7 ms·
Lev Landau's “Theoretical Minimum”
- belter 3y agoLandau's Theoretical Minimum, Landau's Seminar, ITEP in the Beginning of the 1950's - https://arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/0204295v1 https://arxiv.org/abs/hep-ph/0204295v1 "...In the worst cases, when the speaker failed a few times, he was ostracized — excluded from the list of the seminar participants, and Landau would refuse to have discussions with him, but, of course, he (the ostracized person) could attend seminars. (I remember two such cases — in one case the speaker was a famous physicist, V.G. Levich, who eventually became a Member of the Academy of Sciences). Only after a long time, a year or more, and after being advocated by the most respected seminar participants, could such a person be pardoned by Landau..."
- imranq 3y agoI've skimmed through the Landau books and while they are technically excellent, they lack a sense of feeling and motivation which makes it hard to self study from. It felt like a slog across random topics with no application
- yodon 3y agoThe key is to make sure you're reading books by Landau and Lifshitz. Landau was more the famous as a theoretician, Lifshitz was the better writer. That said, these are definitely books to read when you're in the mindset of studying for PhD doctoral exams in Physics. I loved them at the time but would definitely have a hard time curling up by the fire with them on a rainy afternoon.
- MontyCarloHall 3y ago>Landau was more the famous as a theoretician, Lifshitz was the better writer. As the famous quip goes, "not a word of Landau and not a thought of Lifshitz."
- mepian 3y agoI remember trying to read the first tome of Landau and Lifshitz in my first year of studying at the physics department and instantly bouncing off. The textbooks of Irodov, Savelyev, and Sivukhin were much more approachable.
- smueller1234 3y agoThere's a reason the profs love Landau/Lifshitz. The books have a certain elegance that, once you have a decent understanding of the subject already, is easy to appreciate. But as a first year theory student, that's just not what you need. Went through the same experience you describe. But enjoyed them when I picked them up again a few years later.
- asimeqi 3y agoThe first volume is "Mechanics" as in Theoretical Mechanics. It's a second or third year Physics course not a first year one. I took it third year, it was mostly fine. The treatment of Hamilton-Jacobi equation lacked motivation but it wasn't super difficult. I also took volume 2, "Classical Theory of Fields". That was much, much harder. Anything after that seemed unreachable.
- aleph_minus_one 3y ago> I've skimmed through the Landau books and while they are technically excellent, they lack a sense of feeling and motivation which makes it hard to self study from. A person that I know who has a doctoral degree in pysics and loves the Landau-Lifshitz books said: "If you need such an external motivation (for reading the Landau-Lifshitz books), you simply do not have sufficient inner drive for studying physics. Find another major that better is a better fit for you."
- guptadagger 3y agoI think this 100% true, you don't read those books for any pleasure, its simply a necessary part of an education in theoretical physics. rigorous and challenging
- mathisfun123 3y agodon't you just love it when people with "doctoral" degrees meme? this is a really bad paraphrasal of the apocryphal story about hilbert: "There is a much quoted story about David Hilbert, who one day noticed that a certain student had stopped attending class. When told that the student had decided to drop mathematics to become a poet, Hilbert replied, “Good — he did not have enough imagination to become a mathematician.” — Robert Osserman (US mathematician, 1926 – 2011)"
- aleph_minus_one 3y ago> don't you just love it when people with "doctoral" degrees meme? This was not intended as some kind of meme by him. He really is like that. The mention of his doctoral degree in physics has just the relevance that he is not to be considered a crackpot.
- gtsnexp 3y agoIt would be incredible to gain access to the archive of exams, particularly those administered during Landau's era. These must surely exist in paper format somewhere, right?
- nologic01 3y agoFairly comprehensive, highly technical but hardly inspiring or insightful. Old-fashioned, austere (The classical theory of fields has like a handful of diagrams). The polar opposite of the "Pleasure of finding things out" of Feynman. Or the incongruous visual orgy and outright speculation of Gravitation. Of-course the interesting question is which educational / pedagogical approach works "best". Alas that is almost impossible to define, let alone prove on the basis of the highly idiosyncratic development of physics in the 20th century.
- elcritch 3y agoIt makes me wonder of the 43 students who passed, how many achieved significant breakthroughs or Nobel prizes?
- MontyCarloHall 3y agoHis students were successful enough that nine of them have their own articles on English Wikipedia. Many more (>20) have articles on Russian Wikipedia. Amongst the nine students who have English Wikipedia articles, one won a Nobel [0]. The others have all won highly prestigious physics prizes, and all appear to be major contributors to their subfields. One even has a class of subatomic particles named after him [1]. Was Landau's pedagogical approach optimal? Impossible to say. Was it extremely successful? Objectively, yes, without a doubt. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alexei_Abrikosov_(physicist) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alexei_Abrikosov_(physicist) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pomeron https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pomeron
- Panoramix 3y agoIs that not just selection bias? Makes sense that the most gifted students at the most prestigious school over a span of 30 years went on to have great careers.
