4 ms·
> If the rules are approved, they’ll carry a big stick: a fine of up to $50,000 for each fake review, for each time a consumer sees it. Amazon may owe the FTC
by paxys 3y ago
> If the rules are approved, they’ll carry a big stick: a fine of up to $50,000 for each fake review, for each time a consumer sees it.
Amazon may owe the FTC more money than the world's annual GDP.
- kjkjadksj 3y agoAnd thats just considering the reviews where they straight up admit they got the product free for a five star
- VWWHFSfQ 3y agoi dont think that's considered a fake review. useless, yes.
- nvahalik 3y agoHow does the square with section 230 something?
- fiddlerwoaroof 3y agoAs far as I can see the site itself is mostly immune (Amazon, etc.). The fine applies to actors that solicit fake reviews.
- nighmi 3y agoI once bought socks on Amazon, which came with a note saying they would send me a free item for a good review. I then got a free electric kettle with another card. Then I got lenses which attach to a phone camera, a carjack, a foldable lawn chair, but the a raclette cheese melter didn't come with another card. Honestly, all fine products, nothing's broken etc. and I was very happy with such an amazing value for under $10. Werw they even fake reviews?
- ceejayoz 3y agoWere yours in particular fake? Maybe not. Does this cause people who might've given a four start review to bump it up to five? Probably. Does it mask the company later subbing in a cheapened, shittier version a few months later to float on the large number of five star reviews? Yes.
- thaumasiotes 3y ago> Does it mask the company later subbing in a cheapened, shittier version a few months later to float on the large number of five star reviews? Yes. What does that have to do with the proposed rule? There is a rule against substituting in an unrelated product to get credit for reviews that were originally written for something else. Making a new batch of your product that is cheaper and worse than the old batch is allowed.
- ceejayoz 3y ago> The Federal Trade Commission proposed a new rule to stop marketers from using illicit review and endorsement practices such as using fake reviews, suppressing honest negative reviews, and paying for positive reviews, which deceive consumers looking for real feedback on a product or service and undercut honest businesses. > Review Hijacking: Businesses would be prohibited from using or repurposing a consumer review written for one product so that it appears to have been written for a substantially different product. The FTC recently brought its first review hijacking enforcement action. The scenario is explicitly part of the new rule, even if you'd otherwise have given it a five star review. They're not giving you free products just for fun. One of the reasons is to get hundreds or thousands of good reviews
- thaumasiotes 3y agoThe scenario is not part of the new rule. Review Hijacking refers to transferring reviews from one product to an unrelated product, not transferring reviews from one product to the same product assembled on a different manufacturing line. The new version of the product may be obviously worse, but it is not a substantially different product.
- ytdytvhxgydvhh 3y agoThe last time I got one of those cards I wrote a 1-star review of the product for that reason. Amazon refused to publish the review citing their policy that product reviews aren’t meant to be reviews of the seller (even in this case when the seller is also the manufacturer and doing shady review manipulation). Sellers only play those games because Amazon is on their side.
- taurath 3y agoAnd the process of “reviewing the seller” (IE reporting them for bribing you) is made extremely difficult by Amazon. It’s nice that Amazon has gotten the government to enforce policy for them in their platform, it must be a lot cheaper to pay lobbyists than to make their platform work.
- rvba 3y agoOh you got a "car jack" not a "carjack". I wondered how did you rate it..
- partiallypro 3y agoA trick on Amazon, which I have no idea how it's allowed, is to create a listing for a product like detergent or soap, get tons of reviews that are 4.5 stars+ then change the listing to something else entirely, like supplements or anything. Something high margin that is being drop shipped. Suddenly all the reviews are mixed between this new product and the old one, but you have 4-5 people go in and create reviews for the new product the listing has been replaced with, and have accounts just mark those as the most helpful, so they rise to the top (most people don't go through more than 5-10 reviews.) It's such a scam. It's very common too.
- Mistletoe 3y agoThis infuriates me and I know Amazon could fix this with like five minutes of trying on their part. It seems like such an obvious engineering fix that it must be intentional that it remains as-is.
- partiallypro 3y agoKinda like Amazon turns a blind eye to selling counterfeits and just outright stolen items.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoIt's almost as if Amazon is inventivized to make money...
- hutzlibu 3y agoYes and we have to set those incentivization right, so they don't see fraud as profitable anymore. Which is what this law is about and it comes way too late.
- ClumsyPilot 3y agoThey dont turn a blind eye, they directly profit by traking a vut from this fraud. This is like claiming that a kingpin could shutdown crime on his street - why would he, he gets a cut
- crazygringo 3y agoNo it won't because Amazon doesn't write any fake reviews, to the best of our knowledge. The article and rules make clear that this applies to the companies writing and submitting fraudulent reviews, not the platforms hosting them. (If Amazon wrote a bunch of its own fake 5-star reviews for products under its own label, then this would apply in that case. But considering how many Amazon-brand products have terrible ratings, there's no reason to believe they've ever engaged in that practice.)
- 0cf8612b2e1e 3y agoWhat are some of the poorly reviewed Amazon products? Anytime they show up (at the top of the search results, naturally), they are typically a high averaged score. My prior assumption was that Amazon took a page from Walmart's playbook and would, ahem, borrow ideas for only the best/top-selling products.
- varenc 3y agoI tried for awhile and the lowest rated items with more than 10 reviews where 3-stars. This 3-star listing has 30 reviews: https://www.amazon.com/low-rated-item-varenc-found/dp/B099Q6WRXS https://www.amazon.com/low-rated-item-varenc-found/dp/B099Q6... And here's a 1 star item but it only has 1 review: https://www.amazon.com/low-rated-item-varenc-found2/dp/B09Z6YHF7W https://www.amazon.com/low-rated-item-varenc-found2/dp/B09Z6... I'm guessing after you hit some number of reviews and the average is less than 3, Amazon doesn't let you list it anymore. Which is funny considering Amazon lets you filter search results on 1-star or 2-star items only and up. Seems like that filter option exists just to make you feel like the higher star ratings are more meaningful.
- EA-3167 3y ago...Mattress and VPN companies may owe more than the world's GDP.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 3y agoMattresses make me wonder if, stupidly assuming the rule is enacted and enforced, there might be knock-on effects. TVs, mattresses, electronics, etc like to sell distinguishing SKUs to different platforms. That is, Target may get to sell the Sony 59" ABC123, but Walmart only ever gets the Sony 59" ABC456. Rendering it impossible to get stores to price match products from other marketplaces. Big if, but if these rules go into effect, I wonder if maybe reviews being harder to solicit could result in more consolidation of model numbers to concentrate the review scores?
- dialogbox 3y agoWait... $50,000 per number of page view not per number of review? That's insane. How the FTC would know the number of times each customer saw it?
- indymike 3y agoThis will not survive the courts. Damages are unconscionable.