5 ms·
> If there are seven proven ways to success and your teacher can only show you the fourth best way, that still beats the two hundred ways leading to nowhere pre
by crazygringo 3y ago
> If there are seven proven ways to success and your teacher can only show you the fourth best way, that still beats the two hundred ways leading to nowhere presented to you on the Internet.
My experience is exactly the opposite. Most teachers are about the same level as you'd get from a random blog post (since these are often the people writing those blog posts). But with the internet, you can find the absolute best book or video or tutorial in the whole world that blows your local teacher out of the water.
The only exceptions where a teacher is essential are areas where you learn by doing and being critiqued, not by reading/watching. E.g. instrument/voice lessons, team sports, dancing, acting, etc. Or when you're close to the top of your field and the remaining knowledge is only in top experts' heads because they haven't written it down yet.
- probably_wrong 3y ago> you can find the absolute best book or video or tutorial in the whole world My complaint in these cases is that yes, I can find it, but I would first have to know what I'm looking for and yet I have no way to recognize what the best book is. If I wanted to learn about Sparta, I would have no way of knowing whether Paul Cartledge's book is better than Stephen Hodkinson's or Steven Pressfield's. And God help me if one of them has a loyal Twitter following spamming 5-star reviews everywhere...
- crazygringo 3y agoBut that's just called research. If you want to learn about Sparta, it's pretty easy to find blog posts or reddit threads about what the best book is, or to find the multi-paragraph reviews on Amazon and Goodreads and see what they say, or professional book reviews of them. So you absolutely do have a way of knowing. What you usually don't have a reliable way of knowing is how good of a teacher on Sparta a local history teacher happens to be. And the answer is usually, not good enough to write a book on it.
- mbrameld 3y ago> But that's just called research. If you want to learn about Sparta, it's pretty easy to find blog posts or reddit threads about what the best book is, or to find the multi-paragraph reviews on Amazon and Goodreads and see what they say, or professional book reviews of them. > So you absolutely do have a way of knowing. As long as you already know enough about Sparta to be able to tell whether those blog posts, Reddit threads, and Amazon and Goodreads reviews are legit or spam. > What you usually don't have a reliable way of knowing is how good of a teacher on Sparta a local history teacher happens to be. Are you saying you honestly can't think of a way to vet a local teacher? How about taking to their students? > And the answer is usually, not good enough to write a book on it. Which, coincidentally, can be said for most authors as well, but that doesn't stop them from writing a book and then flooding the internet with blog posts, Reddit threads, and Amazon and Goodreads reviews about how good it is.
- crazygringo 3y ago> As long as you already know enough about Sparta to be able to tell whether those blog posts, Reddit threads, and Amazon and Goodreads reviews are legit or spam. Nope, it's more of just a generalized credibility/bullshit detector. It has zero to do with the topic at hand. This is a major life skill that is important to develop. > Are you saying you honestly can't think of a way to vet a local teacher? How about taking to their students? You can figure out if they're good at teaching as a general skill (although contacting a bunch of students who are willing to take the time to talk to you is a lot of work). It's quite difficult to suss out their actual knowledgeability, however. For example, you can find a local moral philosophy professor who is well-liked, but who will teach everything through a lens of Kantianism and disparage consequentialism and never even mention virtue ethics. And you could spend 50 hours of private tutoring and never know you were receiving major bias and being left with huge gaps -- something unlikely to happen if you spent the same time carefully reading a couple of well-respected intro textbooks on the subject. > ...and then flooding the internet... See above about credibility/bullshit detection. Remember, don't look at average stars or anything like that, look for posts/reviews that go in-depth where you can tell the reviewer knows what they're talking about, and then look for consistent commonalities between posts.
- rg111 3y agoThis is why there are forums and places like Reddit (RIP?) and Quora (RIP). I come from a really small town and made it further than anyone I know in that town in tech. (Not in terms of money, though) Just Google: "best books on Sparta reddit". You will find 10 threads, and on those threads if you look at top-k, you will see some entries recurring. And two-three lines of explanation. Read a non-trivial amount of sections to know whether it is what you are looking for. Library is a good place. You can also check Google Books or pirate before buying. Not only about books but about MOOCs, YT playlists, and so on. I have used this method since Junior year in High School, straight up to Master’s degree. I always got good grades, many times topped the class.
