4 ms·
> Biden must really like this decision. He has never really supported large scale forgiveness and does want repayments to start again. Yes, that’s why he immed
by dragonwriter 3y ago
> Biden must really like this decision. He has never really supported large scale forgiveness and does want repayments to start again.
Yes, that’s why he immediately launched the process to redo debt relief this time under HEA rather than HEROES authority before the ink was dry on the ruling, just announced a payment on-ramp that reduces the impact of failure to pay after the Congressionally-mandated end of the pause, and has used other regulatory authority to launch a new income-based repayment program which will lead to $0 payments for low-income student loan debtors.
- synetic 3y agoThe impression I’ve had is that he is against broad forgiveness and does want repayments to start again. It’s been a political minefield in that he doesn’t want to piss off his base. It appears my impression is wrong but I do believe he wants repayments to start again. Note though that the $10,000 forgiveness is less than what he campaigned on. We should not confuse, in general, new program initiatives as an indication that this is what the politician proposing the initiative wants. Sometimes proposals have to be made to appease the base.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> The impression I’ve had is that he is against broad forgiveness and does want repayments to start again. Okay, but what is the basis for this impression? > Note though that the $10,000 forgiveness is less than what he campaigned on. The $10,000-$20,000 foregiveness plan (with an income cap) is less universal the “at least” $10,000 he called on Congress to provide all borrowers during the campaign, as President-elect after the campaign, and sought (but was rebuffed on) as President in the stimulus bill. It's what he thought he could justify as executive action under HEROES (and even that turned out to be wrong), not what he wanted. > We should not confuse, in general, new program initiatives as an indication that this is what the politician proposing the initiative wants. Absent specific, articulable, evidence-based reasons to believe otherwise, we certainly should take them as exactly that, especially when they keep coming back with different approaches when rebuffed. > Sometimes proposals have to be made to appease the base. Yes, but the claim that any particular proposal is merely a sop to the base should be backed by evidence; the fact that it is sometimes true does not, by itself, support ascribing that basis to any particular policy proposal.
- synetic 3y agoI agreed that I was wrong. I think you missed that part. Absent specific, articulable, evidence-based reasons to believe otherwise, we certainly should take them as exactly that, especially when they keep coming back with different approaches when rebuffed. No. This is way too impractical. You yourself don’t follow this criteria. I suggest you read up on hunches, gut feelings, and things like that. Give you an example. It was always clear that Republican politicians, as a whole, didn’t want to get rid of Obamacare because Obamacare was a Republican plan all along. They blustered and said they’d get rid of it but when they had control of both houses and the Presidency they didn’t get rid of it. I can’t point to a specific thing that gave me the impression they would not actually get rid of it but I was certain they wouldn’t follow through. People, especially politicians, can’t be taken at their word just because one doesn’t have specific, articulable, evidence based reasons. If you really operate in real life this way then you are a dupe.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> No. This is way too impractical. You yourself don’t follow this criteria. Yes, I do. > I suggest you read up on hunches, gut feelings, and things like that. They are very good aids in deciding when to expend more effort looking for facts, they aren’t on their own a great basis for conclusions and even less for public arguments for those conclusions. > It was always clear that Republican politicians, as a whole, didn’t want to get rid of Obamacare because Obamacare was a Republican plan all along. See, that's a specific, articulable reason for the belief that it was an insincere desire. (A bad one, IMO, and one which is counterindicated not only by specific other evidence regarding the mechanics by which they sought to destroy it, but also by the fact that it wasn’t a Republican plan, and by the specific times and contexts similar, but different, plans had been embraced by Republicans, and by the plans Republicans, and the industry from whom the similar plans once embraced by Republicans had gotten the plans in the first place, had moved on to in the interim, but that's a whole different argument.) > People, especially politicians, can’t be taken at their word Substantive policy actions are different than mere words.
- 3y ago