3 ms·
Opposing abortion and same sex marriage is a pretty poor strategy of getting “picked.” The white people who own everything and run everything hate Thomas more f
by rayiner 3y ago
Opposing abortion and same sex marriage is a pretty poor strategy of getting “picked.” The white people who own everything and run everything hate Thomas more for that than they do for any views he has on regulation or taxes.
Calling Thomas a “pick me” is comic book villain levels of racist. Have you ever been to the Georgia coast where Thomas grew up? Being religious and traditionalist, and even believing in bootstraps more than government, makes Thomas a typical member of his Gullah community. The only contrarian thing about him is following those beliefs to supporting the Republican Party. And even that’s not unusual. If you consider Thomas as an individual—not just a black person, but a black man from the rural south who worked his way up from poverty to the upper echelons of society—you’ll find many of the double-digit percentage of black men who voted for Trump.
And that’s the problem with having elite whites curate diversity. They don’t want a representative sampling of minorities. They want minorities who reject their own communities in the ways white elites agree with, like Obama or Ilhan Omar.
- Spivak 3y ago[flagged]
- skissane 3y ago> He literally overturned the case that protected interracial marriage and then half-heartedly tried to carve it out for himself. He "literally" overturned what? The constitutional right to interracial marriage was established by Loving v Virginia (1967). That case has never been overturned, and Justice Thomas has never said he has any interest in overturning it. I assume you are talking about his concurrence in Dobbs v Jackson Women’s Health (2022), which overturned Roe v Wade (1973). Loving doesn't directly depend on Roe, especially given Loving came 5½ years earlier. The reasoning in those two cases was distinct, so overturning one does not necessarily imply overturning the other. SCOTUS only decides cases presented to it. Even supposing every single justice wanted to overturn Loving (and I see no evidence any of them actually do want to overturn it), the only way it could be overturned would be if a case was appealed up to SCOTUS seeking to do so. Since currently no states have laws against interracial marriage on the books (Alabama was the last to repeal theirs in 2000), that would require first a state to pass a new law against interracial marriage. The odds of any state doing that in the next 50 years is almost zero, so the odds that SCOTUS will ever get asked whether to overturn Loving or not is close to zero. Whatever any of the justices may think about the rights or wrongs of that case in theory is practically irrelevant. That's a very different situation from Obergefell – many states still have laws against same-sex marriage on the books, so all it would take to get a case revisiting Obergefell before SCOTUS would be for a state to decide to disregard Obergefell and start enforcing those laws again. Nobody knows whether that's actually going to happen, but it is plausible in a way that reintroducing laws against interracial marriage isn't.
- Spivak 3y agoAnd all it takes is one state to pass one and they're in the same situation as the gays. Their reasoning isn't all that distinct, Row, Loving, and Obergefell are all based on the constitutional protection that is now gone. If such a law was passed it would be upheld as constitutional. And Thomas knows this which is why in the opinion he invented some flimsy reasoning as to why interracial marriage has some deeper history in the US than gays being life partners. I'm not really sure what you're arguing, I think we're saying the same thing. More people are against gay marriage than interracial marriage but lord knows that crowd isn't gone by a long shot.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- skissane 3y ago> And all it takes is one state to pass one and they're in the same situation as the gays. Their reasoning isn't all that distinct, Row, Loving, and Obergefell are all based on the constitutional protection that is now gone. If such a law was passed it would be upheld as constitutional. And Thomas knows this which is why in the opinion he invented some flimsy reasoning as to why interracial marriage has some deeper history in the US than gays being life partners. When the 14th Amendment was being proposed and ratified, there was a lot of debate about whether it entailed a constitutional right to interracial marriage. Its opponents argued that it did, and – since they believed that interracial marriage was a bad thing that ought to be illegal – they therefore argued the Amendment should be rejected. Most of its supporters agreed with its opponents that interracial marriage was a bad thing that ought to be illegal; but they disagreed that the text of the 14th Amendment entailed any constitutional right to it. (There were likely some 14th Amendment supporters who did believe that it implied a constitutional right to interracial marriage–but they were smart enough to keep their mouths shut, they didn't want to hurt its chances.) So, Loving v Virginia would not have been that surprising to people alive at the time of Amendment's adoption, because it was simply a consequence predicted by some at the time eventually coming to pass. But I don't think anyone in 1866–1868 could have foreseen Roe or Obergefell. Therefore, it is arguable that Loving possesses a textual-historical plausibility (it is what some people thought the text meant at the time of its adoption) which Roe and Obergefell lack (nobody at the time of the text's adoption would have ever thought it meant either.) So, if someone has a judicial philosophy which puts a great deal of emphasis on how the text was understood at the time of its adoption, they do have a rational basis for distinguishing Loving from Roe and Obergefell.
- rayiner 3y ago> It's a great strategy if you want to be backed by Republicans And why would he want to do that? As a Yale graduate and lawyer, the easiest thing in the world for Thomas to do would have been to appeal to liberal whites—who make up 90% of his peers. They are the ones who run nearly all law firms, every law school, etc. What I’m earth do you think he gets out of being the favorite Supreme Court justice of plumbers in Iowa? > You can find them in every minority group that are, let's call it disfavored, by the Republicans. Given that 40% of Hispanics and Asians voted GOP in 2022, and black men are slowly but increasingly doing so, that’s a lot of “pick mes.” Or, maybe, as actual racism in society decreases, people are voting more with their values and less by their skin color. > Ingratiating yourself to your oppressors has never stopped the oppression. Who are the “oppressors?” Where do you think the profits from slavery and segregation went? They went to Wall Street banks (who are the limited partners that bankroll Silicon Valley), Harvard’s endowment, etc. The “oppressors” are not plumbers in Iowa. > I could care less about his political views If you’re going to accuse someone of being a “pick me,” his political views matter, don’t they? Otherwise you’re just criticizing him for voting along with the party that reflects the stuff he believes. > Oh come on, this is a joke right? You really don't see Thomas as exactly what you're describing? He's the black Republican figurehead. How is that different from minorities who reject their parents’ values to ingratiate themselves to white liberals? I see woke, white-assimilated asians supporting discrimination against themselves in order to ingratiate themselves to the white liberals around them. Meanwhile, my first-generation parents (who are democrats) emailed me the minute SFFA came out to tell me what a relief it was. White liberals made intersectional activists like Ilhan Omar the face of Islam in American. Meanwhile, among actual Muslim Americans: https://news.gallup.com/poll/112807/blacks-conservative-republicans-some-moral-issues.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/112807/blacks-conservative-repu... > He literally overturned the case that protected interracial marriage and then half-heartedly tried to carve it out for himself. The white paternalism is blinding. What you’re saying is that white liberals are right about everything, and it’s more important for black people to support them than to represent the range of views that actually exist in the black community: https://news.gallup.com/poll/112807/blacks-conservative-republicans-some-moral-issues.aspx https://news.gallup.com/poll/112807/blacks-conservative-repu....
- Spivak 3y ago