2 ms·
It's supposedly a mere slip slope from there to every restaurant and grocer in town refusing to sell food to members of $Disadvantaged_Group, causing them to di
by bell-cot 3y ago
It's supposedly a mere slip slope from there to every restaurant and grocer in town refusing to sell food to members of $Disadvantaged_Group, causing them to die of starvation.
(No, in the actual context, I don't think this ruling is very sensible.)
- infamouscow 3y agoI'd be curious if the people worried about this slippery slope were equally worried about something similar happening with COVID vaccine cards.
- spondylosaurus 3y agoThe Venn diagram of people concerned about discrimination against marginalized groups and people concerned about being asked to get inoculated against an endemic virus is two discrete circles. Also funny how the COVID vaccine card thing never seemed to pan out anyway. I can't remember the last time someone asked me for proof of vaccination...
- kashunstva 3y ago> an endemic virus But COVID-19 wasn’t endemic at the time that proof-of-vaccination requirements were commonplace. An endemic infectious disease has stable low-level incidence within a defined population. Nothing about the early stages of the COVID-19 pandemic when such restrictions were in place fits that description. In any case, I was asked many times for proof of vaccination; but I don’t live in the U.S. so possibly the implementation compliance differed.
- jdlshore 3y agoAsking for proof of vaccination was common here in Portland, toward the NR of the epidemic, when restaurants and venues were opening back up.
- olliej 3y agoAh, I see you're using the false equivalency argument. Should it be considered illegal discrimination to not allow drunks to drive? Should it be considered illegal discrimination to not allow someone with HIV from donating blood? Should it be considered illegal discrimination for a hospital to require licensed doctors?
- infamouscow 3y agoIncorrectly identifying logical fallacies doesn't answer my question. The path arriving to the outcomes is different, but the outcomes are the same. My question is what, exactly, is the distinction because I struggle to see one. More concretely, if someone took a COVID vaccine and had a terrible allergic reaction, doctors will strongly advise against further vaccination. Should that person's immutable physical traits justify discrimination against them?
- olliej 3y ago> More concretely, if someone took a COVID vaccine and had a terrible allergic reaction, doctors will strongly advise against further vaccination. Should that person's immutable physical traits justify discrimination against them? Are there safety concerns? then yes. We don't let people with epilepsy drive, despite that being an immutable characteristic.
- infamouscow 3y agoI think there is a lot of nuance about safety and we probably disagree on the specifics, but I appreciate and thank you for answering and helping elucidate my understanding :)
- mindslight 3y agoNo, it's not a slippery slope. The fundamental concept that our society needs to recover from the corporatist memory hole is that there are drastic differences between various sizes and legal structures of businesses. It's been overwritten by this simplistic distinction of "government xor business", when in reality things like large corporations are closer in functioning and effects to government than they are to individuals. If this particular web design business is a few people and they are all individually refusing to do a certain job, then I'd say this is pretty sensible decision. Whereas if this is a business with many employees (some who likely would do the job), then it would have been sensible to prevent the owners/managers from imposing their personal whims onto the whole group.
- bell-cot 3y ago(I get the sense that you skimmed my response too quickly to notice the second word.)
- mindslight 3y agoHalf that. Half because referencing that other people think it's a slippery slope (even though you seemingly disagree), is also helping to propagate the fallacy of ignoring quantitative differences. When I said "our society" needs to recover it, I mean the legal system as well. As things stand, I can imagine Walmart in court a decade from now arguing that their desire to discriminate is really just a manifestation of the Waltons' individual liberty. Concretely, Citizens United was straight up wrong - a business entity formed by government charter is decidedly not the same as an unincorporated group of people, nor does it preclude the individuals comprising that business from exercising their rights individually apart from that entity. Yet here we are.
- bell-cot 3y ago(Ah. Good thing that I didn't reference Flat Earthers, folks who believe Elvis is still alive, or the army of 8-legged pink polar bears who secretly operate Bernie Sanders' network of brain control space laser satellites, eh?)