- MontyCarloHall 3y agoOP was questioning whether Landau’s method of identifying the most gifted students actually selected for successful physicists: “It makes me wonder of the 43 students who passed, how many achieved significant breakthroughs or Nobel prizes?” So yes, it is selection bias by definition, but the point is that the method of selection worked. Most other professors at the most prestigious schools in the world could only dream of advising anything close to Landau’s academic descendants.
- chinchilla_opt 3y ago[flagged]
- nuccy 3y agoIf by "this civilization" you mean Soviet Union, presuming modern Russia only, then FYI Ukraine is also part of that civilization.
- mepian 3y agoI guess you would be relieved to learn that this civilization died decades ago, and the destroyed Buran orbiter is its tombstone.
- chinchilla_opt 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RD-180#US_production_of_the_RD-180 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RD-180#US_production_of_the_RD...
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dannylandau 3y agoAnyone read the Livshitz-Landau textbooks? Any thoughts on them and how the compare to the Feynman Lecture series? P.S. No immediate relation to Landau (and family name is really Livshitz).
- max_ 3y agoThe Feynman lectures are definitely easier to understand. I could pick something from them. And more fun to read. Course of Theoretical Physics is too "cold". It however seems more comprehensive. As it looks to contain more material.
- wbl 3y agoFeynman was trying to teach the first three years of physics by mixing the splits between topics. It's far less comprehensive than L&L.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoThey are incredibly dense. Like, it assumes you are already an expert on the topic and you need a high level refresher.
- vitehozonage 3y agoAccurate. I had a immigrant Russian professor in undergrad QM whom provided no notes, I could barely understand anything he said, and he just said to use L&L as the course book when people asked for help. I spent hours trying to read it but it was utterly useless. Worst studying experience I ever had
- orthoxerox 3y agoAs the joke goes, one morning Livshitz was riding a tram to work, someone pushed him and he dropped his manuscript into the mud, ruining a few pages. When he arrived at the lab, he complained to Landau that he would have to spend the whole day rewriting the proof of a tricky theorem because the middle part was now gone, but Landau suggested simply to put "from which it is obvious that" there instead.
- 3y ago
- i-use-nixos-btw 3y agoIt’s a strange feeling reading Ioffe’s memoir. When I was a physics undergraduate, I understood the mentality. The high-maintenance asshole professor was exactly who I’d be drawn towards. I learned how unhealthy that was, and many of those who didn’t ended up burning out HARD. Landau was the rare asshole whose ability to hone students was worth the abuse. And reading this, I found myself in the frame of mind of “yeah, in that scenario, I’d absolutely work my ass off just to be in that guy’s favour”. Years training myself out of that unhealthy mentality and boom, a few pages of memoir and I’m back in that naive frame of mind.
- elteto 3y agoWe are seduced and captivated by raw genius. I’m sure Landau was one of the highest caliber. To pass his examination, to be well regarded by him, to be part of such a select group, who wouldn’t want to? Don’t be hard on yourself.
- sdenton4 3y agoI don't even know that it's even raw genius - our brains are full of 'ape shit' which at times includes close attention to hierarchy. Seems likely to be a combination of charisma, ape-dominance, and enough smarts to be a good physics researcher.
- ogurechny 3y agoMany groups that select people for arbitrary reasons exist. Sure, here we see external cause and zealous dedication, but those things don't automatically make anything good. We then have to decide whether “advancement of scientific knowledge” should be seen as some kind of royal mantle (and by whom). And so on, and so forth. It is easier to compare it to professional sport. Not only athletes have natural talents, they also participate in training that would be useless or harmful for everyone else. Only then they can reach the record setting zone.
- freefaler 3y agoWhat memoir you're referring to? A.Ioffe didn't write one as far as my research shows. My bad... Boris Ioffe (not related to A. Ioffe) has indeed written a memoir: Иоффе Б. Л. Без ретуши. Портреты физиков на фоне эпохи. —М.: ФАЗИС, 2004; 160 с. ISBN 5-7036-0088-Х
- beefman 3y agoSusskind taught a series of courses at Stanford Continuing Studies called The Theoretical Minimum, in homage to Landau. The lectures are all on YouTube https://theoreticalminimum.com/ https://theoreticalminimum.com/
- bryan0 3y agoThere’s also an excellent series of books by Susskind of the same name.
- majikaja 3y agoI don't like how so many textbooks and university courses teach physics like it's a bunch of theories that popped out of nowhere to be memorized.