3 ms·
What's different about a "better" insulin varies considerably. It's definitely not true that somehow the "better" products are just magically safer, although I'
by tialaramex 3y ago
What's different about a "better" insulin varies considerably. It's definitely not true that somehow the "better" products are just magically safer, although I'm sure their vendors are happy that you think so. You talk about them being "Often longer-acting" they of course provide a range of different periods and this is one of claimed advantages. For some people I'm sure that's valuable.
My grandmother, for example, would not have been able to successfully use a product which expects you to have a smartphone (she was barely confident with a telephone, and the introduction of touch tone dialling confused her). So whilst I'm sure it's convenient if you're diagnosed age 17 and you can just add it to the phone you always carry anyway, it's not simply "Better", yet several of the modern products need to be used that way.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8406912/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8406912/ is from way back when you might still find humans using animal insulin in the US. The manufacturers presented the (synthetic) human insulin as simply "better" but if it's "better" it's not so dramatic that actual experiments had successfully identified a clear improvement that this meta-analysis saw.
The most important element of success with typical long term medical interventions is almost inevitably the patient actually implementing the treatment plan. That's true for pregnancy prevention (turns out neither condoms nor the pill work if you don't use them), it's true for Thyroxine (I have to take a pill every morning, for the rest of my life, people tried the evening, that'd work in theory but most of them forget) and it's true for insulin. If the $5000 drug doesn't help you actually take it when and how you're supposed to, it has no benefit. If the cheap treatment fits your lifestyle, even if it seems ludicrous to onlookers ("You use the old paper strips? That's so stone age") more expensive is not, in fact, better.