- cgriswald 3y agoSuppose you farm out this decision about which book is best to your teacher. How do you know your teacher selected the best book? How did you find your teacher?
- PragmaticPulp 3y ago> But with the internet, you can find the absolute best book or video or tutorial in the whole world that blows your local teacher out of the water. I’ve done a lot of mentoring, including through some formal programs. One of my biggest challenges has been students/mentees who find a very convincing blog post or video from a confident, polished writer, then mistake that person’s confidence for absolute authority on a subject. The worst example I can think of is the world of JavaScript training influencers. These people produce courses and training material for sale, then heavily use social media to promote their material as the canonical source of truth in the field. These influencers can be very persuasive, confident, and relentless in their advertising. They have an incentive to present their material as flawlessly correct and exaggerate or invent problems with other ways of doing things. The result is juniors who have taken some overpriced online JavaScript course who are utterly convinced their knowledge is superior to that of the 10-plus years of experience of people around them. They’re off on some tangent trying to rewrite part of the codebase in some new framework/tool/language that their influencers said was the “best”. They won’t accept that there are multiple ways to solve problems or that some times the correct engineering solution is to use a simpler framework even if it’s not trending on Twitter. It’s almost a rite of passage for some juniors to go all-in on their preferred internet sources and assume that what they read is superior to the real-world experience of the engineers they work with.
- cgriswald 3y agoStudents can learn The One True Way from their teachers as well. I think that has more to do with who is learning and who is teaching than it has to do with whether they learned from a teacher or from a video.
- mhb 3y agoDoesn't the same potential problem exist regarding the selection of a personal teacher? And the same potential solution.
- nyokodo 3y ago> It’s almost a rite of passage for some juniors to go all-in on their preferred internet sources As long as it’s kept in check I think it’s practically a necessary development stage for many. Everyone needs a starting point from where they evaluate and integrate other values and perspectives. Humility and pragmatism are learned through the process.
- sanderjd 3y agoSoftware engineering also belongs on your "doing and being critiqued" list.
- bastawhiz 3y ago> But with the internet, you can find the absolute best book or video or tutorial in the whole world that blows your local teacher out of the water. To agree with you to some extent, the author fails to consider that you're often not looking for random unrelated things. Finding one really great answer online often provides you with a really great resource for other really great answers.
- hyperthesis 3y agoMisconceptions are insidious because you don't know what you don't know (e.g. boneappletea, france is bacon). A private tutor, coach-like, can observe and correct, and fill in gaps. I think this applies to all fields of endeavour. It won't make you smarter, but gives you a foundation for the next level - where, maybe, some intuitive smarts of yours will shine. Now, the only problem is simply finding a good tutor. You just need to know if they know what you don't know you don't know.
- cgriswald 3y ago> The only exceptions where a teacher is essential are areas where you learn by doing and being critiqued, not by reading/watching. E.g. instrument/voice lessons… I don’t think this is an exception. Record yourself doing these things and critique yourself. It’s not as valuable as having multiple people critique you, but it’s not less valuable than having one other stranger critique you. Until you gain a certain level of competence you’ll know where and how you suck. I’m currently learning bass guitar and recording myself has been incredibly valuable for seeing and hearing things I don’t notice when I’m playing. I think it’s also sort of closed the gap between what I think I sound like and how I actually sound when I play. (I’d recommend it even if you get a teacher.) my only teachers have been online videos and web pages. I can’t see how a teacher can add value here. If I got one, I’d most likely be learning the teacher’s way. I’m finding a lot of value in hearing multiple POVs, trying it all out, finding what works for me and whose opinions I should value. The article says teachers are faster, but I can evaluate online video sources much faster and more easily than I can evaluate teachers. I might not learn faster but I certainly learn more and at a deeper level, because my mind is engaged in every part of the process. As an aside, I think teachers often gloss over things that they think don’t matter right now. You’re getting a short cut, but you either miss out on something or later have to learn how that thing connects to what you know. Often, I find taking a moment to learn a little bit about that thing can aid you on your overall goal.
