3 ms·
> I'm pretty sure the actual reason the Content ID and copyright strike system exists because Google was tired of getting sued by everybody. The way the DMCA w
by AnthonyMouse 3y ago
> I'm pretty sure the actual reason the Content ID and copyright strike system exists because Google was tired of getting sued by everybody.
The way the DMCA was supposed to work, the claimant submits a notice and the site takes it down, the user submits a counternotice and the site puts it back up, and now if the claimant still wants to proceed, the site has nothing to do with it anymore and they go to court against the user.
But the users don't have any money, and there are tons of them, so instead they went to court against the site. Which is the exact thing the DMCA was supposed to prevent.
Part of the reason for this is that pre-Google YouTube did some shady things that gave them an excuse. But then we have the other problem with the law. If you screw up, the penalties are unreasonable, which allows litigious plaintiffs to extract unreasonable concessions. And the same is true even if you didn't screw up, because the alternative is to spend a crazy amount of money on lawyers because the stakes are high.