4 ms·
its ridiculous people still have a hard-on for the nordic model. they just think "how clever! we solved it ya'll!" any effort rooted in the prohibition of sex
by yieldcrv 3y ago
its ridiculous people still have a hard-on for the nordic model. they just think "how clever! we solved it ya'll!"
any effort rooted in the prohibition of sex work will harm workers, and these efforts are based on enacting their discomfort with men having increased access to transactional sex as a normal option.
this model simply exacerbates trafficking by removing one of the main ways exploitation is reported at all - by workers confiding in customers they've built rapport with!
it has to be harmonized as a labor issue, rooted in harm reduction.
edit: there it is
>“The point of this whole thing is to decrease the demand for commercial sex,” said Maine state Rep. Lois Reckitt, D., who sponsored the bill,
- justrealist 3y agoTrafficking and abuse is still a big problem in Amsterdam. There's no magic solution.
- yieldcrv 3y agocorrect, a labor rights issue. just like labor trafficking is still a big problem .... everywhere. tackling this as a commercial sex issue debilitates avenues for addressing labor rights issues.
- 111111IIIIIII 3y ago[flagged]
- briantakita 3y ago> False. Human labor trafficking receives high praise from the global ruling class for its excellent profitability. It is also an effective tool to blackmail willing & unwilling lawmakers, corporate heads, & officials to control policy.
- 111111IIIIIII 3y agoFair point. It is a fabulous means for the pursuit of both profit and power.
- speleding 3y agoTrafficking and abuse are a problem in Amsterdam. But there is good reason to believe that the problem is a bit smaller than in jurisdictions where prostitutes have to hide from law enforcement. (There have been several studies evaluating the effectiveness of Dutch regulation, but comparing the relatively accurate numbers from the Dutch police force with the guesstimates from countries where prostitution isn't legal, means that conclusions are pretty soft).
- LorenPechtel 3y agoYeah, the data is very lacking. However, there's a huge advantage to a legal transaction in that if something goes wrong the wronged party need not fear going to the police. It's much better for disputes to be settled in court than by violence.
- newaccount74 3y ago> workers confiding in customers they've built rapport with Everything I've read about prostitution makes me think this never happens. Johns just don't help prostitutes. "Pretty Woman" isn't a documentary.
- pyuser583 3y agoEuropeans tried legalizing sex work. It didn’t work.
- resolutebat 3y agoCitation needed. "Europe", even within the EU, also has a great deal of variation, ranging from effectively complete legalization in places like Switzerland and Germany to the Swedish model of aggressively prosecuting customers and countries where selling it is illegal as well.
- pyuser583 3y agoSorry I should clarify. Until the 19th century, prostitution was legal basically everywhere. Since then Europeans have gone back and forth between kind of legal to kind of illegal. It really does vary a lot. But the historical acceptance and modern ambivalence is pretty common.
- sureglymop 3y agoThe parent comment already mentioned that "Europeans" is too broad of a generalisation. It would he just as unwise to claim "the US has legalized sex work" due to this headline which clearly is not about the whole of the USA.
- fdsio 3y agoDecriminalising prostitution, providing support services to prostitutes, and making the buying of people for sex illegal is harm reduction. This Maine law doesn't go far enough in that there's no provision for structured support to help those who are prostituted exit the sex trade.
- yieldcrv 3y agowho are prostituted? assumes no agency, does your assumption assume the prevalence of independent people that are not trafficked?
- fdsio 3y agoProviding support services to those who desire to exit the sex trade broadens the options available to those in prostitution. It increases their agency by providing an alternative path, that is their choice to take or not take.
- yieldcrv 3y agoI agree with that, your original post was phrased in an odd way, I dont think making buying illegal is a great solution as making that part legal is also harm reduction.
- ernst_klim 3y agoIt's not ridiculous at all, just a blatant and obvious example of populist policy. Just like war on drugs or subsidizing demand to counter real estate price increase. With issues where people go emotional politics often goes this way, and the social pressure makes quality research nearly impossible, leading to decades of populism like that with little to no reasonable discussion, not to mention decent scientific inquiry.