4 ms·
> the law doesn’t appear designed to be enforced by the state: It appears to create a “private right of action” that would allow individual litigants to sue if
by paxys 3y ago
> the law doesn’t appear designed to be enforced by the state: It appears to create a “private right of action” that would allow individual litigants to sue if they felt they, or more likely their children, had been harmed by viewing such content online.
This is the worst part of it. More and more states are going to turn to this kind of lawmaking and enforcement now that the supreme court set the precedent with the Texas abortion law.
- nashashmi 3y agoWow, that is a very clever law. It avoids the state being responsible on preventing access to certain information. Yet directly holds the site responsible if people get hurt. Well crafted law.
- Terr_ 3y agoThe whole basis is deeply disturbing, since it is basically a kind of half-deputized vigilantism the state governments are using in order to avoid the usual checks and balances. All the same corrupt building-blocks could be used to punish people for having the wrong religion.
- motbus3 3y agoThat's definitely it. No one will publicly question the creation of mechanisms that will be use for censorship if you are "protecting children". If politicians really cared about children they would have invested much more on education.
- halJordan 3y agoPrivate rights of action are not disturbing and I believe you feel that way because you only hear about them in the context of heretical anti-abortion or puritanical prudishness. Both of which are only supported by those nasty others. I, at least, am unwilling to surrender my hipaa private right of action or my securities fraud private rights of action or my ADA private rights of action. How about Epic's right of private action against Apple? Believe it or not, but there's a private right of action against monopolies. No one is a vigilante because they sue a business over being handicap inaccessible.
- Terr_ 3y agoNo, if someone's saying it's all about private rights of action, that's a strawman which ignores: 1. The radical removal of standing requirements. Since when did laws like HIPAA or the ADA ever allow totally random people to sue a hospital "on your behalf", let alone be able to demand $10k from the target to keep it all for themselves!? 2. The farcical idea that regular checks-and-balances and judicial-review don't apply, simply because the legislature claims it delegated alllll enforcement to private individuals, despite still being responsible for, y'know, making the dang law.
- smcameron 3y agoSo how are these litigants going to prove that little Johnny got hurt by looking at nekkid ladies? The idea that kids get hurt just by looking at nudity seems a little far fetched to me.
- fluidcruft 3y agoAs far as I know the US Supreme Court has not even looked at the civil enforcement aspect of the Texas law (yet), so there is no precedent.