3 ms·
"marketing departments that take a broad look at the numbers their network can ideally handle and conclude that [...]" "the power users or edge cases to these
by ajross 15y ago
"marketing departments that take a broad look at the numbers their network can ideally handle and conclude that [...]"
"the power users or edge cases to these hypothetical usage models break down that service offering"
I don't see how you can write the former and then get the culpability
so wrong in the latter. It's not the "power users" or "edge cases"
that broke the model, it's that the model was wrong. AT&T thought
they could offer "unlimited" service at a certain price, and they were
wrong. And rather than honor it and lose money, or change their
pricing and lose customers, they are cheating with a throttle.
I'm sorry, but that is malicious. They're playing with the dictionary definition of "unlimited" instead of offering their customers the service they promised.
- TheCapn 15y agoMy apologies for my poor explanation. You're entirely correct with what you've said. The model they employ certainly is broken if it doesn't account for the possibility that not everyone falls into their ideal customer. When I said that "it is not malicious" I really should have stated that it is not with malicious intent. A marketing manager doesn't create offerings that they feel will piss off the customer base because a child could tell you that unhappy customers == churn and by extension churn == less marketing jobs as the company shrinks. I merely wanted to provide a perspective as to what sort of train of thought is followed regardless of how logical it may be.
- ajross 15y agoOK, agreed. It's not a bait and switch. AT&T honestly believed their pricing was sound. I believe that too.
- Terretta 15y agoI don't, not for a minute. Look at how the AT&T iPad plans changed a month after launch. That was not a usage based decision, and it takes longer for a company their size to create the materials than the time between launch and the change. They've known what they were doing, and considered these actions a viable contingency.