3 ms·
No it won't because Amazon doesn't write any fake reviews, to the best of our knowledge. The article and rules make clear that this applies to the companies wr
by crazygringo 3y ago
No it won't because Amazon doesn't write any fake reviews, to the best of our knowledge.
The article and rules make clear that this applies to the companies writing and submitting fraudulent reviews, not the platforms hosting them.
(If Amazon wrote a bunch of its own fake 5-star reviews for products under its own label, then this would apply in that case. But considering how many Amazon-brand products have terrible ratings, there's no reason to believe they've ever engaged in that practice.)
- 0cf8612b2e1e 3y agoWhat are some of the poorly reviewed Amazon products? Anytime they show up (at the top of the search results, naturally), they are typically a high averaged score. My prior assumption was that Amazon took a page from Walmart's playbook and would, ahem, borrow ideas for only the best/top-selling products.
- varenc 3y agoI tried for awhile and the lowest rated items with more than 10 reviews where 3-stars. This 3-star listing has 30 reviews: https://www.amazon.com/low-rated-item-varenc-found/dp/B099Q6WRXS https://www.amazon.com/low-rated-item-varenc-found/dp/B099Q6... And here's a 1 star item but it only has 1 review: https://www.amazon.com/low-rated-item-varenc-found2/dp/B09Z6YHF7W https://www.amazon.com/low-rated-item-varenc-found2/dp/B09Z6... I'm guessing after you hit some number of reviews and the average is less than 3, Amazon doesn't let you list it anymore. Which is funny considering Amazon lets you filter search results on 1-star or 2-star items only and up. Seems like that filter option exists just to make you feel like the higher star ratings are more meaningful.
- EA-3167 3y ago...Mattress and VPN companies may owe more than the world's GDP.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 3y agoMattresses make me wonder if, stupidly assuming the rule is enacted and enforced, there might be knock-on effects. TVs, mattresses, electronics, etc like to sell distinguishing SKUs to different platforms. That is, Target may get to sell the Sony 59" ABC123, but Walmart only ever gets the Sony 59" ABC456. Rendering it impossible to get stores to price match products from other marketplaces. Big if, but if these rules go into effect, I wonder if maybe reviews being harder to solicit could result in more consolidation of model numbers to concentrate the review scores?
- comfypotato 3y agoConsumer Reports reviews mattresses. They do a decent-to-great job depending on the product. Shopping for anything they review is infinitely better than dealing with the hellscape of normal reviews.
- thaumasiotes 3y agoThe proposed rule prohibits disseminating or causing the dissemination of a testimonial... about the business or one of its [the business's] products or services (when the business knew or should have known that the testimonial was illegitimate). That would catch Amazon if fake reviews were left on sold-by-Amazon products (and Amazon should have known that that was happening), but that seems unlikely unless Amazon is trying to violate the rule. Amazon disseminates a lot of fake reviews, even fake reviews that it has reason to believe are fake, but those are presumably not for Amazon's own products.
- DropInIn 3y agoAmazon handles the customer interactions, the fulfillment at nearly every step (shipping, picking and packing, returns, etc), takes a cut per sale, etc etc etc Under most reasonable definitions the seller of record should in fact be Amazon and not the person who amazon calls a seller.... As usual, corporations manipulate language to undermine government and citizen actions against thier misdeeds
- datavirtue 3y agoYeah, the "seller" is actually a vendor that I have no business with.
- DropInIn 3y agoMore aptly called suppliers imo
- parentheses 3y agoIt's possible we won't know unless there's a before and after review diff.
- Vanilla_Salt 3y agoI would not be surprised if the majority of fake reviews are coming from offshore companies. Does the FTC have jurisdiction to fine those? Otherwise this changes nothing.
- mbrochh 3y agoBingo. This ruling will change absolutely nothing.