4 ms·
The big problem with federation-by-default in the current incarnation of federated software (at least Lemmy, I'm less familiar with Mastodon) is that you will l
by lolinder 3y ago
The big problem with federation-by-default in the current incarnation of federated software (at least Lemmy, I'm less familiar with Mastodon) is that you will likely end up publicly hosting any content from instances that you choose to federate with.
With email, it doesn't really matter if someone is using your email platform to spread controversial political ideas or using it to share pirated media or whatever, because you're not hosting it for the general public to consume.
With the fediverse it's different. If I own fedifoo.app and allow my app to federate with neonazis.app or tankies.app, then eventually neonazi or tankie content will be accessible at fedifoo.app/c/unpleasantcommunity. I don't want that, so I defederate, but now the fediverse is fractured and "it doesn't really matter which instance you choose" is no longer true.
Disabling federation by default helps protect new hosters from the unintended consequences of federation, which is good, but it leaves us starting out on a fractured footing.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThe solution to this is to have a unified namespace which is distinct from hosting. So then /c/unpleasantcommunity is only hosted by instances that choose to mirror it, but if anybody goes to /c/unpleasantcommunity and their default instance doesn't mirror it, it redirects to an instance that does. Then you don't have to host anything you don't want to but you still have a unified network.
- nickorlow 3y agoYeah, I also think having the option to censor communities in specific is a good way to do it. So you could just choose not to host /c/hatefulcommunity. I'd imagine blocklists and community reputation systems would be created much like what exists with e-mail.
- AnthonyMouse 3y agoThe generally right way to do this is to put actual censorship on the far side of impossible but give individuals good filtering tools. So then maybe your instance provides a default blocklist, but if something gets blocked, it isn't just silently invisible, it shows up as a collapsed comment that you can unfurl or a warning page that you can click through if you really want to. And if you don't agree with an entry your instance added by default, you can strike that one out and choose to always see it. The key is to never let anything like a central party impose censorship that can't be overruled by the user, but still allow them to filter out 99% of the crap by default.
- nickorlow 3y agoYeah, Polycentric lets server operators choose to censor individual posts or entire users. Your client can query anything that's censored from one server by querying it from another where the content was published. It's fairly easy to tell when a post is censored since each post has a logical clock per user that is incremented per post, so you can pick out any missing logical clock entries.
- willi59549879 3y agoi quite like how censoring is done in the fediverse. there is no censoring but each user can chose to block content from showing up in the client. i don't like the idea of censoring. some authority decides what other people are allowed to see.
- nickorlow 3y agoI like it in principal, but I think it's hard to keep up with spam in a manner like this.
- tsimionescu 3y agoHow does a user choose to block content without seeing it, say in order to avoid seeing gore videos from war zones or such?
- Gareth321 3y agoSadly Lemmy’s implementation is quite poor. The owner of each instance can choose which other instances to federate with. So shortly after the Reddit exodus, many are already forming tight ideological bubbles. For example, Beehaw defederated with almost every other instance because they want an ideological safe space. This despite the fact that the protocol already gives individuals plenty of tools to block and avoid users and communities they don’t like. So there is a strong push to control the experience for all users in an instance, instead of allowing individuals that control. And I see a lot of support for this model in other, “less” authoritarian instances like lemmy.world. I think many people are just very authoritarian today, and don’t appreciate the internet as we knew it 20 years ago. They’re not content to control how they interact with the internet. They want to control how everyone interacts.
- cassianoleal 3y agoBasically Usenet then?
- FormerBandmate 3y agoYeah, literally a modern Usenet. Reddit is barely different than Usenet anyway
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tsimionescu 3y agoA big problem with this is that certain kinds of content are illegal both to host but also to link to, in many parts of the world (including the USA). Your solution works well for legal-but-reprehensible-to-the-admin content such as nazi or tankie content (or porn or [...]). But if you end up linking to illegal pornography, or to drug selling, or even to gambling etc, then you're likely still liable and the fact that you're not directly hosting the content is not going to protect you that much (look at torrent trackers to see how well that defense worked).
- pdntspa 3y agoYou can't censor content on a federated platform without fracturing that platform.
- z3t4 3y agoYou can't login to Hotmail to read your Gmail email. You can however have an e-mail client that pull your mail from both.