5 ms·
Do good products fail to take off on their own because advertising is an absolute necessity, or is it because advertising allows bad products to saturate the ma
by lolinder 3y ago
Do good products fail to take off on their own because advertising is an absolute necessity, or is it because advertising allows bad products to saturate the market so thoroughly? In a hypothetical world without advertising, would it still be true that good products couldn't take off on their own merits? Or would they spread effectively by word of mouth in the absence of the noise generated by the advertising industry?
I don't have an answer to this question, it's purely hypothetical. And even if it is true that in this hypothetical world, good products would spread, we're still left with a prisoner's dilemma to resolve in the real world.
- cryptoz 3y agoI've been thinking about this comment for a few minutes and do find it interesting. But the extremes of the comments and quotes above make it clear that even displaying your product is an ad; demonstrating how it works to a crowd would be an ad; telling someone that it exists would be an ad; there seems to be no way to tell the market that your product exists without that being defined as an ad. So I would answer you with, given the extremes defined above, that indeed advertising is a necessity since good products would otherwise rot inside the inventor's home. It being illegal (say, for example) to have ads would mean that it is illegal to even tell anyone that you invented a product. I think there's got to be some kind of give from the anti-ad side if we want to have _things_ in the world that do stuff - because if I can't even say "I made a better product that does x,y,z" then how the heck is anyone ever gonna find out about it? Where does the word-of-mouth kick off even? You gotta _tell_ people you made something - but that's an ad.
- gAI 3y agoSo I've been producing ads for a couple of decades, and I agree that they're basically psychological warfare. I justify it to myself because I usually get to make ads for products that help people, but the war over mindshare is absolutely depraved. That said, there does need to be a place for people to access information about products and services. I'd just prefer it be a place that people go to intentionally learn about products and services, rather than something ingrained in every aspect of modern life.
- roenxi 3y agoSo I suppose where you are coming from is that you're using dirty tricks to convince people who don't need a product to buy it. Which is not ideal. But I've seen a lot of software engineers write code that is unreliable and causes their users a lot of suffering. Most people do a bit of harm on the margins because their job is part of messy reality instead of some imaginary pure world. On average the amount of trickery in advertising will cancel out and decisions still get made based on the quality and usefulness of the products. It is just much easier to sell something useful with sneaky advertising than selling advertising in a vacuum. People not knowing about their options is one of the bigger problems in modern life. There are a lot of things I'd spend money on to change and I'm just not sure how to do it. As far as I can tell that is normal. "I'd just prefer it be a place that people go to intentionally learn about products and services" - when I see people doing that I'll believe it is an option. Most people sit there until told to do something. Even when doing the thing is in their own interests.
- gAI 3y agoIt's not so much about any particular ad or product, but the attention that ads steal. Most peoples' heads are FULL of ad jingles they never wanted there.
- polygamous_bat 3y ago> On average the amount of trickery in advertising will cancel out and decisions still get made based on the quality and usefulness of the products. How? Take the examples from above about selling beauty products to teenagers, where is the ad saying "you're perfect as you are, no need to drop hundreds of dollars on any of this bullshit"? All the ads in existence will try to extract money from them by playing up body image issues, so the noise WILL NOT cancel out on their own. > Most people sit there until told to do something. Even when doing the thing is in their own interests. To think that you know what's better for people than they know for themselves... Tell me, are you an advertising professional? Because your thought process is just as obnoxious.
- roenxi 3y ago
- prox 3y agoOne of my clients make really good products. I would say the best you can get (this is a mobility product) It has ergonomic properties that blows away any competition, and build quality is second to none. However, it’s expensive. It has been a really tough uphill climb to connect to our audience and convince them the money is worth it here. In a market with marked up shitty quality products it has been a journey to position ourselves, especially since our budgets are maybe 1/10th of that of aforementioned shitty producers who outmarket us. I honestly feel the work I am doing is near to a community service. Although still advertising our ads are honest of what the products can do.
- _aavaa_ 3y ago> You gotta _tell_ people you made something. I think that the rest of your discussion hinges on this assumption, and I completely disagree with it. What you need actually is for people to know that your product exist. People have needs & problem beyond the fake ones created by advertising. People can _ask_ for what options exist to solve their problem. And that to me is fundamentally different. Having a way for consumers to go out and pull information in about what options exist is fundamentally different from having advertising shoved down their throat.
