3 ms·
Sometimes freedom of speech and the democratic process has to be prioritized over private platform policies. There are large nations where all large mass media
by carlosjobim 3y ago
Sometimes freedom of speech and the democratic process has to be prioritized over private platform policies. There are large nations where all large mass media networks are forced to allow every candidate and party a certain amount of election propaganda on their airwaves, maybe that's an idea to stop this abuse by YouTube and other networks?
- krapp 3y ago>Sometimes freedom of speech and the democratic process has to be prioritized over private platform policies. Freedom of speech is exactly what allows Youtube to decide what speech to allow and what speech to prevent, and under what terms. Forcing a private company to publish speech against its will is the exact opposite of freedom. >There are large nations where all large mass media networks are forced to allow every candidate and party a certain amount of election propaganda on their airwaves, maybe that's an idea to stop this abuse by YouTube and other networks? It isn't abuse. Youtube removed the material because it violated their policies. Also, Youtube isn't a mass media broadcaster. The premise for regulation of broadcast over the electromagnetic spectrum is that useful bandwidth represents a limited resource. The internet isn't a limited resource, there isn't a finite amount of "internet" to be used that Youtube is taking up, so the argument for regulating Youtube as if it were a broadcaster makes no sense.
- carlosjobim 3y agoIf you can't admit that YouTube is a mass media broadcaster, then I feel it's not really an honest discussion. Of course they are, they're huge enough now, they're replacing TV. It doesn't matter that they're a private company. The question of free speech can't be reduced to technicalities. We're all people and we're all smarter than that. First it's YouTube and Facebook censoring, next it's your ISP, next it's your chat apps. And even if you're 100% aligned with their decisions on what should be censored, one day you won't. And then you have no way to be heard.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> If you can't admit that YouTube is a mass media broadcaster Mass media broadcasters also set content policies, and usually are much narrower than YouTube in what they will carry (both as to actual content and provenance.) So, sure what you're point is there, is it now that YT is excessively tolerant rather than too restrictive?
- carlosjobim 3y agoThat is why some democracies force broadcasters to allow all political candidates in an election to get their message through. So the minimum would be to not permit YouTube deleting election propaganda.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Sometimes freedom of speech and the democratic process has to be prioritized over private platform policies. Freedom of speech IS EXACTLY the right of private platforms to set content policies.
- ifyoubuildit 3y agoWhether or not big tech censorship is currently legal, I think a more interesting question is should it be? Should this small handful of unelected people be able to wield so much power over the country? If one of them (or even worse, a few of them in collusion) decided that they wanted a particular outcome in an election, it seems like they'd be pretty well situated to make it happen. This power used to rest with the legacy media companies, but now it's shifting. What's the right thing to allow here (if you pretend for a second that it's up to us)?