3 ms·
Because the term found through decades of literature isn't attached to legal categories, as I explained. It's the same way the term "drug" doesn't have much leg
by crazygringo 3y ago
Because the term found through decades of literature isn't attached to legal categories, as I explained. It's the same way the term "drug" doesn't have much legal distinction, as I can't think of any legal commonalities spanning coffee, alcohol, Lipitor, cannabis, and heroin.
> Regardless, the laws... refer to specific chemicals by their name.
Not directly, very often. I doubt there's any specific law around Lipitor. Rather, drugs are grouped into categories and then the laws that permit or restrict them are mostly around those categories. Otherwise it would all be incredibly redundant (with exceptions for certain incredibly common drugs like alcohol). And the question here is how to categorize pyschadelics for legal purposes. And saying that we just call them psychadelics answers as many legal questions as saying we call them quooquaquams -- i.e. zero.
- shwaj 3y agoWhy can’t “psychedelics” be the name for the category?
- seabird 3y agoBecause that's not how controlled substances are grouped and regulated, and for good reason.
- anigbrowl 3y agoThen maybe it's the controlled substance administration that's wrong. Seriously, what level of hubris does it take to think that natural substances like psilocybin mushrooms which have existed for millions of years must be brought under the control of a polity's legislature? It's like declaring sharks or snakes illegal because they give some people nightmares. Future generations will laugh in disbelief at this idiocy.
- seabird 3y agoI don't know what you're getting at here. We're not talking about values. We're talking about why the word "psychedelics" is a worthless term as far as the law is concerned. From a values standpoint, I don't see how it would be idiotic to schedule truly dangerous drugs like 25i-NBOMe more strictly than psilocybin or LSD.
- krispyfi 3y ago25i-NBOMe isn't "truly dangerous". It's only dangerous if mistaken for LSD and dosed carelessly, so rather than scheduling it more strictly, there should be strict requirements for accurate labeling and consistent dosing, like every other drug.
- seabird 3y agoIt is straight up dangerous. 5x a common dose of <1mg can kill you. Nobody that can actually execute on properly dosing it will expose themselves to the liability of doing so. Drugs are cool and interesting, go ahead and do them, but trying to pretend that something like 25i-NBOMe is something that Joe Average will safely deal with is, frankly, pretty fucking stupid. This conversation is constantly approached with this idea that everybody is a reasonable, informed person that is fully educated on the risks, but that's just not how this works.
- squirtlebonflow 3y agoWell, that's an interesting idea. 20x a common dose of acetaminophen, an extremely pervasive, legal, over the counter painkiller, can kill you. Less can kill a child. Lots of drugs contain it, such as over the counter cough medicine. People legitimately die or become seriously ill every year because they don't know this. Granted, 5x is a lot different than 20x especially when a drug is taken for recreation rather than necessity. I've never done 25i-NBOMe, but it's my understanding that it's easy to overdose because a method of administration is blotter paper and people think they're taking LSD. In our current world, when you get prescription drugs for the first time, you are provided with information about risks. Over the counter medicine, you aren't. In my ideal world, if you wanted to do a recreational drug and it had risks like this, you'd have to complete a drug education course and obtain a prescription, you'd be provided with phone numbers for services like overdosing or mental health, specific to the drugs you're planning on doing, and dosage would be easy because medical professionals are doing it in a lab before they sell it to you. The average Joe would much rather do drugs that they know are manufactured correctly, not adulterated or cut with other substances, where the dose is measured accurately, and where if something goes wrong they have a professional to help them, even if it means they have to pay a bit more than the black market - which will surely still exist. And if someone goes through the black market and does because they did a drug that is now legal, and they didn't know the correct dose? Sad, but that's on them
- scns 3y agoHow did drugs become illegal? Check out the documentary series Hooked. Short answer: Racism and corruption. [addendum] Marijuana and Methamphetamine: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZvGtn8RzF0U&list=PL2-GCln73gJRBMMSLz7IuOf5kyu45o9HC https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZvGtn8RzF0U&list=PL2-GCln73g... Ecstasy, LSD & the Raves: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3id6j6nJmlo&list=PL2-GCln73gJRBMMSLz7IuOf5kyu45o9HC&index=3 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3id6j6nJmlo&list=PL2-GCln73g... Opium, Morphine and Heroin: https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x2ocqwm https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x2ocqwm
- mensetmanusman 3y agoThis is true in China as well?
- mensetmanusman 3y agoIt could be, but once you have any experience with the legal system, you realize that terms are very flexible and explicitly defined. Maybe not using psychedelics as the legal term is useful strategically.