- andsoitis 3y ago> People need can _ask_ for what options exist to solve their problem. Where do you propose people ask? Who would fulfill those queries? What formats would you allow the information to be expressed in? Would you filter out any non-objective characterization (“best car in the world”)? Would you constrain packaging (eg color, creativity, etc.) so that it isn’t attention-grabbing? Etc.
- _aavaa_ 3y agoI’m not sure how it would all work out. But let’s start where we are now with search engines. Remove the ads and make people pay to use them beyond some number of queries a month. This alone gets rid of the problem of the platform intentionally shoving ads down your throat. Find a shitty website that SEO’d it’s way to the top and got through the cat and mouse game? Then allow people to blacklist websites so they stop appearing in results. Then as the provider investigate and downrank sites that people downrank and block often. Maybe also preferentially treat companies that don’t load their own sites with other people’s ads and tracking scripts. Oh and tell the user how many of those trackers exist on the site. This obviously don’t solve the problem of companies pushing ads onto you. But it: 1. Sets up your information provider to not be the biggest and worse ad pusher of them all. 2. It gives people the tools to start penalizing bad content and ads and to outright block them from their results. This alone, I strongly believe, would be a great improvement.
- eszed 3y ago
- Intermernet 3y agoI recently bought a ski touring pack. It's almost certainly the best pack money can buy. The guy who made it has a waiting list and seems to be happy with his life. He doesn't advertise at all. If you find him, you move in the circles that mean that you want a high quality ski touring pack, and word of mouth will eventually reach you. If you really care about this category of product you can find him. The pack is competitive in price with anything else on the market of similar features and quality. It's not really a "luxury" or "boutique" product. This is an example of how businesses and customers can be perfectly happy without any advertising. It's not the only example, just the first that came to mind.
- jacquesm 3y agoI know a Polish guy that makes sleeping bags along much the same model. Best sleeping bags that you can find. He's got a waiting list longer than a year now and people don't mind. Never a single ad, just word of mouth. And no, it doesn't scale but he couldn't care less.
- salawat 3y agoWanna know how to tell people you did something? Put up a non-intrusive entry in a directory that people would use to reach out to you. Let them come to you. Stop hounding people to be the repeatedly ground in impression by repetition. So much time is wasted today... When I think of all the broadcasting/transmission medium throughput that's eaten up by carrying unsolicited advertisements to people that could either A) be left unused, or used to provide better performance for everyone, or B) utilized for, heaven forbid, the public calling out for proposals from service providers!
- PaulDavisThe1st 3y agoWhile it rings rather hollow at this point, I still find NPR's description of how they differentiate "advertising" from "sponsor messages": - no qualitative adjectives That is, you can say "Foo Corp. makes high speed Gizblams that can help you and your family deal with the challenges of flamming" without it being an ad. BUt if you say "Foo Corp. makes the best anti-flam devices", it's an ad. I mean sure, it's sort of bullshit, but there's some sort of idea buried in there somewhere.
- Waterluvian 3y agoI really like this. There is a huge difference between, “We make Foo. Foo helps you Bar the Baz. Check us out at foobarbaz.com” Vs. “Look at this scary Baz. Feel emotions about it. We want you feeling anxious and ill-equipped. Okay now here’s Foo. We want you feeling better. Nicer music. Smiles. Good emotions from you. What a relief. If you’re tired of being a dumb idiot who suffers from Baz all the time, we can fix you with Foo.”
- IIsi50MHz 3y ago[flagged]
- IIsi50MHz 3y ago[flagged]
- BugsJustFindMe 3y agoHN asks for substantive comments, not memes or internet tropes. HN also asks you not to comment on voting because it's shallow and boring. Written guidelines are here: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- squirtlebonflow 3y agoI'd rather take is a step further: "Foo Corp. makes Gizblams." Whether or not they're high speed depends on the other Gizblam manufacturers, whether or not it can help me or my family depends on if I like it or not.
- alexvoda 3y ago> Or would they spread effectively by word of mouth in the absence of the noise generated by the advertising industry? It is even more complex than that. As it already happens, word of mouth can also be hijacked by advertising resulting MLM pyramid schemes. To bring about such a world we need more than just banning advertising, we need to make it a socially repulsive behaviour.
- salawat 3y agoYou know, we could just bin the entire sector/activity under dishonesty like we did before puffery was enshrined as an acceptable behavior for a business.