problem if they allowed themselves to grow so big they can’t manage their own store. If they can’t handle product updates, they shouldn’t allow it.
- octacat 3y agoEasy, lol. Add into the rules "if it is a whole new thing and we see it from the user claims, your account goes bye-bye". But it is still profitable for Amazon to sell scam items, so they do nothing. Also, yes, they could spend some time to review the updated pictures for the listings or make it a paid feature for the sellers. They could even use AI to compare descriptions and if USB-flash drive becomes 1TB SSD drive, they could flag that.
- bfdm 3y agoDon't. Just dump all reviews upon any product change (at least by default). Everything goes into a secondary bucket of "Old reviews for a previous version of this product." With a clear notice that "product features or even core functions may be different". They love money and fees. They can offer a review process to keep reviews for a new version once manually reviewed and confirmed as substantially the same product, perhaps with new images of new packaging.
- throwaway14356 3y agoyou either have enough reviews that it is worth a substantial amount of money to preserve them or you just make a new listing. Change review pricing can also scale with the number of reviews.