- mtalantikite 3y agoI think one of the issues is that there can be a significant gap in the level of teachers that you encounter. There are tons of teachers out there that are probably not much better, and maybe even worse, than going through people on YouTube, personal websites, online courses, etc. But then there are the truly masterful teachers in which the experience is on a whole different level, where the learning is beyond what you could do on your own. It's more on the level of a traditional guru, in the original sense of the word [1]. I've had both experiences, and I agree, in most cases a private teacher might not be worth it, but if you find the right person, it'll bring you way further than you ever could have gone on your own. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guru https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guru
- fn-mote 3y agoI read a lot of discussion here that focuses on learning as some kind of basic skill acquisition. How to I learn Rust? How to I learn to speak conversational Japanese? Other topics require judgement, the weighing of alternatives. Sometimes there is no clear winner. When you just need to know a fact, searching online or asking GPT is a good way to go. I haven't had good luck learning higher level concepts this way. One example: how would you discover an idea like "don't repeat yourself" if you didn't know it? There's a school of thought that says you'll learn it when you need it, but I'm not so sure - I think you can make faster progress if someone guides you through several complex improvements at once. Another example: say you're writing a networked game and you are communicating some basic information but you are also communicating inforation that is derived from the basic information (and hence is unnecessary to send). How do you learn this is inelegant, "repeating yourself", a waste of bandwidth? A critique from a mentor would clue you in right away.
- cm2012 3y agoThe problem is every teacher who has the skills to teach you something valuable can make more money just doing that thing.
- clnq 3y agoIt can't always be reduced to a zero-sum game. If one teaches their team to perform well, everyone on the team benefits.
- thfuran 3y agoAnd you're under the impression that everyone is just an income-maximization agent?
- cm2012 3y agoThere's tons of exceptions. But there's a reason people who graduate with teaching degrees have the lowest SAT scores of pretty much any major/discipline.
- Given_47 3y agoNot denying the validity of that but if we agree that “teaching” as the ability to relay unintuitive concepts in a way relevant to the student, there’s not an section on standardized tests where that burgeoning skill would be detectable. A teacher obviously has to have some baseline level of intellect/subject knowledge but so much of teaching is everything else (eg pertinent examples, optimally sequencing lessons, illustrating how things fit together etc). Anecdotal but similarly in sports it seems like many of the best coaches were career role players and given their lesser talent, have a much better understanding of the myriad techniques that aided their development. Whereas someone like lebron (not saying he’d be a bad coach) is so inherently talented he probably has less of a grasp on communication because it comes so naturally. The passing reads he was making as a junior in high school were more advanced than most of the NBA today lol. And learning is exponential so I don’t think it’s a teacher job to lead you all the way there just far along enough so anyone with enough aptitude can figure out the rest themselves. I could just be trying to further validate my belief but I almost think it’s dangerous to inherit the entirely of someone else’s knowledge since every view we develop is influenced to some extent by our own life experiences. Also just for diversity of thought
- light_hue_1 3y agoOne on one a good teacher is far more effective than even the world's best book or video. As a child I was taught one on one when I had trouble. It really got me unstuck as needed. I still remember some of those lessons fondly. I used to teach one on one for pay. I've taken the worst cs student in class and in a few weeks made them well above average. I've helped people pass math classes that they were completely failing at in just a few hours. This isn't anything special. And now teaching my PhD students one on one I know each very well. I know what they know, what they tend to miss, and no amount of online videos or books will be better than a tailored explanation designed just for them where I recast a tricky problem into one that they already know. You haven't experienced a good teacher one on one.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- BeetleB 3y agoThe purpose of the teacher is to tell you which book or tutorial or video is worth it.
- clnq 3y ago> But with the internet, you can find the absolute best book or video or tutorial in the whole world that blows your local teacher out of the water. You can find the absolute best teacher in the whole world.